The Seattle Mariners acquired their starting catcher for the 2019 season and beyond on Friday morning in what was expected to be a busy day of transactions.
While the much of the baseball world is focused on the expected trade where the Mariners would send second basemen Robinson Cano and closer Edwin Diaz — both All-Stars — to the New York Mets for a collection of players, Seattle attended to a glaring need for the upcoming season.
The Mariners acquired catcher Omar Narvaez from the White Sox in exchange for right-handed set-up man Alex Colome.
Narvaez, 26, posted a .275/.366/.429 slash line with 14 doubles, a triple, nine homers and 30 RBI in 97 games for the White Sox. He was worth 2.1 WAR per Fangraphs in 2018. The left-handed hitting catcher has a career .366 on-base percentage in 221 Major League Baseball games.
He’s a candidate for a platoon role at the position. He’s got a career .285/.366/.392 slash line vs. right-handed pitching and a .222/.366/.315 slash line vs. left-handed pitchers. His on-base percentage is not hindered by splits, which is a plus.
From a defensive standpoint, he’s about average if not below average. Opposing scouts said he’s not a liability, but not close to the catcher he’s replacing — Mike Zunino.
Narvaez is a bargain. He will make the league minimum in 2019 before entering three years of arbitration eligibility starting in 2020.
“Omar has quietly developed into one of the tougher outs among catchers in MLB, his contact and on-base skills are welcome additions to our lineup,” Seattle general manager Jerry Dipoto said in statement. “The fact that he is also under club control through 2022 made him a great fit for our club.”
Having traded Zunino to the Rays earlier in the offseason, the Mariners needed to fill an open roster spot at catcher. The only catcher they had on their 40-man roster was back-up David Freitas. Seattle could still add another catcher, preferably a right-handed hitter, via free agency on a one-year contract or even on a minor league contract. There isn’t much in the way of depth in the organization since they allowed Chris Herrmann to be claimed waivers by the Astros.
Since the Mariners are in stepback mode, Colome was always a likely trade candidate. There is no need for a high leverage set-up man making significant dollars, particularly when you are also trading your closer as well. Colome was solid in his role for Seattle after being acquired from the Rays on May 25 along with outfielder Denard Span.
A closer with the Rays, Colome accepted his lesser role and flourished, posting a 5-0 record and one save with a 2.53 earned-run average in 47 appearances for Seattle. Colome made $5.3 million in 2018, but has two more years of club control. He was estimated to make more than $7 million next season in his second year of arbitration eligibility.