Lorraine Matuschak relaxes on the front porch of her 1925 Craftsman home, which won the 2019 Marian Krell Award in Everett’s Monte Cristo Awards. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)

Lorraine Matuschak relaxes on the front porch of her 1925 Craftsman home, which won the 2019 Marian Krell Award in Everett’s Monte Cristo Awards. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)

Purchase Photo

This old house wins top honors in Everett’s Monte Cristo Awards

The 1925 Craftsman bungalow gets a new kitchen, remodeled bathrooms and a “secret garden.”

Lorraine Matuschak sent her husband an urgent request.

“You have to meet me here on my lunch break,” she told him.

She was working in real estate at the time and had just spotted a listing for a 1925 Craftsman style home in Everett’s Riverside neighborhood. It was described as having hardwood floors, a fireplace and a living room with built in bookcases. And it was being sold “as is.”

It was 2009, and even though the economy was in recession, there were four offers on the home.

“We were lucky enough to get it,” she said. “We knew it needed a ton of work, but we thought we could do it ourselves instead of having to pay out thousands of dollars for labor.”

It still had its original trim, and the fireplace, she said, was beautiful. “It had tons of character,” she said. “It just needed some love and sprucing up.”

She and her husband, Sean Matuschak, who works for a design firm, had previously lived in Snohomish and had fixed up rental properties. “We loved doing it,” she said.

So they felt prepared to take on the upgrades needed in what was then an 84-year-old home, beginning with a “secret garden,” and then moving on to major renovations to the kitchen and two bathrooms.

Over the years, others recognized what the couple had accomplished. In 2012, it was named a Monte Cristo Award winner, annual awards given to homeowners and businesses across Everett for their beautification efforts.

This year, the home won a second honor — the Marian Krell Award — which recognizes superior care on an ongoing basis by a prior Monte Cristo Award winner.

It was one of a series of neighborhood awards announced during ceremonies at the Historic Everett Theatre Thursday evening in four categories: neighborhood-friendly businesses, pride of the neighborhood, rejuvenation and transformation, and, new this year, green gardening for properties with environmentally-friendly landscaping.

One of Lorraine Matuschak’s first projects was adding a garden. When the couple bought the home the “garden” was a tree and a bush. She fenced off the side of the property, enclosed the garden, and later installed a deck on the back of the house.

“I did that shabby chic style,” she said. “We were on a budget. I salvaged a bunch of old shed doors and barn doors.”

Then the couple started work on the downstairs bathroom, initially so tiny “you could barely move in it,” she said. It had to be gutted.

Next, they moved on to the kitchen. Among other challenges, there were no electrical outlets on one entire side of the kitchen — a problem that wasn’t apparent until you started looking for a place to plug something in, she said.

The original kitchen cabinets had been replaced in the 1970s. Lorraine Matuschak knew someone whose husband was a contractor who had some spare kitchen cabinets sitting in a barn — and that were being offered for free.

“We looked at those cabinets, and that got the kitchen remodel going,” she said. Their philosophy was: If we can salvage something, we will.

With two kids, the kitchen remodel took several years, having to be divided into steps so they could still prepare meals.

“These old houses, once you start digging in, you realize how much has to be replaced,” she said.

Most of the home’s remodeling was done over the first five years they lived there. But those projects were mixed in with other necessities — a new roof, water heater and furnace. Overall, they estimate their improvements cost about $40,000.

The goal was to retain as much of the home’s original character as possible. The Matuschaks have a message for those considering buying an older home: Everything costs more and takes longer than you think.

“If you’re buying an old house, you really have to love it,” she said.

The couple, now both 39, have two sons, Nolan, 10, and Ben, 5. They plan on making the Craftsman their longtime home.

“The house is big enough for all of us,” she said. “I’m glad I was able to bring an old house back to the good old days.”

Sharon Salyer: 425-339-3486 or salyer@heraldnet.com.

Award winners

This year’s Monte Cristo Award winners, listed by neighborhoods, are:

Rejuvenation and Transformation

South Forest Park: Wesley Briscoe and Jennifer Lazara

Twin Creeks: John and Marilyn Ellis

Lowell: Marcelino and Susan Chavez

Lowell: Jose and Michelle Padilla

Riverside: Carl and Randi Breeden

Bayside: Donald and Kimberly Wayne

Glacier View: Brent and Kathryn Watkins

Port Gardner: Kyle Mindemann and Megan Monroe

Port Gardner: Allan and Deana Upton

Northwest: Geoff and Sandra Grice

Northwest: Ted and Carole Jacobs

Neighborhood-Friendly Business

Holly: Fairway Estates: Senior Mobile Home Park

Lowell: Laura Wilson

Port Gardner: Port Gardner Bay Winery

Green Gardening

Glacier View: Sharyn Gerhardt

Northwest :Diane Loop

Pride of the Neighborhood

View Ridge: Darren Frazier

View Ridge: Lisa Siefert and Chuck Tondell

South Forest Park: Malaki and Linda Seanoa

Valley View: Randy and Donna Karg

Valley View: Babby Skowyra

Twin Creeks: Arthur Young

Cascade View: Mike and Barbara Patrick

Cascade View: Tom and Judy Vang

Delta: Victoria Jonas

Delta: Jennifer McKinney and Gerry Donathan

Evergreen: Athena Doolittle

Evergreen: Devon and Nettie Midkiff

Holly: Alan and Linda Jesmer

Westmont: Tara Austin

Pinehurst: Donald, Jenny and Neil Hoyt

Pinehurst: Dan Nickel

Riverside: Carolyn Kelly

Bayside: Rafe and Kathryn Anders

Bayside: Paul and Kerri Bernhard

Glacier View: Linda Falleen

Boulevard Bluffs: John and Hazel Beiermann

Harborview-Seahurst-Glenhaven: Nancy Jo and Ted Lombard

Port Gardner: Greg and Andrea Meuret

Port Gardner: Nathan and Alisa Muntz

Northwest: Liesa Postema and Chad Bullock

Northwest: Clint and Alyssa Seal

Talk to us

More in Life

Flying Heritage and Combat Armor Museum will close — for now

The fate of the vintage aircraft museum that featured Paul Allen’s private collection is up in the air.

Board game designer picks 9 to play while you’re stuck at home

There’s a game here for players of any age — and most of them don’t take hours to play.

Pandemic moves Dueling Pianos act to couple’s Lynnwood garage

You can catch Jeff Coleron and Rhiannon Kruse this Friday live on social media.

This Everett artist finds strength in flower power

Kimberly Mattson is drawn to the infinite number of elements that can be seen in a flower.

Sierra Wilkin wipes down pens for customers during the opening day of Cama Beach Cafe on Friday, May 22, 2020 in Camano Island, Wa. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Shutdown hit Camano cafe hard, but owner’s used to a challenge

When Cama Beach Cafe was forced to close, Donna King’s yoga-derived sense of calm helped her cope.

Vandalism or art? Graffiti rocks at Howarth Park

It’s against the law to deface public property with spray cans, no matter how artful.

COVID-19 and domestic violence

Public Health Essentials! A blog by the Snohomish Health District.

Columbia Valley wineries look back on ‘St. Helens Vintage’

Growers Mike Sauer and Dick Boushey and winemaker Rob Griffin shared their recollections of the eruption.

Gumbo made without shellfish reminds her of South Carolina

This one-pot gumbo is made with chicken, spicy andouille sausage and the holy trinity of Creole cooking.

Most Read