Everett officer didn’t act in self-defense, jury decides

EVERETT — A Snohomish County jury’s verdict on Tuesday against an Everett police officer acquitted of murder may have created more questions than the decision answered.

Jurors on Tuesday found that Everett police officer Troy Meade didn’t prove that he shot Niles Meservey in self-defense. Those same jurors on Monday acquitted Meade of second-degree murder and first-degree manslaughter.

The two verdicts seemingly send a mixed message about what jurors believe happened on June 10 outside the Chuckwagon Inn. One lawyer involved with the case suggested the verdicts likely reflected the differing laws governing the legal questions jurors had to answer.

Tuesday’s ruling means Meade’s legal expenses won’t be reimbursed, an option under state law when somebody is acquitted of criminal charges after making a self-defense claim.

Meade on Tuesday again told reporters he wants to get back to work. He remains on paid administrative leave and has yet to discuss his return with his supervisors.

Meanwhile Everett officials declined to discuss the verdicts or if they will have any bearing on Meade’s future as an Everett police officer. They remained silent at the insistence of a civil attorney hired to represent the city in a $15 million lawsuit filed on behalf of Meservey’s daughter.

Some in the legal field say it may not be that easy for Meade to again patrol Everett streets.

Ed Budge, a Seattle attorney well-known for winning multimillion-dollar settlements in police misconduct cases, said he wasn’t surprised that the jury acquitted Meade on criminal charges.

Given the dangerous job of a police officer, it’s very hard for juries to convict an officer of a crime beyond a reasonable doubt, Budge said.

“Just because he’s been cleared of criminal wrongdoing doesn’t mean there was no wrongdoing,” Budge said. “He may well have violated Mr. Meservey’s constitutional rights” and department policy.

City officials now should conduct their own investigation to determine if Meade should be allowed to return to work, Budge said.

“The department needs to make up its own mind about whether that policeman acted appropriately,” the attorney said.

The police department hasn’t conducted an internal investigation regarding Meade.

City officials have repeatedly declined to discuss whether they believe Meade’s conduct was in accordance with department policies. They also have declined to say if they’ve made any changes in how they train police officers to handle drunken suspects, or if they’ve changed how they counsel officers involved in shootings. They’ve been mum on whether they’ve taken any steps to minimize the potential for another shooting like the one involving Meservey.

Jurors on Tuesday declined to be interviewed by reporters gathered at the courthouse.

One juror would only say that the decisions were not easy to make. The jurors also brushed past legal staff from the city of Everett who are preparing to fight the $15 million lawsuit over Meservey’s death.

Those city attorneys had asked to join an interview of the jurors by prosecutors and Meade’s defense counsel, but were rebuffed.

The majority of the jury on Tuesday decided that Meade’s shooting of Meservey did not meet the legal definition of self defense.

Under jury instructions, the key question they answered was “Did the defendant, Troy Meade, prove by a preponderance of the evidence that the use of force was lawful?

Meade’s defense was based in part on his belief that he was properly using force to defend himself and others.

Meade said he was disappointed by Tuesday’s decision but still grateful the jury earlier acquitted him of criminal charges.

“I want to thank the jury for the decision. I respect that,” he said.

Snohomish County deputy prosecutor Matthew Baldock and a lawyer representing Meade spoke privately with jurors after they were excused and thanked for their service by Superior Court Judge Gerald Knight.

Baldock made it clear he wasn’t speaking for the jurors. He said it was evident jurors understood the different legal standards that needed to be applied to the evidence at each stage of the case.

In the criminal trial they had to determine if Meade was justified in shooting because he felt his life was threatened. In the second phase of the trial, which began after they acquitted Meade, civil legal rules prevailed. The definition of a “justified” use of force was different.

Jurors were instructed to apply an objective standard, meaning whether a “reasonably prudent person, under the same or similar conditions existing at the time of the incident, would have used the same degree of force” as Meade.

In the criminal phase of the trial, the standard was subjective, meaning what Meade perceived was most important. At that stage of the case, jurors also were instructed that actual danger was not necessary to find Meade’s actions justified.

Baldock said it was fair to say that the jury gave careful consideration to the difference between what Meade thought he saw and the reality of what unfolded outside the Chuckwagon Inn.

“I think we see that reflected in their verdicts,” he said.

During the criminal phase of the trial, jurors needed to reach a unanimous verdict to decide the case. They voted 12-0 to acquit Meade on both counts, second-degree murder and first-degree manslaughter.

Jurors didn’t have to reach a unanimous verdict in the civil phase of the trial. They needed just 10 votes. It was an 11-1 split against Meade’s self-defense claim after several hours of deliberation. The jurors also were told to decide the issue based on a preponderance of the evidence. That means they believed their finding about what happened was more likely than not.

In the criminal trial, the standard of proof was higher — beyond a reasonable doubt. Meade was presumed innocent, and prosecutors had the burden of proof.

In the civil phase, Meade shouldered the burden of proof and had to demonstrate his actions were justified.

If the lawsuit filed against Everett goes to trial, civil rules and standards of proof will apply.

“The Everett jury’s finding (Tuesday) that officer Troy Meade did not act in self defense is consistent with our position in the civil damage case. We are confident that the jury in the family’s civil case will come to the same conclusion,” said Seattle attorney Paul Luvera, who filed the lawsuit against the city and Meade.

Seattle University law professor John Strait said the Snohomish County jury faced a difficult decision. Ultimately self-defense cases require jurors to determine what happened.

“It’s a tough line for anyone to draw,” Strait said.

Strait didn’t attend Meade’s trial, but he followed it closely.

“The case was reasonably well tried by both sides, and the jury made a difficult decision,” he said.

Diana Hefley: 425-339-3463, hefley@heraldnet.com.

Talk to us

More in Local News

An example of the Malicious Women Co. products (left) vs. the Malicious Mermaid's products (right). (U.S. District Court in Florida)
Judge: Cheeky candle copycat must pay Snohomish company over $800K

The owner of the Malicious Women Co. doesn’t expect to receive any money from the Malicious Mermaid, a Florida-based copycat.

A grave marker for Blaze the horse. (Photo provided)
After Darrington woman’s horse died, she didn’t know what to do

Sidney Montooth boarded her horse Blaze. When he died, she was “a wreck” — and at a loss as to what to do with his remains.

A fatal accident the afternoon of Dec. 18 near Clinton ended with one of the cars involved bursting into flames. The driver of the fully engulfed car was outside of the vehicle by the time first responders arrived at the scene. (Whidbey News-Times/Submitted photo)
Driver sentenced in 2021 crash that killed Everett couple

Danielle Cruz, formerly of Lynnwood, gets 17½ years in prison. She was impaired by drugs when she caused the crash that killed Sharon Gamble and Kenneth Weikle.

A person walks out of the Everett Clinic on Thursday, Sept. 7, 2023 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
The Everett Clinic changing name to parent company Optum in 2024

The parent company says the name change will not affect quality of care for patients in Snohomish County.

Tirhas Tesfatsion (GoFundMe) 20210727
Lynnwood settles for $1.7 million after 2021 suicide at city jail

Jail staff reportedly committed 16 safety check violations before they found Tirhas Tesfatsion, 47, unresponsive in her cell.

A semi-truck rolled over blocking all traffic lanes Thursday morning on I-5 north just south of Arlington on Sept. 21, 2023. (Washington State Patrol)
Overturned trailer spills fish onto I-5 near Arlington, closing lanes

The crash blocked all lanes, forcing drivers going north during rush hour to use the left shoulder.

The Marysville Municipal Jail is pictured Thursday, Sept. 14, 2023, in Marysville, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Marysville weighs mandatory jail time for repeated ‘public disorder’

The “three strikes” proposal sets a minimum sentence of 30 days in jail for crimes like public drug use and trespassing.

Everett police on patrol heard gunshots near 26th Street and Lombard Avenue and closed off multiple roads as they investigated on Wednesday, Sept. 20, 2023. (Everett Police Department)
3 teens arrested after gunfire in downtown Everett

No one was injured. Police heard gunfire in the area of 26th Street and Lombard Avenue.

It’s time to celebrate and say thanks

Local journalism — and community support — will be the stars of Behind the News Stories on Oct. 24 in Edmonds.

Most Read