‘Last Bohemia’ a sad tale of greed at Carnegie Hall

  • By Robert Horton Herald Movie Critic
  • Thursday, June 21, 2012 12:23pm
  • LifeGo-See-Do

The title of the documentary is “Lost Bohemia,” but this film describes as lost paradise, as well. The paradise was located in the upper floors of Carnegie Hall.

The fabled Manhattan building, bankrolled by Andrew Carnegie and opened in 1891, has long been known as a gold standard for live performance. But it’s more than a performance space; from its earliest days, Carnegie Hall has also been a living space.

“Lost Bohemia” introduces us to some of the residents of Carnegie Hall, who lived in the apartments above the concert chambers. These places were designed and intended for artists, musicians and dancers, and created as light-filled studios.

Filmmaker Josef Astor is a photographer and former resident himself. All of this is in the past tense; the owners of Carnegie Hall, including the city of New York, determined to kick out the residents over the course of the last few years, so that the spaces could be remade and gentrified, presumably with no room for struggling artists.

Astor’s film chronicles these evictions and brings to life the fantastically eccentric people whose lives are upended because of the change. Some of them — dance instructors, acting teachers, singers, pianists — have lived in the Carnegie for decades.

The film is an elegy, then, for a building’s past. But it’s also infuriating; this is yet another example of a system being willfully changed, in direct violation of the original intentions of the people who created the system, for very simple reasons of greed.

In that sense, “Lost Bohemia” is an effective microcosm for the mindset of the monetary transaction as the all-important reality in society. The people being evicted can find other homes, right? And as for the rich history of the building’s residents, what good is history if you can’t make money from it?

So out they all go — and Astor’s camera captures the process, right down to the apartment interiors being reduced to rubble.

The movie traces some of the history, although you sense there’s a lot more. Past residents include Leonard Bernstein, Marlon Brando, Isadora Duncan and many others mentioned in the film.

Aside from a few comments at a press conference, the people behind the changes are not quoted in the film, as they declined to be interviewed. They probably have reasons. What speaks most eloquently in this horribly sad film is the trashed contents of these rooms that hold so much history and art, all now reduced to debris.

“Lost Bohemia”

A horribly sad documentary that chronicles the gentrification of the apartments in the upper floors of Carnegie Hall, which have housed artists for decades but now must be cleared for progress. Filmmaker Josef Astor, himself a resident, catches this infuriating process, and brings to life the eccentric residents who were the last to live in the storied place.

Rated: Not rated; probably PG-13 for language.

Showing: Northwest Film Forum.

Talk to us

More in Life

abstract background from a grass covered with hoarfrost
How cold is too cold for the Northwest garden? It depends

Overnight temperatures in the teens, and daytime highs that don’t exceed the mid-20s, can spell doom if gardeners don’t take action.

The GPP for this Friday is Blechnum spicant, commonly called deer fern, and the image credit goes to Richie Steffen.
Great Plant Pick: Deer fern

This native fern is an excellent choice for the woodland garden. And despite (or maybe because of?) its name, it’s resistant to deer.

November was a trying month for PUD crews and customers

A generator, if you live in a rural area and can afford one, will likely come in handy at some point in the winter.

Photo Caption: There's finding a toy in your food packaging, and then there's making a toy from the packaging. Towle's Log Cabin brand provided a rolling platform to turn their iconic syrup tin into a pull toy.
Advertising was targeted at kids back in Grandpa’s day, too

This Log Cabin Express toy transformed into a toy after its days as a pancake syrup dispenser were finished.

Caption: The eternal fragrance of bath products triggers memories from long ago. (Jennifer Bardsley)
Bath product fragrances are full of memories

A Costco-size bottle of Neutrogena Rainbath takes the author back to the carefree days of seventh grade

In Turkey, it's easy to meet locals in a mosque and learn more about Islam.
Rick Steves’ Europe: Experiencing Islamic traditions in Turkey

Ramadan is perhaps the best time to travel to the country where the Islamic world meets the Christian world.

These tips can help you nurture a positive outlook on life

No one likes to be negative. Yet some adults can’t help but see their cup as half full.

The 2021 Lexus RX 350 luxury midsize SUV is available with front-wheel or all-wheel drive. (Manufacturer photo)
Lexus RX 350 luxury SUV gains new standard features for 2021

Wireless charging and a blind spot monitoring system with rear cross traffic alert are included.

2022 Genesis GV70 Sport Prestige (Genesis)
2022 Genesis GV70 Sport Prestige

Luxury SUV’s just got cooler with the introduction of the 2022 Genesis GV70.

Most Read