Friend wants honest feedback about creepy new flame

Carolyn Hax is away. The following is from June 29, 2003.

Dear Carolyn:

I have a friend who came out of the closet and moved from a creepy husband (alcohol, crawly hands, very parental, controlling) straight to a live-in girlfriend with a similar personality. It’s kind of like the husband had a sex change. I know that what my friend goes for is not my business, even if it makes me worry. But lately, every time I see her, she asks me if I like her girlfriend. And since I don’t, I’ve evaded the question or lied outright. I don’t think I should insult my friend’s girlfriend. But now she’s reminded me that her friends never liked her husband, either, and didn’t say so until after she’d broken up with him; she’d never have stayed with him if she’d been given honest feedback. She has asked, openly, for me to give her my honest opinion. Should I?

— Seeing a Pattern

Yes, absolutely — about everything but the girlfriend.

You don’t have to like your friends’ mates. But you do like your friends, and for that reason alone any friend who seeks your opinion deserves more than your careful evasions. (Even people you dislike deserve better than outright lies.)

Plus, as a friend, you’re in a position — close, but not too close — to see things she might have missed.

The trick is to skip the pointless “nope, can’t stand her” and the insensitive “it’s kind of like your husband had a sex change” and stick to what counts, which is whether she’s happy.

If she were, she wouldn’t be fishing for feedback. You can say that to her — and that you’re worried, and that her love dynamic seems awfully familiar, and that you’re deliberately not saying anything about her girlfriend, since you’re right: It isn’t your business.

Which brings us to the sum of all honest opinions: She shouldn’t count so much on friends to form her opinions. How does she know “she’d never have stayed” had her friends been honest? Because she already had major doubts of her own, apparently.

It’s one thing for her to solicit outside perspectives; it’s quite another to grill everybody she knows till she gets the answer she wants.

If her instincts are telling her once again that something’s not right at home, then the better answer is to trust them.

Dear Carolyn:

What’s wrong with asking a girl out when she has a boyfriend? Two girls I know seem to think it would be inconsiderate. But I see girls going out with losers all the time — because they’re afraid of being alone, think they can’t do any better, believe the guys still “love” them even if the guys have cheated, etc. If the relationship is worth it, she’d simply decline, right?

— Dan

Right. But then you’d have a girl who’s insecure, desperate or naive. That’s the real problem — unless you plan to (swoon) rescue her, which is worse.

Otherwise, go for it, but with a nod to her status: “If it’s not inappropriate, I’d like to ask you out.”