Mukilteo School Board plans vote on the fate of ‘Mockingbird’

Speakers offered varying opinions on whether the novel should be required. The board is to decide Jan. 24.

"To Kill A Mockingbird" by Harper Lee

MUKILTEO — The Mukilteo School Board will vote in two weeks to decide if “To Kill a Mockingbird” should be required reading in the ninth grade.

At Monday’s meeting, board members offered differing opinions on a novel that students have been reading for six decades.

Three high school English teachers made the request in September that the book be removed from the required reading list for freshmen.

Reasons included it “celebrates white saviorhood,” “marginalizes characters of color” and “uses the ‘n’ word almost 50 times.”

This is the first time in over 20 years a book faces removal from required reading in the district.

The 20-member Instructional Materials Committee of staff and parents evaluated the removal request and heard both sides. They recommended to the board the novel not be required curriculum, but that it should remain on the approved novels list for teachers to use.

The book tells the story of a white lawyer defending a Black man wrongly accused of rape in Alabama in the 1930s, and it uses the dialogue of that time and place. The theme is prejudice and loss of innocence. Harper Lee’s novel won a Pulitzer Prize in 1961.

Each grade has a required novel. Freshmen read “Mockingbird.” Sophomores are assigned “Things Fall Apart,” juniors read “Their Eyes Were Watching God,” and for seniors the book is “Pygmalion.” In lower grades, books are “Talk Two Moons” for sixth grade; “Tangerine” for seventh grade; and “Fahrenheit 451” or “The Giver” for eighth grade.

For years, “To Kill a Mockingbird” has been challenged and at times removed or banned by other school districts nationwide.

In the request, teachers Verena Kuzmany, Riley Gaggero and Rachel Johnson suggested replacing the book with “All American Boys,” a 2015 novel about two teens, one Black and one white, handling racism and police brutality. That novel has also been “banned and challenged due to profanity, drug use, and alcoholism, and because it was thought to promote anti-police views,” according to the American Library Association.

Board member John Gahagan planned to do some reading homework of his own before deciding.

“I am going to re-read the book,” Gahagan said of “Mockingbird.” “It has been 50-plus years.”

He mentioned the notion of “white saviorhood.”

“Why is it always that a white guy has to come and save the day?” he said. “It’s a beloved book, but maybe after 60 years it’s time to re-look at that. Not to say kids can’t read it, teachers can’t teach it, but should we require it?”

Charles Hauck, the sole new member on the board, appeared to have already made up his mind.

“Other generations of children have read this book and understood it and used it in their learning experience,” Hauck said. “It’s a bad thing to start out picking and choosing books. Once you start this process, I don’t see any end to it. The book has the ability to teach, not to destroy and not to make someone feel bad.”

Thien Nguyen, Mariner High School student board representative, said some students are offended by the derogatory terms.

“There are so many better books out there … that can offer valuable insights in a less harmful way and a more educational way,” Thien said.

He called for more student input in the decision.

“One missing variable is the students, whose voices matter the most in this discussion,” he said.

Monica Chandler, district director of curriculum and professional development, said racial events in recent years prompted seeing the book “through a different lens.”

“The students in our classrooms are very different than the students we had 30 years ago,” she said.

Ann Freeman, a community member, voiced opposition to the book’s removal.

“It is through our discomfort with any literary work that we gain insight, true learning and then can effect change,” she said. “The answer is not to remove it.”

Kamiak teacher Kuzmany stated her case at the meeting.

“Regarding the romanticizing of this book as a beloved classic, I’d like to ask those of you listening today to consider for whom this text exactly is a cherished classic,” she said. “… Just as Confederate statues have no place in our cities and should be dethroned from pillars of history, we should re-examine texts that do not provide our students of color, who continue to be marginalized in our society and in our schools, with an empowering narrative.”

Judy Schwab, a board member since 1997, expressed concern the removal would be “setting a precedent for all novels going forward.”

She cited the “misogyny in the works of Shakespeare” or “‘The Diary of Anne Frank,’ a true story of Jews being persecuted.”

The board is set to vote on its decision Jan. 24.

Andrea Brown:; 425-339-3443. Twitter @reporterbrown.

Talk to us

More in Local News

Michael Jensen, left, and Nathan Jensen, right, pick up trash in their encampment that they being forced to clear out of by Parks Department the near Silver Lake on Wednesday, Jan. 23, 2019 in Everett, Wa. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Annual homeless count could shed light on pandemic’s impact

Snohomish County canceled its 2021 point-in-time count. Officials hope this year’s will bring clarity.

Section of a tsunami high ground map. (Island County)
Tsunami warning fizzled, but future threat to Whidbey is real

State and county officials have long warned about the possibility of a tsunami striking the island.

Judge: Sex abuse of former Marysville student violated law

A woman sued the district last year, accusing a longtime art teacher of sexual abuse in the 1980s.

Darrell Cain, Pierce College Puyallup president and incoming Everett Community College interim president
Pierce College Puyallup president picked to lead EvCC for now

Everett Community College’s board chose Darrell Cain as its interim president.

Christian Sayre (Washington County Sheriff's Office)
$1 million bail for Everett bar owner charged with rapes

Christian Sayre, 35, owner of The Anchor Pub, was charged last week with 10 counts of felony sex crimes.

NO CAPTION NECESSARY: Logo for the Cornfield Report by Jerry Cornfield. 20200112
Democrats ready to ditch the other ‘grand bargain’ of 2021

Here’s what’s happening on Day 10 of the 2022 session of the Washington Legislature.

Photo by Emily Gilbert/Whidbey News-Times
Jonathan Kline said a museum would be coming in to take most of the pews from the former Jehovah's Witness church on Morris Road outside Coupeville. The Whidbey Homeless Coalition wants to turn the building into an overnight shelter.
Appeal filed against homeless shelter project near Coupeville

More than 300 neighbors signed a letter saying the location isn’t an appropriate place for the shelter.

The entrance to the new free COVID vaccination site at the Everett Mall on Monday, Jan. 17, 2022. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Free mass-vaccination site opens Tuesday at Everett Mall

Hundreds of appointments are up for grabs at the state-run site, which will offer initial doses, boosters and pediatric shots.

Inches of snow cover roads Saturday afternoon in downtown Edmonds, Washington on February 13, 2021.  (Kevin Clark / The Herald)
After snowstorms, cities make a roadmap for next time

Meanwhile, Lynnwood was inundated with entries in a contest to name a city plow. One idea? Plowy McPlowface.

Most Read