There’s a difference between a lie and a misstatement

A recent letter writer attempted to make the point that politicians on both sides of the aisle tell lies, using three examples of Democratic politicians lying.

One of the examples the letter writer provided shows, inadvertently, how a misstatement is different from a lie.

A lie is when someone willingly says (or writes) something that that person knows to be untrue.

Motive is key; it has to be provable that what was said or written was known by that person to not be true for what was said to be a lie.

In the example used, President Obama said that under the proposed Affordable Care Act, one would be able to keep one’s doctor. At the time President Obama said this, the as-yet-unpassed act was still being written, and at that time the intent of the authors of the act was that, yes, patients would be able to keep their doctors and their plans. As the act was revised and re-written, this part was subsequently deleted.

So at the time he made that statement, President Obama believed it to be true, and it was.

It’s a common tactic of the right to point to this one example to “prove” that President Obama told a lie. Yet that is the lie. Not what Obama said.

Jeff Rivers

Mountlake Terrace

Talk to us

More in Opinion

Editorial cartoons for Thursday, Aug. 13

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Commentary: Boeing-Airbus trade dispute is a pointless relic

The question of who gave what aid years ago feels silly when the pandemic has crippled air travel.

Editorial: Debate regarding Snake River dams is far from over

If we are to avoid the extinction of salmon runs and orcas, talks regarding the dams should continue.

Editorial: Release of weekly list of deaths should resume

The county health district no longer provides the list to The Herald; but it’s misinterpreting the law.

Editorial: Tax credit proposal would aid local journalism

Bipartisan legislation in the U.S. House would offer tax credits to advertisers and subscribers.

Editorial: Wishful thinking useless against virus, recession

Concrete steps — by Congress and ourselves — are necessary to protect our health and the economy.

Comment: Harris’ elevation to ticket has been long time coming

Following many women before her in politics, Harris could deliver final blow to the glass ceiling.

Comment: During Covid, cancer patients now face lonely fight

Cancer patients and their families are forced to adapt to harsh complications for an already difficult fight.

Experience shows security for mail-in ballots

President Trump has shared concerns and threats about the validity of mail-in… Continue reading

Most Read