Iraq mistakes detailed

Published 9:00 pm Wednesday, November 26, 2003

LONDON – The retired American general who headed the first occupation government in Iraq says the decision to disband the Iraqi army was one of several major mistakes Washington has made in Iraq.

The United States should also have put more troops into Baghdad after the fall of Saddam Hussein and done a better job of winning support from the Iraqi people, Jay Garner said in a British Broadcasting Corp radio interview aired Wednesday.

Garner arrived in Baghdad on April 21, shortly after Hussein’s fall. He was replaced by Paul Bremer on May 12 after less than a month as Iraq’s civilian administrator. At the time, he was criticized for not doing enough to stop the lawlessness in Baghdad.

Garner, a former lieutenant general who ran the relief mission for Kurdish refugees after the 1991 Gulf War, claimed he was undermined by interagency rivalry and said the military did not act quickly enough to restore law and order and key services in the city.

After the collapse of the Baath regime, looters rampaged for days. Crime remains a problem in the capital.

“If we did it over again, we probably would have put more dismounted infantrymen in Baghdad and maybe more troops there,” Garner said, speaking to the BBC from his home in Florida.

He also criticized Bremer for disbanding the Iraqi army at a time when manpower was needed for rebuilding. The original plan had been to pay the army to take part in reconstruction work. Bremer’s decision threw hundreds of thousands of breadwinners out of work and provided potential recruits for insurgency, he said.

“You’re talking about around a million or more people … that are suffering because the head of the household’s out of work,” Garner said.

“And we had budgeted to pay the Iraqi army. But part of our plans said, you know, they’ll surrender like they did in the first Gulf War. “Well, hell, they didn’t surrender, they just evaporated,” Garner said.

In defense of his decision, Bremer has said the army had already dissipated during the last days of the war, military facilities were heavily damaged and stripped by looters, and it was necessary to rid the military of Hussein’s supporters.

Garner admitted some mistakes of his own. In hindsight, he said, he would have done a better job communicating with the Iraqi people and restoring electricity.

“I think we are finally placing more trust in Iraqis, which we should have done to begin with,” he said.

“We should have tried to raise a government a little faster than we did.”

Copyright ©2003 Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.