Silvertips right wing Patrick Bajkov (8) battles in front of the net as Thunderbirds goaltender Liam Hughes (30) looks for the puck during a playoff game on March 31, 2018, at Angel of the Winds Arena in Everett. (Ian Terry / The Herald)

Silvertips right wing Patrick Bajkov (8) battles in front of the net as Thunderbirds goaltender Liam Hughes (30) looks for the puck during a playoff game on March 31, 2018, at Angel of the Winds Arena in Everett. (Ian Terry / The Herald)

The WHL’s postseason playoff format has major flaws

The unusual setup means a greater chance the league doesn’t crown the best team champion.

The second round of the WHL playoffs begins in full swing Friday.

In the Western Conference, the Everett Silvertips face the Portland Winterhawks in a series that pits the team that finished with the best record in both the U.S. Division and the conference (Everett with 99 points) against the team that finished with the second-best record in both (Portland, with 94 points). Meanwhile the Tri-City Americans, who finished fourth in the U.S. Division and fifth in the conference (85 points), face the Victoria Royals (84 points), who finished sixth in the conference, for the other berth in the conference finals.

The story is the same in the Eastern Conference. The Moose Jaw Warriors (109 points) and Swift Current Broncos (103 points), which finished with the best records in both the East Division and the league, will start slugging it out in a heavyweight second-round series. Meanwhile the Brandon Wheat Kings (85 points), who finished fourth in the East Division, face a Lethbridge Hurricanes team (72 points) that had the second-worst record among the 16 teams that advanced to the postseason.

Is it just me, or is something wrong with this picture?

This imbalance is the result of the WHL’s unusual playoff format, and that format means there’s a greater chance the league will crown a team that isn’t actually its best.

The WHL instituted its current playoff system beginning in the 2014-15 season. Two pods are created in each conference, one for each division. The top three teams from the division are placed in a pod together, then a wild-card team is added from the remaining conference teams with the two best records — the best wild-card record goes into the pod with the division champion with the worse record, and the second-best record goes into the pod with the conference’s best record. The pods play themselves out, with the pod winners squaring off for the conference title.

The league’s rationale for the current system is that it mirrors the NHL’s system, enhances division rivalries and cuts down on travel.

“We think that this formula and this particular format is real good for our league,” WHL commissioner Ron Robison said when he stopped through Kent during the first-round playoff series between the Tips and the Seattle Thunderbirds. “First of all, when you consider the travel demands on players, we really want to have those games in the first round within the division because travel is limited. At the same time it’s great rivalries.

“There’s pros and cons, and one of the concerns is you’re going to lose some good teams in the first round,” Robison continued. “But generally speaking we think this format makes a lot of sense for our league.”

The problem is the whole point of playoff seeding is to reward the teams that performed during the regular season. What this format has done this year is render regular season success meaningless.

Moose Jaw and Swift Current had the league’s two best records the entire season. They both loaded up at the trade deadline specifically to keep pace with one another. Their reward? One is going home after the second round and left wondering if it was worth it to have mortgaged its future.

Then there’s the case of the Wheat Kings, who were essentially rewarded for tanking. Brandon had the league’s third-best record at the January trade deadline. However, the two best records just happened to be in the same division. Therefore, the Wheat Kings traded away two of their best players, slipped into fourth place in the division, and ended up in the Central Division pod, where they had the best record. That’s right, the team that finished fourth in the East Division — and waved the white flag at the trade deadline — ended up with a considerably easier path to the conference finals than the three teams that finished ahead of it.

The league will argue that this year is unusual circumstances, that it’s rare for the balance of power in a conference to be weighted so heavily toward one division. But is that really the case? I went back and looked at the years since Everett entered the league in 2003 and found the following:

— This is the fourth time the league’s top two teams in the regular season resided in the same division: Kootenay and Kelowna in the B.C. in 2005, Medicine Hat and Calgary in the Central in 2006 and Tri-City and Spokane in the U.S. in 2008. Had the current playoff format been in place those years, at least one of those teams would have been out by the end of the second round.

— In 2010 we would have had the same situation as Brandon this year, as Portland finished fourth in the U.S. and would have switched over to the B.C. pod, where it would have had the best record. It would have been close in 2014, too, as Kootenay finished fourth in the Central Division and would have been placed in the East pod, where the Ice would have had just two fewer points than East champion Regina.

So six times in 15 years these problems cropped up. Once every two or three years. It’s actually not a rare occurrence at all.

And the league’s claim that the system cuts down on travel in the first round doesn’t float when Brandon plays Medicine Hat (514 miles apart) this year, Portland faces Prince George (727 miles apart) last year and Spokane meets Victoria (421 miles plus a ferry ride) in 2016.

I get the business angle. First-round playoff attendance figures usually take a dive from the regular season as teams lose their group sales and some of their season-ticket holders. One need only look at the relatively-full buildings for the first-round series between Everett and Seattle and compare them to the sparse crowds in previous first rounds to understand that.

But from a competitive standpoint — and isn’t that the whole purpose of sports? — it just doesn’t make sense.

So enjoy the Everett-Portland playoff series when it begins Friday, it should be a good one. It’s just a shame that the playoff format means that instead of being for the Western Conference title, it’ll send one team home prematurely.

Follow Nick Patterson on Twitter at @NickHPatterson.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Sports

Silvertips forward Carter Bear fields questions after the Detroit Red Wings selected him 13th overall in the 2025 NHL Entry Draft in Los Angeles on June 27, 2025. (Photo courtesy Natalie Shaver / CHL)
Two weeks after Draft, Silvertips’ Bear still can’t believe it

The Red Wings’ first-rounder reflects on draft night and his experience at Detroit’s development camp.

Storm flies too close to the Sun, loses in an upset

Connecticut snapped a 10-game losing streak to beat Seattle 93-83 on Wednesday morning.

Giancarlo Stanton of the New York Yankees flips his bat after hitting a three-run home run in the sixth inning against the Seattle Mariners at Yankee Stadium on Tuesday, July 8, 2025, in New York. (Evan Bernstein / Getty Images / Tribune News Services)
Raleigh, Judge heat up homer race at Yankee Stadium

In the battle of baseball’s biggest sluggers, Aaron Judge… Continue reading

Seattle Seahawks linebackers Derick Hall (58) and Boye Mafe (53) celebrate a defensive play during the 2024 season. (Rio Giancarlo / Getty Images / The Athletic)
Season to reveal long-term plans for Seahawks linebackers

The Seattle Seahawks selected edge rusher Boye Mafe with… Continue reading

Silvertips defenseman wins U20 Ball Hockey World Title with Canada

Rylan Pearce helps Canada win gold at the ISBHF U20 World Championships in Slovakia.

Seattle Seahawks wide receiver Doug Baldwin (89) makes a catch against San Francisco 49ers defensive back Rashard Robinson (33) in the second quarter at Levi's Stadium in Santa Clara, Calif., on Sunday, Jan. 1, 2017. (Nhat V. Meyer / Bay Area News Group / Tribune News Services)
Sports psychologist changed Seahawks’ Doug Baldwin’s outlook

The former receiver overcame intense emotions during his player career

Paolo Banchero, Orlando agree to max contract extension

The former O’Dea star could earn up to $287 million over five years.

NHL players, owners vote to ratify 4-year CBA

Notable changes include an 84-game season starting in 2026, shorter contract terms.

AquaSox outfielder Carson Jones gets settled in the batter's box during Everett's 4-3 loss to the Vancouver Canadians at Funko Field on July 6, 2025. (Joe Pohoryles / The Herald)
AquaSox show progress, but drop fifth straight to Canadians

Jones’ go-ahead, 3-run homer is spoiled in 4-3 loss to wrap up homestand.

Bryan Woo of the Seattle Mariners delivers a pitch in the first inning against the Toronto Blue Jays at Rogers Centre on Friday, April 18, 2025, in Toronto. (Vaughn Ridley / Getty Images / Tribune News Services)
Three Mariners added to MLB All-Star Game

Major League Baseball announced today that Mariners outfielder Julio Rodríguez,… Continue reading

George Kirby (68) of the Seattle Mariners pitches in the third inning against the Pittsburgh Pirates at T-Mobile Park on Sunday, July 6, 2025, in Seattle. (Alika Jenne / Getty Images / Tribune News Services)
Pirates finish historically bad offensive series in Seattle

Similar to the first two games of the series, the… Continue reading

Seattle Storm forward Alysha Clark (32) and Aces guard Jewell Loyd (24) guard each other during a free throw in a WNBA basketball game between the Aces and the Seattle Storm at Michelob ULTRA Arena Friday, June 20, 2025, in Las Vegas. (Madeline Carter / Las Vegas Review-Journal / Tribune News Services)
Storm uses third-quarter thunderbolt to down Liberty

Rookie Dominique Malonga scored 11 and took over in the third quarter for Seattle.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.