Judge asked to cut number of Growler flights on Whidbey Island

The state Attorney General’s Office is asking a judge to require the Navy to cut number of flights.

Logo for news use featuring Whidbey Island in Island County, Washington. 220118

WHIDBEY ISLAND — The state Attorney General’s Office and a Whidbey Island anti-noise group are asking a federal judge to require the Navy to cut the number of training flights back to the level allowed prior to an environmental assessment process that authorized an additional 33 EA-18G Growlers at Naval Air Station Whidbey Island.

Earlier this year, the state Attorney General’s Office and Citizens of Ebey’s Reserve, or COER, partially succeeded in their lawsuit against the Navy over the adequacy of the environmental assessment, which looked at what impact the noise from additional Growlers and increased practices would have on residents and the environment.

In August, a federal judge ruled against the Navy on four issues and instructed both sides to work out a remedy. Negotiations fell through, however, and now it falls on the court to decide the issue.

Both the state Attorney General’s Office and COER submitted briefs on the proposed remedy. Both argue that the Navy should be compelled to vacate the 2019 Record of Decision, which authorized the increase in Growlers, and prepare a supplemental Environmental Impact Statement on the issues that weren’t adequately addressed.

If the judge agrees, that would mean a significant — although possibly temporary — reduction in Growler operations on Whidbey, especially at Outlying Field Coupeville where the hours of aircraft activity would drop to a quarter of the current amount of aircraft landing practice allowed. Currently, the Navy can conduct 360 hours per year of landing practice.

In his decision, U.S. District Court Judge Richard Jones agreed with the Attorney General’s Office that the Navy violated the National Environmental Policy Act by failing to quantify the impact of Growler noise on classroom learning and failing to take a hard look at species-specific impacts on birds.

In addition, the judge agreed with COER’s argument that the Navy erred in failing to give detailed consideration to basing the Growlers at El Centro, California and failing to disclose the basis for greenhouse gas emission calculations.

The two plaintiffs want the Navy to set aside the Record of Decision and go back to the drawing board on the flawed portions of the environmental study. After that, Navy leaders would then have adequate information to decide what would be the appropriate level of Growlers and flights on Whidbey.

The attorney general opined that the Navy top brass may make a different decision.

“A lawful environmental review of childhood learning impacts, species-specific bird impacts, greenhouse gas emissions, and an alternative training location could lead the Navy to, among other things, adopt a different alternative, reduce or shift flight operations, alter flight patterns or training schedules, or implement additional mitigation measures,” the brief states.

The Navy has until Nov. 22 to respond.

This story originally appeared in the South Whidbey Record, a sibling publication to The Herald.

Talk to us

More in Local News

Construction continues at the site of the Lake Stevens Costco now slated to open Dec. 2. (Andrea Brown / The Herald)
Lake Stevens’ new Costco opening delayed till after Thanksgiving

The new warehouse opening was pushed back to Dec. 2. Meanwhile, it’s still under construction.

x
Pedestrian hit, hospitalized after crash on Highway 99 in Edmonds

The person was crossing the highway near 238th Street SW. The driver stayed and cooperated with officers, per Edmonds PD.

Cars drive along 76th Avenue West in front of Edmonds-Woodway High School on Friday, Nov. 18, 2022 in Edmonds, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Edmonds eyes speed cameras near three schools

Roads near Edmonds-Woodway High, Chase Lake Elementary and Westgate Elementary could get automated enforcement.

Shoppers walk in and out of Macy’s at Alderwood Mall were Black Friday deals are being advertised on Thursday, Nov. 17, 2022 in Lynnwood, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Go ahead, hit snooze: Most Black Friday deals are online

Braving the stores on Black Friday is still a thing, but more retailers are closed on Thanksgiving.

The Smith Ave homelessness camp Thursday afternoon in Everett on March 11, 2021. (Kevin Clark / The Herald)
Audit: Snohomish County lacks data-driven approach to homeless services

The Washington State Auditor’s Office this month published a 73-page report looking into four local governments across the state.

Logo for news use featuring Snohomish County, Washington. 220118
New director named for county’s Department of Emergency Managment

After six years, Jason Biermann has stepped aside but will stay in Snohomish County. Lucia Schmit will move in from Seattle.

(Dutton)
Pulitzer winner’s new book digs into Snohomish County cold case killings

The Everett library will host a talk with Edward Humes on “The Forever Witness,” about a double murder and pioneering DNA evidence.

Lawmakers meet on the Senate floor, Thursday, March 10, 2022, at the Capitol in Olympia, Wash. Washington lawmakers were wrapping up their work Thursday with final votes on a supplemental state budget and a transportation revenue package before planning to adjourn the legislative session. (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren)
Crime, climate, abortion on docket in legislative session warm-up

Washington lawmakers will hold 39 hearings this week. Nearly all will be conducted in person, which hasn’t happened in three years.

Detonators seized from Jeffrey Carlton's vehicle in Everett in May. (U.S. Attorney's Office)
Man caught with illegal explosives in Everett sentenced to time served

Jeffrey Carlton has had a lifelong interest in explosives. He pleaded guilty to unlawfully owning them.

Most Read