Tribes win key ruling; others will have to pay

SEATTLE — Indians will have a much greater role in deciding how and where the state and other governments build culverts that impede salmon migration, following a federal court ruling Wednesday siding with the Tulalips and many other Washington tribes.

In their federal lawsuit, the tribes said that state and local government has an obligation under the 1855 Treaty of Point Elliot to protect salmon habitat by not hindering fish passage with narrow or blocking culverts.

The written decision by U.S. District Judge Ricardo Martinez “declares that the right of taking fish secured to the tribes in the Stevens Treaties imposes a duty upon the state to refrain from building or operating culverts …. that hinder fish passage.”

Martinez also found that the state “currently owns and operates culverts that violate this duty.”

The full effect of the decision is not known.

The ruling was good news for the Tulalip Tribes, which is in the forefront of asserting their treaty rights.

“This is a clear step for the tribes to enter into discussions with the state in terms of the impact to our tribal culture,” Tulalip fisheries commissioner Terry Williams said.

The tribes alleged in their lawsuit that fish don’t have access to 249 miles of streams that they should have, preventing the production of potentially 200,000 fish for tribal harvest.

“This is very significant,” Williams said. “Obviously we have to wait to see the detail of the judge’s comments, but clearly what is being said is when the fish are impaired by habitat problems, that affects the reserved rights of the tribes.”

The 152-year-old Point Elliot Treaty, also known as the Stevens Treaties, gave the tribes the right to take fish “at all usual and accustomed grounds and stations.” That’s key to this lawsuit, as it was to the landmark tribal fisheries decision of federal Judge George Boldt in 1974.

“For (fish) to exist, they have to have habitat,” Williams said. ” The treaty right is hollow without the habitat to sustain our culture. This is a treaty obligation. That’s what this comes from.”

Janelle Guthrie, spokeswoman for the state attorney general’s office, said the lawsuit is not over.

“The court said the Stevens Treaties say the state has to make sure our culverts allow fish to pass. While we currently have some culverts that don’t allow fish to pass, the state has plans in place to improve or replace these culverts,” Guthrie said. “The next step in the process is for the court to determine its remedy. The court has set a status conference for next Wednesday.”

Whatever the remedy, it will have an effect on Snohomish County government.

“How this ruling is going to affect our current business, I’m not sure,” said Steve Thomson, Snohomish County public works director. “I’m sure it will have some impact. I just can’t say right now.”

The county works with state fisheries officials on new road projects near streams, and occasionally gets grants to restore older culverts that block salmon.

The state didn’t dispute that some culverts block returning salmon. According to documents, the state found 18 percent of the culverts on land managed by the Department of Natural Resources were identified as barriers to fish in a 2000 inventory.

The state’s attorneys argued that since 1991 the state Department of Transportation’s culvert projects have also opened access to more than 410 miles of salmon habitat, Guthrie said. They also argued that there is no evidence the state is diminishing the number of fish for the tribal harvest.

Reporter Jim Haley:425-339-3447 or

Talk to us

More in Local News

Logo for news use featuring the municipality of Lake Stevens in Snohomish County, Washington. 220118
Motorcyclist identified in fatal crash near Lake Stevens

Anthony Palko, 33, died Monday night after colliding with a passenger car. The juveniles in the car were taken to the hospital.

Police: Marysville man shot sword-wielding roommate in self-defense

The roommates were arguing over eBay sales, according to police. Then one of them allegedly brandished a two-foot sword.

Logo for news use featuring the municipality of Lake Stevens in Snohomish County, Washington. 220118
Everett boy, 12, identified as Davies Beach drowning victim

Malachi Bell was one of three swimmers in distress Sunday in Lake Stevens. He did not survive.

Port of Everett hosting annual open house after pandemic hiatus

Also, Rustic Cork Wine Bar plans to open a second shop at Fisherman’s Harbor — the latest addition to the port’s “wine walk.”

Mike Kersey with Aiya Moore, daughter of Christina Anderson, right, talk about the condition of Nick’s Place in Everett, Washington on June 17, 2022.  (Kevin Clark / The Herald)
‘We’re all good people when we get clean and sober’

Who has fentanyl taken from us? A messenger who saved lives. A “street mom.” A grandpa who loved his grandkids “999 trillion times.”

Snohomish County Superior Courthouse in Everett, Washington on February 8, 2022.  (Kevin Clark / The Herald)
Bailiff’s comments leads to appeal of child rape conviction

Joseph Hall, of Snohomish, was sentenced to more than 13 years in prison. Now he faces another trial.

Jeffrey Vaughan
In unexpected move, Vaughan resigns from Marysville council

He got re-elected in November. But he and his wife moved to Texas when she received a job promotion.

Snohomish County Prosecutor Adam Cornell at the Snohomish County Courthouse on Monday, Nov. 15, 2021 in Everett, Wa. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
How to answer Snohomish County’s basic crime questions? ‘Transparent data’

An initiative funded in part by Microsoft could reveal racial disparities, while creating an “apples to apples” database.

Chris Rutland and son Julian buy fireworks from the Big House of Boom stall at Boom City on Thursday, June 30, 2022 in Tulalip, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
At Tulalip’s Boom City, fireworks are a family tradition

Generations have grown up at the Fourth of July institution. “Some people make good money, some are just out here for the pastime.”

Most Read