Autumn Covington makes all of the bakehouse’s six-ounce cookies. (Rachel Rosen / Whidbey News-Times)

Autumn Covington makes all of the bakehouse’s six-ounce cookies. (Rachel Rosen / Whidbey News-Times)

Cookie shop stirs up excitement on Whidbey Island

A new family-owned business in downtown Oak Harbor has been whisking up quite a buzz lately.

OAK HARBOR — A new family-owned business in downtown Oak Harbor has been whisking up quite a buzz lately, often selling out within hours of opening.

The Mad Batter Bakehouse makes decadent six-ounce cookies and other handmade baked goods. The thick, cake-like cookies are made with real butter and come in such varieties as “mudslide” (dark chocolate with peanut butter chips) and “wonderland” (birthday cake flavored dough with golden Oreo and white chocolate chunks and rainbow sprinkles). The flavors of cookies for sale are rotated every few days.

The bakehouse had a soft opening on Sept. 1 and sold out in an hour and a half. It was open during the Oak Harbor Music Festival and owner Natalie Covington said there was a line out the door the whole weekend. She said they even had to shut down a few times just to bake more cookies and restock.

“It was so overwhelming the support that Oak Harbor gave us,” she said. “What a welcome, that’s all I’m going to say, what a welcome. ”

Natalie owns the shop with her cousin Buck Galbreath, her daughters Asianna and Autumn and son Christian Covington, who plays in the NFL for the Los Angeles Chargers. The defensive tackle was signed to the active roster this week.

“Off-season you guys will see a lot of him because he plans to be here,” Natalie said, adding that he’ll be training on the beach and then treating himself with Mad Batter baked goods.

The family is originally from Vancouver, Canada and were previously living in Texas, where Christian was playing for the Houston Texans. Natalie said their dream was to come back to the Northwest.

“We came through here and said, ‘Do places like this really exist anymore?’” she said. “We just fell in love. We fell in love with Oak Harbor and the people were so pleasant.”

The Alice and mudslide cookies made by Mad Batter Bakehouse. (Rachel Rosen / Whidbey News-Times)

The Alice and mudslide cookies made by Mad Batter Bakehouse. (Rachel Rosen / Whidbey News-Times)

The family, which has a long tradition of baking, uses family recipes that have been passed down through the generations. Natalie said her aunt and her husband’s mother were extremely talented bakers. The talent was apparently passed down to Asianna and Autumn, who are often asked by friends and family to bake for holidays and parties.

During the pandemic, the cookie-making family began hand-pouring organic candles because Natalie was getting congested because of an allergic reaction to store-bought candles. They started selling the candles and baked goods at farmer’s markets.

“It’s just taken off like crazy,” Natalie said.

The handmade candles are for sale in the store, along with ice cream and specialty drinks, including coffee, lemonade and plant-based energy drinks.

For October, Asianna and Autumn will be making an abundance of apple, pumpkin and sweet potato recipes. For the last two weeks of the month, they plan to have a Harry Potter theme in the shop. They also plan to add vegan items to the menu.

“Stressful but worth it,” Asianna said when asked what it’s been like to open the business. “It’s a lot of stress but it’s a lot of fun.”

She said she is hoping to turn the bakehouse into a place where people can hang out after they’ve ordered their food. It is sleekly designed, outfitted in black and gold furniture. Customers have already been asking about renting out the shop to host private parties.

Mad Batter Bakehouse is located at 800 SE Pioneer Way and is open from 11 a.m. to 7 p.m. Monday through Saturday.

This story originally appeared in the Whidbey News-Times, a sister publication to The Herald.

Talk to us

More in Food & Drink

The butter chicken at 5 Rivers Indian Cuisine in Everett is a bestseller. Wednesday, Sept. 21, 2022. (Taylor Goebel / The Herald)
5 Rivers Indian Cuisine, Tía Lety reopen in Everett after devastating fire

The Snohomish County dining scene regained the Indian and Mexican eateries in September.

A sign celebrating the hop harvest is seen outside Carpenter Ranches hop farm in Granger. (Photo courtesy of R.J. Whitlow, owner and head brewer at 5 Rights Brewing)
Hop season is here. So is fresh, locally brewed craft beer.

Our resident craft beer expert rounded up a list of fresh hop beers hitting the taps soon.

New Snohomish County eateries: A sneak peek of upcoming restaurants

Check out The Daily Herald’s list of upcoming restaurants in Snohomish County.

This cozy white chicken chili is perfect for transitioning into fall while fresh corn is still available locally. (Photo courtesy of Aimee Heriard-Dubreuil)
Cozy white chicken chili with a summery twist

This recipe is perfect for transitioning into fall while fresh corn is still available locally.

Ruse Brewing Insulator IPA, Wayfinder Hell Lager and Zoiglhaus Zopo Italian Pilsner at Josh’s Taps & Caps on Monday, July 18, 2022 in Snohomish, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Old-school lagers, freshened for the craft-beer generation

Beer lovers asked for elevated versions of the brews their dads drank, and Snohomish County beermakers answered

Shrimp “Poor Boy” Sandwich from Daiane Lasswell, Quil Ceda Creek Casino
This Big Easy delicacy boasts balanced flavors with a kick

Classic “Poor Boy” sandwich is rich on history and flavor, with ingredients shared by our region and Bourbon Street

Bulkogi Stew, a mixture of beef steak, potato starch noodles, green onions and broth, is enjoyed as part of the Korean harvest festival, Chuseok. (Photo by Tressa Dale/Peninsula Clarion)
A hearty Korean stew to celebrate harvest and loved ones

This savory Bulkogi stew is perfect for drizzly fall weather in Alaska or the Pacific Northwest.

Food forum
Meaty pasta bundt bake for your next Sunday dinner

This pasta bake yields a ring of fettuccine with Italian sausage, pepperoni, cheese and more.

Jordan and Brandon Molina at the newly opened Peace of Mind Brewing Tuesday afternoon in Lynnwood, Washington on September 13, 2022. (Kevin Clark / The Herald)
New Lynnwood brewery opens at former Cask & Trotter location

Peace of Mind Brewing is filling a craft beer void in south Snohomish County.

The St. John II, is unloaded at Home Port Seafoods in Bellingham, Washington on April 15, 2022. (Kevin Clark / The Herald)
From sea to table: How sustainably-caught halibut ends up on your plate

A fourth-generation fishing family from Snohomish shares the perils, triumphs and realities of catching their livelihood.

Autumn Covington makes all of the bakehouse's six-ounce cookies. (Rachel Rosen/Whidbey News-Times)
Cookie shop stirs up excitement on Whidbey Island

A new family-owned business in downtown Oak Harbor has been whisking up quite a buzz lately.

The queso birria tacos at El Mariachi call for slow cooked brisket, melty cheese sandwiched between two corn tortillas, a shower of cilantro and bright pink pickled onions, and a bowl of consomé. Thursday, Sept. 8, 2022. (Taylor Goebel / The Herald)
El Mariachi opens Everett restaurant, promising everlasting birria tacos

Your favorite taco truck has a new, permanent home right on Evergreen Way.