A car registration tab is shown on a vehicle parked at the Capitol on Wednesday in Olympia. (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren)

A car registration tab is shown on a vehicle parked at the Capitol on Wednesday in Olympia. (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren)

State high court upholds Sound Transit vehicle excise tax

Taxpayers sued to erase the increase for ST3 and to secure hundreds of million of dollars in refunds.

OLYMPIA — The state Supreme Court delivered a huge win to Sound Transit on Thursday, upholding provisions of a law that allows the regional transit authority to collect hundreds of millions of dollars in vehicle-license taxes that voters approved in 2016 for mass transit.

In a 7-2 decision, the court concluded that while the law references two different depreciation schedules drafted years apart, it “properly adopts both schedules” and “does not require a reader to conduct research” to figure out which will be in force.

“We hold the MVET statute is constitutional,” wrote Justice Susan Owens for the majority, referring to the motor vehicle excise tax.

Justices were considering the case of seven residents, including three from Snohomish County, who sought to erase the rate hike — approved by voters to pay for the $54 billion Sound Transit 3 expansion — and refund hundreds of millions of dollars collected from it thus far.

“Obviously it is a disappointing result for us,” said Attorney Joel Ard of Bainbridge Island, who represented the taxpayers.

Sound Transit attorneys had said that rolling back the fee would have resulted in the loss of billions of dollars in collections and a “drastic impact” on the authority’s ability to build voter-approved ST3 projects. That threat is now gone.

“We are pleased with the decision,” said Sound Transit spokesman Geoff Patrick. “We are pleased the court held that the depreciation schedule to be used was readily ascertainable from reading the statute.”

Sound Transit 3 aims to build 62 miles of new light rail, reaching Everett, Tacoma, new neighborhoods in Seattle and fast-growing cities to the east, including Kirkland and Redmond. It passed on the strength of support in Snohomish and King counties. It was rejected by voters in Pierce County.

Part of the plan’s financing package includes a 0.8% increase in the excise tax rate — from 0.3% to 1.1%.

Sound Transit calibrates car-tab fees using that excise tax rate and a vehicle depreciation schedule drawn up in the late 1990s that overvalues vehicles. In 2006, lawmakers drew up a new depreciation schedule that better reflects a car’s actual value.

A 2015 law that enabled Sound Transit to put its expansion plan on the ballot also permitted the transit agency to keep using the older vehicle valuation schedule until 2028. That’s when original bonds sold using the older valuation are scheduled to expire. At that point, Sound Transit is required to switch to the other depreciation schedule.

The plaintiff taxpayers argued that the rise in the MVET rate approved by voters must be repealed because that 2015 law was unconstitutional.

They contended it violated a provision which, in pursuit of clarity, calls for changes in existing law to be spelled out “at full length.” In this case, lawmakers should have included the complete text of the depreciation schedules but did not.

The law “provided inadequate guidance to legislators, voters, and future taxpayers of the taxes authorized by this statute,” the plaintiffs argued in court papers. And, they wrote, “even the most diligent search” would not reveal the actual valuation schedule to be used by Sound Transit.

But the court rejected those arguments.

“The MVET statute specifically states in which circumstance each depreciation schedule will apply,” Owens wrote. “It does not matter if the legislature set forth two depreciation schedules for different circumstances and made the current depreciation schedule inapplicable for a period of time because it remains clear to the reader when each depreciation schedule will apply, and that is what article II, section 37 requires. Because the legislature clearly laid out when each schedule will apply, there is no confusion or ambiguity arising from the text of the statute itself.”

Two Supreme Court justices signed a strongly worded dissent. The law’s failure to include the depreciation schedules and its incorporation of material from existing and outdated statutes creates confusion, not the clarity demanded by the state’s constitution, wrote Justice Sheryl Gordon McCloud.

“This history of motor vehicle excise tax in Washington is not easy to follow. The statutes have been amended, repealed, and reenacted by both the legislature and the people, and we have invalidated portions of those enactments and repeals as unconstitutional,” she wrote. “The legislature’s latest attempt in 2015 … further confuses things.”

Ard and attorney David DeWolf of Spokane filed the suit on behalf of the seven residents, who include Roger and Mary Struthers of Mukilteo and Frank Maietto of Snohomish.

Jerry Cornfield: 360-352-8623; jcornfield@heraldnet.com. Twitter: @dospueblos.

Talk to us

More in Local News

Students arriving off the bus get in line to score some waffles during a free pancake and waffle breakfast at Lowell Elementary School on Friday, May 26, 2023, in Everett, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
800 free pancakes at Everett’s Lowell Elementary feed the masses

The annual breakfast was started to connect the community and the school, as well as to get people to interact.

Marysville Mayor Jon Nehring speaks at the groundbreaking event for the I-5/SR 529 Interchange project on Tuesday, May 23, 2023 in Marysville, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
$123M project starting on Highway 529 interchange, I-5 HOV lane

A reader wondered why the highway had a lane closure despite not seeing work done. Crews were waiting on the weather.

Justin Bell was convicted earlier this month of first-degree assault for a December 2017 shooting outside a Value Village in Everett. (Caleb Hutton / Herald file)
Court: Snohomish County jurors’ opaque masks didn’t taint verdict

During the pandemic, Justin Bell, 32, went on trial for a shooting. Bell claims his right to an impartial jury was violated.

Gary Fontes uprights a tree that fell over in front of The Fontes Manor — a miniature handmade bed and breakfast — on Friday, May 12, 2023, at his home near Silver Lake in Everett, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Everett’s mini-Frank Lloyd Wright builds neighborhood of extra tiny homes

A tiny lighthouse, a spooky mansion and more: Gary Fontes’ miniature world of architectural wonders is one-twelfth the size of real life.

Will Steffener
Inslee appoints Steffener as Superior Court judge

Attorney Will Steffener will replace Snohomish County Superior Court Judge Janice Ellis, who is retiring in June.

News logo for use with stories about Mill Creek in Snohomish County, WA.
Police: Mill Creek man fatally stabbed wife amid financial woes

After quitting his job at Amazon, the man amassed about $50,000 in debt, triggering a discussion about finances, he told police.

Outside of the current Evergreen Recovery Centers' housing to treat opioid-dependent moms with their kids on Thursday, May 25, 2023 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
$8M in behavioral health grants to benefit children, youth, families

Snohomish County awarded one-time federal funding to five projects that will reach at least 440 new people each year.

A PUD vehicle drives along Lovers Road under newly-erected power poles that will eventually connect Stanwood and Camano Island on Tuesday, May 30, 2023, in Stanwood, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
To keep Camano lights on, PUD builds a new power line

The new line establishes a second electrical connection to Camano Island, which will help maintain power in windstorms.

Highway 9 is set to be closed in both directions for a week as construction crews build a roundabout at the intersection with Vernon Road. (Washington State Department of Transportation)
Weeklong closure coming to Highway 9 section in Lake Stevens

Travelers should expect delays or find another way from Friday to Thursday between Highway 204 and Lundeen Parkway.

Most Read