Pay off mortage early or put money elsewhere?

Three financial experts weigh in on the ever-evolving debate.

By Deborah Kearns /

Paying off a mortgage is a huge accomplishment, and it’s a cornerstone of financial independence. Homeowners who don’t want the shadow of a mortgage payment hanging over them for decades are eager to map out a strategy for tackling their mortgage debt for good. But other homeowners might be better served putting their cash to use elsewhere, such as higher-return investments or retirement savings.

Three financial experts weigh in on the ever-evolving debate on whether you should pay off your mortgage early — or put your money to work in other places. Let’s dive in.

Everyone agrees: Tackle mortgage debt last

Before you even think about paying off your mortgage early, financial advisers say you should get rid of high-interest debt, student loans and other sizable debt. Two other key areas that many people short-change or neglect are their retirement and emergency savings.

A recent Bankrate study shows that nearly half of working adults (48%) are saving something, but no more than 10% of their annual incomes. Only one in six employees (16%) say they’re saving more than 15% of their yearly earnings.

But tackling any type of debt requires discipline and a plan, says Douglas Boneparth, president of Bona Fide Wealth Management in New York City.

“You need to put a system in place for your goals that allows you to identify what they are, quantify them by time and value, and prioritize them,” Boneparth says. “You’ll have to make sacrifices along the way that may require you to spend less or increase your income.”

Evaluating how best to put your money to work

Pouring money into a house that you don’t plan on living in for more than five or 10 years ties up a good chunk of your liquidity for the foreseeable future. That probably won’t be in your best interest, especially if your mortgage carries a low interest rate, says Helen Ngo, CFP, founder and CEO of Capital Benchmark Partners in Atlanta.

“Look at where else can you put your money so that it works for you,” Ngo says. “Your interest rate plays a factor in the decision, and you have to weigh the spread in rates.”

For example, a 30-year mortgage with a 4.5% rate is still super cheap compared with the 8% to 9% that people paid in the 90s, Ngo says.

Boneparth points out that if you have a mortgage rate near 4% but you can get a 6% to 7% return on a diversified investment portfolio, paying off your mortgage early won’t make sense on paper.

“The spread between your mortgage interest rate and what you can conservatively assume by investing your money might influence how you allocate your savings across any large debt,” Boneparth says.

How emotional baggage of debt factors in

Let’s face it: debt is a heavy topic. People feel defined by it, and that comes with considerable emotional baggage. Some people will always view debt of any kind as the enemy, Boneparth says. Their feelings about debt— even carrying a mortgage long term — will override any financial considerations of putting their money to work elsewhere.

“It’s easier to think, ‘Hey, I’m debt-free’ instead of how to diversify an investment strategy,” Boneparth says. “But you have a choice to make. People are shooting from the hip instead of crunching the numbers.”

Ngo adds that many people assume all debt is bad, but a mortgage is different.

“A house is not like a car that depreciates in value (right away),” Ngo says.

Your age and appetite for risk matter, too

The younger you are and the more money you earn, the more you can afford to be aggressive with investment risk. But that appetite for risk dwindles as you get closer to retirement age, says Richard Barenblatt, a mortgage specialist with GuardHill Financial Corporation in New York City.

“There are situations where not having mortgage is good,” Barenblatt says.

He adds that knocking out your mortgage ahead of schedule makes sense if you’re retired or you don’t need the tax benefits, which are less robust under the new tax law.

“Being debt free is the holy grail of financial security, and that’s ultimately what a retiree is working toward,” Barenblatt says, adding that as people age, they’re more afraid of running into financial trouble that could take the roof from over their heads. “It’s a common perception as people get older, and that overrides any other lucrative (money-making) opportunities that come their way.”

4 ways to pay off your mortgage early

If you’re ready to aggressively pay down your mortgage, here are four ways to get started:

1. Refinance to a shorter-term loan

If you have a 30-year loan, you can refinance to a 10- or 15-year mortgage. While your monthly payments will be higher, you’ll pay off the loan in a fraction of the time (depending on how far you’re into repaying your current mortgage). Unless you can nab a lower interest rate for a shorter-term loan, though, refinancing won’t make sense, Barrenblatt says.

2. Reconfigure your payments for a shorter term — without refinancing

To tackle your mortgage in less time, ask your lender to help you figure out what the monthly payment would be at your current loan’s interest rate for various timeframes. Or you can use Bankrate’s mortgage payoff calculator to run the numbers for yourself.

Before you make extra payments, ensure your lender doesn’t charge a prepayment penalty for paying the loan off early, says Ngo. You also want to earmark extra payments to go toward principal only. Ask your lender what their specific process is for applying extra payments toward principal, Ngo says. Check your mortgage statements to make sure principal payments are applied properly, too.

3. Pay a little more each month or one extra payment each year

If you’re looking to chip away at your mortgage at a more gradual pace, pay a little extra each month or make one extra monthly payment each year. Again, you’ll want to follow your lender’s process for making principal-only payments.

4. Make lump-sum payments

Applying a lump-sum payment toward your principal balance when you come into extra cash — a bonus at work, tax refund or a sizable inheritance payout — can shave off time from your mortgage.

The downside to this strategy is that it can make it harder to pinpoint your payoff date. But if paying off your mortgage early is a top goal and you’ve met other obligations, putting it right toward your principal instead of leaving it in a checking or savings account where you might be tempted to spend it will keep your early payoff goal on track.

Talk to us

More in Herald Business Journal

Small business relief effort inundated with 850 applications

The economy in and around Everett has struggled amid fallen revenues and uncertainty about the future.

‘Hundreds of millions’ in bogus jobless benefits paid out

Washington state has been reported as the top target of a Nigerian fraud ring.

Marysville drivers wait overnight for Chick-fil-A opening

The popular chicken restaurant began serving at 6:30 a.m. Thursday. Police plan to guide traffic for days.

Tulalip Resort Casino and Quil Ceda Creek to open Tuesday

Guests must wear a mask and occupancy is limited, the Tulalip Tribes announced Wednesday.

As Arlington gym closes, a Snohomish barber continues to cut

PA Fitness closed after the state attorney general filed a lawsuit. “We would lose,” a co-owner conceded.

FAA says it will let Boeing employees vouch for plane safety

The agency defended the current system but identified areas for improvement. Some lawmakers disagree.

Fraudsters using local identities for phony jobless claims

The Everett School District, for example, saw about 310 false claims using employees’ personal information.

State sues an Arlington gym for violating stay-home order

“It is my constitutional right to be open,” says a co-owner of PA Fitness. He plans to countersue.

Heavy traffic expected when Chick-fil-A opens in Marysville

The city warns there will likely be delays for days along 88th Street NE. near the new restaurant.

Somers announces $14 million in relief for small businesses

One program will target aerospace companies. The other will focus on service and retail industries.

Paine Field terminal to close for 71 days of ramp repairs

Alaska is down to one departure per day due to the coronavirus outbreak’s effect on travel.

Quarantini time! New state rule allows cocktails to-go

Enjoy a margarita or a Manhattan with lunch or dinner to go. At Buck’s in Everett, you keep the mason jar.