Snohomish County wins key battle in Oso mudslide lawsuit

OSO — A King County judge this week significantly reduced the ability of people harmed in the Oso mudslide to claim Snohomish County officials failed to adequately warn them of the risks connected to where they made their homes.

In a written ruling Monday, King County Superior Court Judge Roger Rogoff held that only those who attended a March 2006 meeting, or those “who relied on the substance” of information shared at that meeting, can press claims that they were insufficiently warned.

Snohomish County officials called the 2006 meeting with people who lived in the Steelhead Haven neighborhood to discuss flooding and other risks after a slide blocked the North Fork Stillaguamish River that year.

Plaintiffs’ lawyers contend the county called the meeting to warn about landslide risks. The county, meanwhile, claims that people at the meeting were told the government no longer would provide them with protection from likely future flooding. It also asserts that landslide activity linked to that flooding was unpredictable.

The law is clear that the county only can be held responsible for what it promised to do, Rogoff ruled.

“No evidence exists that the county promised to monitor the slide, further investigate the slide or do any other act that would enhance its warning abilities,” the judge wrote. “The county owed no duty to engage in further affirmative acts to improve its ability to warn. Rather, the county owed a duty to adequately warn the residents of Steelhead Haven based upon the information they had at the time they affirmatively acted to do so.”

In all, 43 people were killed and dozens of others injured in March 2014 when a wall of mud and trees raced across the Stillaguamish River valley.

Lawyers representing the families of those harmed have argued that county officials knew, or should have known, that the hillside above Steelhead Haven was dangerously unstable. Key to their claim are numerous studies of slides at the site, some dating back decades.

The county has countered that none of the reports gave them a clear warning that the hillside was poised to collapse in 2014 with such disastrous consequences. Moreover, the county and other parties being sued contend there was more opinion than science behind one expert’s 1999 report that hinted at the potential for a huge slide.

The Oso litigation is believed to be the state’s largest-ever wrongful death case. Karen Willie, one of the attorneys representing the plaintiffs’ families, declined to talk about the implications of this week’s ruling.

“I am not comfortable discussing a judge’s order when there’s active litigation,” Willie said.

Earlier in June, the judge ruled that the county, state and a timber company being sued in the case may ask jurors to consider that the disaster was an “act of God,” and that those harmed may also bear some responsibility through contributory negligence.

Trial in the case is set for fall.

Attorneys for the state and county earlier asked for more time to consider the results of drilling that state experts conducted over the past year in an effort to better understand the geology of the hillside and how water moved through the ground. The work has raised questions about some widely held theories, including the suggestion that logging over the years was a primary reason that water saturated the hillside and triggered a collapse.

Scientific examinations of the area since the 2014 slide paint a complex picture, including signs that similar giant slides have occurred repeatedly in that valley since the Ice Age.

Scott North: 425-339-3431; Twitter: @snorthnews.

Talk to us

More in Local News

FILE - Former President Donald J. Trump watches the NCAA Wrestling Championships, Saturday, March 18, 2023, in Tulsa, Okla. (AP Photo/Sue Ogrocki, File)
Lawyer: Trump indicted, 1st ex-president charged with crime

Former president Donald Trump has been indicted on charges in New York regarding payments made during the 2016 presidential campaign to silence claims of an extramarital sexual encounter.

Jeanette Westover poses for a photo at her home in Snohomish, Washington on Tuesday, March 28, 2023. (Annie Barker / The Herald)
Tenant: Housing Hope ignored meth contamination at Snohomish apartment

Jeanette Westover says meth contamination far exceeding state limits gave her seizures and kidney infections.

Logo for news use featuring the municipality of Snohomish in Snohomish County, Washington. 220118
Police investigating cause of fatal 3-vehicle crash on Highway 9

The man, 61, crossed the center line in Snohomish on Monday and crashed into the truck, the sheriff’s office said.

Logo for news use featuring the municipality of Snohomish in Snohomish County, Washington. 220118
1 dead, 1 in hospital after 3-vehicle crash on Highway 9

A concrete pumping truck and two sedans crashed Monday afternoon, closing the highway near Bickford Avenue.

Moses Malachi Brewer appears in court for sentencing Friday, March 24, 2023, at Snohomish County Superior Court in Everett, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Man sentenced to 18 years for 2019 shooting in Everett

Moses Brewer, 23, shot four people in an Everett apartment, which left one victim paralyzed on his right side.

Logo for news use, for stories regarding Washington state government — Olympia, the Legislature and state agencies. No caption necessary. 20220331
Health care spending continues to outpace inflation, driven by prices

Can state efforts curb 6.7% growth per year in overall health care spending?

NO CAPTION NECESSARY: Logo for the Cornfield Report by Jerry Cornfield. 20200112
A buffet of budgets, a bunch of whales and a request for your miles

It’s Day 78. Here’s what’s happening in the 2023 session of the Washington Legislature

Deputy prosecutor Craig Matheson makes closing arguments in the trial of Richard Rotter at the Snohomish County Courthouse on Friday, March 31, 2023 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Jury still deliberating in trial of Everett cop’s killing

Jurors deliberated for just over three hours Friday with no verdict on the aggravated murder charge for Richard Rotter.

NO CAPTION NECESSARY: Logo for the Cornfield Report by Jerry Cornfield. 20200112
A tax hike, a difficult compromise and a faulty Predict A Pen

It’s Day 82. Here’s what’s happening in the 2023 session of the Washington Legislature

Most Read