Aiming for good enough

WASHINGTON — Maybe this is how the Soviets felt in 1989.

There was a heavy tone of defeat in the questions senators posed to Ryan Crocker Wednesday morning as they prepared to confirm the star diplomat as the new ambassador to Afghanistan.

“What we’re trying to give to the Afghan peo

ple and have worked at for 10 years, and given them in blood, sweat and tears — you really, really wonder whether they want what we’re trying to give them,” complained Sen. Jim Risch, R-Idaho.

“When I see the reports, both public and private, about where our money has gone here, where the corruption is at, and when I see (Afghan President Hamid) Karzai talk about the United States as an occupying force, I have real problems having American lives shed and having American treasure continuing to be shed,” protested Sen. Bob Menendez, D-N.J.

Sen. Jim Webb, D-Va., argued that “if there’s any nation in the world that really needs nation-building right now, it’s the United States of America.” As for Afghanistan, “when we’re putting hundreds of billions of dollars into infrastructure in another country, it should only be done if we can articulate a vital national interest.”

Crocker, who retired from the foreign service but was called back to duty by President Obama, did not attempt to dissuade the lawmakers from their pessimism. “I’m under no illusions of the difficulty of the challenge,” the former ambassador to Pakistan and Iraq told them. “If Iraq was hard, and it was hard, Afghanistan in many respects is harder.”

The defeat that weighed on the questioners was not a military one; the surge of troops into Afghanistan has been reasonably successful against the Taliban. But the military success was intended to buy time to stand up Afghanistan’s civil society — a hope that has come to naught.

Nine years ago, President George W. Bush promised a Marshall Plan of sorts for Afghanistan. He said the military victory must be “followed by a moral victory that resulted in better lives for individual human beings,” taking the form of a “stable government,” a “national army” and a functioning education system.

A decade and tens of billions of dollars later, the Senate Foreign Relations Committee’s Democratic majority staff concluded that the nation-building effort has had only modest success. As The Washington Post’s Karen DeYoung reported, fully 97 percent of Afghanistan’s GDP is foreign military spending. As the military begins its promised pullout next month, the small improvements in Afghanistan’s corruption-plagued government could quickly be lost.

The committee members were uniformly grateful that Crocker had agreed to take on the thankless new role, and they were nearly as uniform in their doubts that it would go well.

“Our current commitment in troops and in dollars is neither proportional to our interest nor sustainable,” said the chairman, Sen. John Kerry, D-Mass.

Ranking Republican Sen. Dick Lugar of Indiana, noting Afghanistan’s cost of more than $100 billion a year to U.S. taxpayers, fretted about “massive, open-ended expenditures” and “more faith than is justified in Afghan institutions.”

Crocker, in his opening statement, added to the gloom. “Enormous challenges remain,” he said. “Governance, rule of law, including corruption, which undermines the credibility of the Afghan state, narcotics, sustainable economic development … along with the capacity of the government to provide basic services such as education and health care.”

Pressed by Kerry, Crocker suggested he’d settle for reducing the corruption. “We’re not out to clearly create a shining city on a hill,” he said. “That’s not going to happen.”

Even this less ambitious goal seemed optimistic in comparison to the senators’ comments: “back to square one again” (Lugar), “not sustainable for multiple reasons” (Bob Corker, R-Tenn.), “supporting a corrupt system” (Ben Cardin, D-Md.), “we do not have a solid partner” (Menendez), “how this is going to end with us achieving (our goals) is very, very difficult to grasp” (Risch).

“What is the goal?” asked Sen. Bob Casey, D-Pa.

“I was not among those who have ever used the word ‘winning’ or ‘victory,'” Crocker replied. His alternative description of success: “Good-enough governance: Governance that is good enough to ensure that the country doesn’t degenerate back into a safe haven for al-Qaida.”

A decade after Bush spoke of “moral victory” in Afghanistan, even “good-enough” sounds a bit too hopeful.

Dana Milbank is a Washington Post columnist. His email address is

Talk to us

More in Opinion

Editorial cartoons for Saturday, Jan. 16

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

FILE - In this April 12, 2018, file photo, a marijuana plant awaits transplanting at the Hollingsworth Cannabis Company near Shelton, Wash. Five years after Washington launched its pioneering legal marijuana market, officials are proposing their most ambitious overhaul yet of the way the industry is regulated, with plans for boosting minority ownership of pot businesses, spreading out oversight among a range of state agencies, and letting the smallest cannabis producers increase the size of the operations in an effort to help them become more competitive. (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren, File)
Editorial: Adults should be allowed to grow cannabis at home

A bill has returned to allow residents, as they are in other states, to grow their own marijuana.

Schwab: White, racist and anti-Semitic; that is who they are

And punishing the man who incited the Capitol mob is a prerequisite to healing the nation.

Gift of a cookie from neighbor was a bright spot

I would like to share a bright spot in our dreary days.… Continue reading

Pleased to be long-time Herald subscribers

We so appreciate our local paper.We even get disappointed when the Times… Continue reading

Editorial cartoons for Friday, Jan. 15

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

FILE - In this Dec. 10, 2020, file photo, an electronic sign warns travellers to maintain social distance in the terminal of Denver International Airport in Denver.  Two airline passengers who got into disturbances after allegedly not wearing face masks now face potential fines. The Federal Aviation Administration said Friday, Dec. 18,  that it is seeking civil penalties of $15,000 and $7,500 over two separate incidents. Both happened in August.  (AP Photo/David Zalubowski, File)
Editorial: ‘This is your captain speaking: Settle down!’

Unruly and unmasked passengers are a threat to flight safety and risk spreading the pandemic.

Rep. Andy Kim, D-N.J., cleans up debris and personal belongings strewn across the floor of the Rotunda in the early morning hours of Thursday, Jan. 7, 2021, after protesters stormed the Capitol in Washington, on Wednesday. (AP Photo/Andrew Harnik)
Editorial: Regardless of outcome, president must be impeached

If only to allow history to record that members of Congress stood up to Trump’s assault on democracy.

Soldiers working in a logistics area of Madigan Army Medical Center at Joint Base Lewis-McChord in Washington state stand Tuesday, Dec. 15, 2020, near cooler bags that will be used to transport vials of the first shipment of the Pfizer vaccine for COVID-19 to other locations in the hospital when shots are given to workers on Wednesday. (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren)
Editorial: Slow roll on covid vaccination can’t be tolerated

With only a fraction of available doses administered, vaccination rates must quickly ramp up.

Most Read