Tax cut is good idea, but don’t make it retroactive

Deficit financing of stimulus would be a smart thing to do if our economy needed it, but it’s not clear that it does.

Erasing history seems to be very popular these days. Both ISIS and the Taliban, for example, seem to have a pathological fear of the past that leads them to destroy entire cities and reduce religious architecture to rubble. And in the United States, activists and others from the protest industry not only attack statuary that memorializes our country’s past but also persecute individuals and even horses whose names are reminders of our past.

The U.S. Congress has its own way of monkeying with the past. It’s called ex post facto legislation — in plain language, a law that takes effect retroactively — and initially usually involves nothing more complicated than passing a law that goes into effect at some earlier date. Whether the law is Constitutional, though, is complicated enough to satisfy any real or armchair litigant.

It appears that Congress, to ease the deadline pressures on itself, is considering just such an ex post facto law for its tax cut and tax reform bill, making its provisions retroactive from January 1, 2017. It really isn’t a good idea.

The Constitution specifically prohibits Congress from passing retroactive laws, but an early U.S. Supreme Court ruling (in Calder v. Bull, 1798) found that the prohibition applies only to criminal, not civil, laws.

Not everyone agreed with the court, and some notable figures such as Thomas Jefferson and James Madison believed that the Constitutional prohibition against retroactive laws by Congress applied equally to both civil and criminal legislation. But the Supreme Court’s 1798 opinion has survived several challenges and remains the guideline.

Samuel Chase, the Chief Justice in the case, was a brilliant, if occasionally imaginative, jurist. Over 200 years later, his opinions still manage to provide fuel for both sides of the Constitutional interpretation argument that is burning in American politics and judicial appointments: strict interpretation and liberal reading.

We might think that since the Internal Revenue Code invokes specific criminal penalties for noncompliance, it could reasonably be considered a criminal law when it suddenly transforms compliance into noncompliance by rewriting history.

A retroactive increase in income tax rates, or voiding of deductions, could place some taxpayers in immediate criminal violation of the law, unless Congress covers that issue somehow in its tax reform language.

There is an economic impact to making the tax reform bill retroactive, also.

The individual tax portion of the tax reform bill, at least as it is currently being described as retroactive, would essentially be an unfunded economic stimulus program. Much of the personal income tax is deducted from paychecks, and therefore individual taxes would have been overpaid because they were based on now incorrect, higher tax rates.

The Treasury will have to refund that money to taxpayers, and that will blow a hole in the federal budget and increase the deficit.

The theoretical basis for reducing tax rates is that it will stimulate economic growth and result in higher tax revenue. The accounting problem is that even if everything works out as planned, the deficit is “now” while the offsetting tax revenue collection is in the future. Of the available economic stimulus options, tax rate reductions have a near-immediate effect. That is a distinct advantage over, say, infrastructure spending, which can take years for its full economic impact to be felt.

The timing disadvantage would be worsened if the tax reductions are given a year’s head start by making them retroactive. It is one more expenditure of funds at a time when the budget is being battered by necessary storm recovery, a buildup of military capabilities made necessary by increased security threats, and the rebuilding of our neglected, and sometimes unsafe, infrastructure.

Deficit financing of an economic stimulus would be a smart thing to do if the economy needed it, but it is not clear that our economy really does. A year ago would have been a different matter, but as things stand now the economy is growing twice as fast as it had been, on average, for the past eight or ten years. It would seem that the reduction in interest rates would be stimulus enough — by itself, without being retroactive.

In an article in the Wisconsin Law Review, Even C. Zoldan wrote regarding the prohibitions of retroactive legislation in the U.S. Constitution that, “It is beyond dispute that these clauses spring from a deeply held aversion to retroactivity.” While it is equally beyond doubt that people would look forward to a one-time, fatter tax refund check, their passion for lower taxes will be just as strong when their take-home pay is larger next year. The Congress should consider the “deeply held aversion to retroactivity” and the dubious economics of a retroactive tax bill when it drafts our much-needed tax reform bill.

James McCusker is a Bothell economist, educator and consultant.

Talk to us

More in Herald Business Journal

Demolition of the YMCA in downtown continues on Tuesday, April 13, 2021 in Everett, Wa. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Apartments will rise from the site of the former YMCA annex

In all, 260 units are planned for the downtown Everett site. The older brick building will remain.

Signs from the Department of Ecology warning about contamination in the creek that runs through Powder Mill Gulch on Wednesday, March 31, 2021 in Everett, Wa. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
State order targets Boeing Everett plant’s polluted history

Records show a dispute over cleanup requirements for chemically tainted water. The company denies there’s a disagreement.

FILE - In this Oct. 1, 2020 file photo, traffic passes the Boeing airplane production plant, in Everett, Wash.  U.S. manufacturers expanded in March 2021 at the fastest pace in 37 years, a sign of strengthening demand as the pandemic wanes and government emergency aid flows through the economy.  (AP Photo/Elaine Thompson, file)
Boeing sees uptick in airplane orders as travel picks up

The company in April delivered 19 Maxes, three 737s for military use and seven larger widebody planes.

FILE- In this Sept. 30, 2020, file photo, a Boeing 737 Max jet, piloted by Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) chief Steve Dickson, prepares to land at Boeing Field following a test flight in Seattle. Boeing says it has informed 16 of its customers that they should address a possible electrical issue in certain 737 Max aircraft before using them further. Boeing said Friday, April 9, 2021, that the recommendation was made “to allow for verification that a sufficient ground path exists for a component of the electrical power system.” (AP Photo/Elaine Thompson, File)
Boeing: possible electrical issue in some 737 Max aircraft

The company said that the new problem was unrelated to the flight-control system.

The 214-foot tall cranes work to unload their first cargo shipments at South Terminal at the Port of Everett on Thursday, April 8, 2021 in Everett, Wa. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Renovated Port of Everett terminal gets first cargo customer

The 655-foot Westwood Columbia is the first ship to call at the newly upgraded South Terminal dock.

Project Roxy is a proposed 2.8 million square foot distribution center that would be built on a 75-acre parcel at the Cascade Industrial Center. The rendering depicts the proposed project at 4620 172nd Street in Arlington from a northwest perspective.
1,000 jobs: Amazon to open distribution center in Arlington

The company is the tenant behind Project Roxy, a $355 million building at the Cascade Industrial Center.

Edmonds grocery store workers may soon earn hazard pay

Some employers are required to increase wages by $4 an hour, the city council voted Tuesday.

Aerospace supplier with Everett site files for bankruptcy

Wichita-based TECT Aerospace filed for Chapter 11 and plans to sell an Everett manufacturing facility.

Washington's Lottery ticket display. (Andrea Brown / The Herald)
Want to get lucky? Washington’s Lottery lists Top 10 stores

One of the luckiest retailers in the state was a Safeway in Everett, as measured by $1,000-plus winners.

What local firms are doing to promote diversity and equity

Here’s how some of Snohomish County’s biggest companies and organizations say they are making a difference.

Garry Clark, the new CEO of Economic Alliance Snohomish County (Kevin Clark / The Herald)
At a tough time, a new CEO leads local economic development

Garry Clark has taken the helm at Economic Alliance Snohomish County, where job one is pandemic recovery.

Kathy Coffey (left) and Courtney Wooten
Leadership Snohomish County offers racial equity conference

The fifth annual day-long Step Up: Moving Racial Equity Forward will be held online on April 30.