Forum: Layoffs at Everett Clinic point to for-profit problem

Optum’s control over providers, hospitals, medicines and health insurance is staggering.

By Eileen de la Cruz / Herald Forum

The Herald recently reported that Optum, the parent company of The Everett Clinic, despite earning multi-billion dollar profits, recently laid off dozens of people from the clinic (“Former Everett Clinic employees speak out about mass layoffs,” The Herald, Sept. 8).

There were nurses, a social worker, couriers and even a woman who had worked for the clinic for 35 years. They were “escorted” from the clinic premises (as though they were dangerous) and given severance packages with conditions that have made them fearful of speaking out. This is not the physician-owned Everett Clinic that I joined in 1996, but instead the disturbing evolution of the corporate-owned, profit-hungry entity I retired from in 2021.

These women and men were laid off from a company that is already immensely profitable. Their lives, families and economic stability have been severely disrupted. And it was done in such a way that not only shamed them, but also created an atmosphere of fear. Many at the clinic are now afraid for their own livelihoods. But this ultimately is why Optum and other corporations lay people off in this way; not only to cut costs, but to display power and instill submission and fear in those who remain. This is cruel, and for a company supposedly dedicated to human health, inhumane.

United Health Group is a massive and massively profitable managed health care and health insurance company that owns Optum. Optum is now not only the largest employer of physicians in the U.S., but also a pharmacy benefit manager that controls the cost and availability of medicines to millions of people. This concentration of power and control over providers, hospitals, medicines and health insurance in this one company is staggering and potentially dangerous; because profit, not compassion for human beings, is a core value that drives it.

Our current for-profit corporate health care system leaves millions without insurance, bankrupts the sick, overcharges us for vital medications and treatments, and keeps many of us in poorer health than people in other countries. It doesn’t need to be this way.

As an internist for 25 years, I cared for so many people from so many walks of life. We are all more alike than we are different. All of us will become ill. When that happens, we deserve compassionate, conscientious and affordable care.

I support a Medicare for All plan (which for-profit corporate health care executives are vehemently against, as they are against Medicare being able to negotiate drug prices.) No one should be uninsured. No one should become bankrupt due to sickness or be unable to afford life saving medications or treatments because of inflated costs.

And no one who works hard and conscientiously should be shamefully and needlessly laid off by a company that is obscenely profitable already. Here in the richest country in the history of the world we can do so much better.

Let us stop putting profit at the center of our health care and center our dignity and worth as human beings instead.

Dr. Eileen de la Cruz was an internal medicine physician at The Everett Clinic from 1996 until her retirement in 2021. She lives in Lake Forest Park.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

toon
Editorial cartoons for Sunday, Jan. 12

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Participants in Northwest WA Civic Circle's discussion among city council members and state lawmakers (clockwise from left) Mountlake Terrace City Council member Dr. Steve Woodard, Stanwood Mayor Sid Roberts, Edmonds City Council member Susan Paine, Rep. April Berg, D-Mill Creek; Herald Opinion editor Jon Bauer, Mountlake Terrace City Council member Erin Murray, Edmonds City Council member Neil Tibbott, Civic Circle founder Alica Crank, and Rep. Shelly Kolba, D-Kenmore.
Editorial: State, local leaders chew on budget, policy needs

Civic Circle, a new nonprofit, invites the public into a discussion of local government needs, taxes and tools.

FILE - Old-growth Douglas fir trees stand along the Salmon River Trail, June 25, 2004, in Mt. Hood National Forest outside Zigzag, Ore. The results in early 2023 from the government’s first-ever national inventory of mature and old-growth forests identified more than 175,000 square miles of the forests on U.S. government lands. (AP Photo/Rick Bowmer, File)
Comment: The struggle over the Department of Everything Else

The Secretary of Interior leads an agency tasked with managing public lands, resources and Tribal affairs.

Orca calf’s death argues for four dams’ removal

In “Encounters with the Archdruid,” his narration of David Brower’s battles with… Continue reading

Comment: King’s call to fulfill dream still ours to heed

Join in a two-day celebration and commitment to service with events in Everett on Jan. 19 and 20.

Stephens: Among successes, much will weigh on Biden’s legacy

Illusions and deceptions, chief among them that he was up to defeating Trump, won’t serve his reputation.

Harrop: Mamas, don’t let your baby boys grow up to be sponges

There may be many reasons young men are failing to leave home. But moms may not be helping much.

Forum: Drive for pitching speed troubles dad over injuries

More young baseball players are facing shoulder surgery as the sport pushes for high speeds and strikeouts.

Forum: New Herald columnist hopes to encourage dialogue, insight

Todd Welch is a Navy veteran and former member of the Lake Stevens City Council and will focus on local issues.

Comment: Investors will sit at end of line for Boeing’s rebound

Boeing can rebuild culture and company, but shareholders shouldn’t count on big dividends for awhile.

toon
Editorial: News media must brave chill that some threaten

And readers should stand against moves by media owners and editors to placate President-elect Trump.

FILE - The afternoon sun illuminates the Legislative Building, left, at the Capitol in Olympia, Wash., Oct. 9, 2018. Three conservative-backed initiatives that would give police greater ability to pursue people in vehicles, declare a series of rights for parents of public-school students and bar an income tax were approved by the Washington state Legislature on Monday, March 4, 2024.   (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren, File)
Editorial: Legislation that deserves another look in Olympia

Along with resolving budgets, state lawmakers should reconsider bills that warrant further review.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.