A little history lesson

Regarding Jessica Sutton’s Dec. 8 letter, “Election 2000: Let’s live by real democracy”: Here are a couple of points to consider. The United States is not a democracy; it is a representative republic and union of fifty sovereign states. The Electoral College, for all its perceived unfairness, provides the means by which the Union of sovereign states selects the leader of the country formed in the Union. The constitutional amendment required to eliminate the Electoral College and the extra recognition of the individual states it represents will never happen.

Now a little history lesson. Andrew Jackson did have the majority of electoral votes in 1824; he just did not receive the 50 percent plus one majority required in the Constitution. The election went to the House. Henry Clay, who came in third and had collected electoral votes, cut a deal with John Quincy Adams, putting his support and his electors behind Adams in return for the vice presidency. Adams then had the required majority and was certified by Congress.

And finally, as close as this election was, we would be recounting every county in the country right now if we had direct elections of the president. Could this republic survive the Florida scenario played out in every state?

Marysville

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

toon
Editorial cartoons for Saturday, July 26

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

2024 Presidential Election Day Symbolic Elements.
Editorial: A recap of The Herald’s primary endorsements

Primary elections, setting the November ballot, are no time for voters to sit on the sidelines.

Eco-nomics: Texas floods show threat of climate disaster, debt

We’re seeing what happens when the crises of a warming world and debt limit our ability to respond.

Comment: Academy’s graduation of peace officers marks milestone

With its first graduating class, Arlington training academy provides a local home for public safety.

Forum: Are fear of shame, pride what drive privacy obsession?

We are holding who we are — even our ailments — so closely it keeps us from health and community.

Forum: Harm reduction offers better outcomes than prohibition

A committee’s proposal to provide a safe supply of drugs can limit overdoses and offer a path to recovery.

Comment: AI ought to pay a price for its environmental damage

Fossil fuels have long gotten a pass from paying for their harm to the climate. Don’t give AI the same deal.

toon
Editorial cartoons for Friday, July 25

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

The Buzz: All aboard the Crazy Train for a faux news week

Someone’s going off the rails, trying to distract attention away from the Epstein files.

Schwab: Is Epstein saga showing MAGA what Trump thinks of them?

In trying to divert attention from the scandal, Trump reveals it’s about what benefits him, not them.

Douthat: If Trump doesn’t control MAGA, who will when he’s done?

He may insist he makes the decisions, but Trump reads MAGA first for much of what passes for policy.

Comment: Clawback of public stations’ funding is cultural arson

Public media has an especially crucial role to play in keeping Americans informed, educated and entertained.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.