Everett firefighter paid $224K over discrimination claims

James Nagle says his colleagues doubted his ability to lead given his mental health history.

Jim Nagle

Jim Nagle

EVERETT — The city of Everett has agreed to pay a firefighter $224,217 to resign and to settle his allegations that he was discriminated against for his anxiety and depression.

James Nagle in March filed a damage claim, which is a precursor to a lawsuit. He indicated he would be seeking $1 million.

The settlement forbids him from making public comments about the matter. The Daily Herald obtained a copy of the document, along with the damage claim, through public records requests.

The agreement is dated Oct. 12. Under its terms, Nagle had to resign, and the city marked his departure as a retirement in personnel records.

Nagle, 51, of Mill Creek, had been with the department since 1994. Last year, he was promoted from captain to assistant chief. His annual salary in the new role was $142,920. He was demoted in January back to captain. He says the demotion was part of the discrimination.

In June 2017, Nagle had given a presentation on mental wellness to his colleagues. He was promoted the next month.

Around that time, Nagle alleges that several of the department’s battalion chiefs — those in the rank he skipped between captain and assistant chief — were opposed to him acting as their supervisor. The claim says they doubted his abilities to be an effective manager “given his mental health history,” and that they cited his presentation as evidence.

He says they defamed him and undermined his authority, and that one of them received a reprimand over it. He says he experienced “extensive stress” over the situation, and that it was a significant factor in his separation from his wife.

Court records show that Nagle filed for divorce in early 2017, saying that he and his wife had been living in separate homes since 2014. The same month that he was promoted, he withdrew his petition, telling the court they had reconciled.

This past April, he filed again for a divorce, which is pending.

As part of the settlement, Nagle agreed not to seek further legal action, and the city did not admit wrongdoing. The city also is obligated to provide him with health insurance through 2019, and to pay out unused vacation time.

His personnel file will be updated to say he retired as an assistant chief.

Rikki King: 425-339-3449; rking@heraldnet.com; Twitter: @rikkiking.

More in Local News

Nation’s first coronavirus patient said to be fully recovered

The Snohomish Health District has released the man from home isolation.

Gun-ammunition bill is suffocated by GOP amendments

It’s Day 40 of 60 of the 2020 session of the Washington Legislature in Olympia.

Chris Walsh and his wife, Carol, talk outside the Delta Rehabilitation Center about their plans to close the care facility long known as the Snohomish Chalet. Chris is the owner and administrator of the nursing home that cares for people with severe brain injuries. Carol has worked as a nurse there for many years. (Dan Bates / The Herald)
Delta Rehabilitation, home to brain injury victims, to close

“There’s no replacement,” head of care facility agency says of place once known as Snohomish Chalet.

A Hamas heir, a nose job, $1.5 million — and global intrigue

An urgent plastic surgery request in Lynnwood may have exposed huge fraud by a Palestinian refugee.

Edmonds School District leaders plan for another school bond

It won’t be in April, but the district could float another bond proposal in August or November.

Boeing asks that its big state tax break be suspended

The company hopes the move will resolve a trade dispute involving European rival Airbus.

Everett defense investigator stripped of license

Witness tampering charges against Michael Powers were dropped, in a deal that ends his career.

Body scanner could replace strip searches in Monroe prison

A new bill suggests using a scanner, like those in airports, to check for contraband on or in people.

High school wrestler steps in after twin faces fight of his life

SULTAN — Tyler Deason was the one his family thought would be competing at the state high school wrestling tournament.

Most Read