BPA payments are just bribery to keep lower Snake dams


In July, several Ohio politicians were arrested for accepting $60 million in bribes for their support of failing utility projects.

Corrupt Midwestern politicians, you think? By Northwest standards they’re small time losers that don’t know how to play the game.

At this moment Bonneville Power Administration is pressuring Northwest states, agencies and tribes to sign a document called the Columbia Fish Accords Extension. The original accords paid tribes and the states of Washington, Montana and Idaho a total of $100 million a year for 10 years. The extension promises BPA will add $420 million to the amount they have already paid.

The con is that BPA and the recipients want you to think the accords pay for habitat, hatchery and lower Columbia estuary projects to benefit the basin’s fish, particularly salmon, steelhead and lamprey.

The truth is much simpler. BPA is buying silence and fealty. The accords prohibit those who sign on from supporting lower Snake River dam breaching, the universally accepted best way to recover endangered salmon. Or, simpler still, call it what they call it in Ohio: bribery.

Worse, the main reason BPA and the Army Corps of Engineers want to keep the dams is bureaucratic arrogance and pride. They’re embarrassed to admit they screwed up.

The empty promise of the lower Snake River Dams back in the 1970s was that they would provide cheap navigation, cheap energy and not endanger fish. They are failing at all three.

Forty-five years after they were built, navigation tonnage on the Snake is now about half of its break-even level and trending downward as shippers abandon the river for cheaper, more reliable alternatives. Power from the lower Snake River Dams is surplus power that is produced mostly in the spring when it is not needed and is sold, mostly to California, for a loss.

And the salmon? The salmon are teetering on the edge of extinction as Idaho lurches from one canceled fishing season to the next and Idaho’s Gov. Brad Little refuses to allow his Salmon Workgroup to discuss the benefits of dam breaching.

In other words, BPA ratepayers, taxpayers, and the salmon would all be better off without the lower Snake River Dams and the bribes BPA pays to support them.

The best way to end the corruption is to eliminate the cause. Breach the lower Snake River dams. Time is wasting.

Tony Jones

Boise, Idaho

Talk to us

More in Opinion

Editorial cartoons for Thursday, Sept. 24

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Editorial: DelBene represents 1st Congressional District well

The Democrat has shown herself as a leader on issues and an ability to work with both parties.

Editorial: Franz’s efforts will assure healthier forestlands

Hiliary Franz, as public lands chief, has led notable gains in forest health and fire prevention.

Editorial: Let’s clear the air on wildfires, climate change

Agreement and commitment is needed to address the causes of wildfires and climate change.

Editorial: With McCarthy, Auditor’s Office now able watchdog

Pat McCarthy has restored morale and overseen efforts that provide greater access to audit findings.

Harrop: 2 cheers for drugmakers; third rests on price reforms

Drug companies have stood up to Trump’s empty promises. Now they can deliver on assuring fair prices.

Comment: What a conservative high court means for abortion

The court won’t necessarily split 6-3 to end Roe, but a majority is likely to endorse more restrictions.

Governor’s race: Inslee made right calls on pandemic

I’ll be casting my vote for Jay Inslee. When the virus hit… Continue reading

10th LD, House, Pos. 1: Homola shows firm grasp of issues

Angie Homola is the outstanding choice for state Representative, Pos. 1 for… Continue reading

Most Read