Tax incentive’s wage requirement will cost good jobs

Regarding the editorial regarding a business tax break (“Update tax break for Cascade Industrial Center jobs,” The Herald, Feb. 19):

Here’s a hypothetical: I am a manufacturer located in another state. State taxes and regulations have crippled my companies ability to make a profit, pay my 50 employees, and continue to invest in product innovations so my company can remain competitive. My employee positions range from college degree electronic design engineers to marginally educated warehouse workers.

Our company manufacturers high-precision digital widgets. We have two competitors making similar products in China and India. By all accounts, our company makes the highest quality digital widgets, with features the competitive products can’t yet match. My company is looking for a new location where both our company and our 50 employees can thrive. We came to the conclusion that the tax incentives offered with a relocation to the Arlington-Marysville business park would allow us to move into the future and remain competitive.

We now learn that greedy politicians want to move the goal post. We determined that we could meet the $18-an-hour minimum wage and still offer health coverage. Now we learn the new goal will be $23 an hour. The $23 requirement, with health care, causes me to rethink a proposed move to Arlington. We simply can’t pay our warehouse workers, facility maintenance staff and janitorial staff $23 an hour. In the aggregate, those workers comprise 16 percent of our total payroll. Sixteen percent of my payroll, earning $23 an hour, cuts my profit margin by 31 percent. At that rate, I can no longer invest in future product development and my competitors will continue to innovate and I will soon be out of business.

I must now consider the states of Texas or Nevada. Many of the very best high-tech companies are already relocating to these business-friendly locations. Snohomish County job seekers, the cities of Arlington, Merysville and the state of Washington will be the losers.

John Branthoover

Arlington

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

toon
Editorial cartoons for Wednesday, Jan. 22

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Advocates for people with intellectual and developmental disabilities rallied on the state capitol steps on Jan. 17. The group asked for rate increases for support staff and more funding for affordable housing. (Laurel Demkovich/Washington State Standard)
Editorial: Support those caring for state’s most vulnerable

Increasing pay for care workers of those with developmental disabilities can save the state money.

Columnist correct on state tax priorities

Herald Columnist Todd Welch’s first column (“Spreading ‘tax policy love around’ would… Continue reading

Reflect on qualities that MLK advised make us strong

In reflecting on the work and message of Martin Luther King Jr.… Continue reading

Kash Patel poor choice for FBI chief

I am opposed to President Trump’s nomination of Kash Patel as FBI… Continue reading

Honor President Carter’s memory by supporting aid programs

The United States and the world have been remembering President Jimmy Carter… Continue reading

Douthat: Four years later, Trump remains same as he ever was

What will factor most during the next four years is the same embodiment of all-American hubris as before.

toon
Editorial cartoons for Tuesday, Jan. 21

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Klein: Why Trump’s, GOP’s slim victories don’t feel that way

Trump and the Republicans won on ‘bad vibes’ for Democrats. That will be tough to govern with.

Harrop; Behold Trump’s new coin of the realm

Trump is selling $TRUMP, a cryptocurrency that surged in value at its fortuitously timed release.

Comment: MAGA world’s split is made-for-TV drama

And President Trump, a winner regardless who wins, is here for every moment of it.

Dowd: Trump brings a chill to D.C. that will persist

Yet, Trump was assisted in his second victory by Biden’s hubris and his staff’s secrecy.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.