POLL: One-batter starters: good strategy or bush league?

What do you think about Milwaukee manager Craig Counsell’s unique maneuver in Game 5 of the NLCS?

Let’s do something just a little bit different this week.

In Game 5 of the National League Championship Series between the Los Angeles Dodgers and Milwaukee Brewers last Wednesday, the Brewers sent left-handed pitcher Wade Miley out to start the game. Miley pitched to one batter, walking Dodgers leadoff man Cody Bellinger, then was immediately removed in favor of right-hander Brandon Woodruff, who threw the next 5.1 frames. During the game it was announced that Miley would be the starter again two days later in Game 6.

This maneuver created huge waves in the baseball world. Never before had something like this ever been done in a playoff or World Series game.

The logic behind it is this. Dodgers manager Dave Roberts essentially had two lineups he used during the NLCS, a left-handed lineup that he used against right-handed starting pitchers and a right-handed lineup he fielded against left-handed pitchers as he tried to leverage a deep roster to maximize his platoon advantage. What Milwaukee manager Craig Counsell did was devise a method for countering that, enticing Roberts to put together a right-handed lineup, then immediately bring in a right-hander so that Milwaukee would either have the platoon advantage or force Roberts to burn up his bench early in the game.

On one hand, this is good strategy. The Brewers, for whom starting pitching was not a strength, basically played the series without any starting pitchers. Milwaukee’s starters combined to throw 20.1 innings in the series’ seven games, which is an average of eight outs a start. The Brewers instead relied on a deep and capable bullpen which Counsell could use to get favorable matchups and prevent Los Angeles’ batters from seeing a pitcher more than once in a game. This was just the extreme example of this.

On the other hand, this goes against more than a century of baseball tradition. The way baseball has always worked is that teams name their starting pitchers for upcoming games, and the opposing teams then set their lineups based on the pitcher they’re facing. This maneuver went against tradition, and I heard many a traditionalist rail against Counsell’s gimmicky way of flouting the unwritten rules of the sport.

One can argue whether the strategy worked or not. Woodruff gave the Brewers 5.1 strong innings of relief. But the Dodgers may have suspected something was up as Roberts had two lefties in his starting lineup (Woodruff had to be warming up before the game somewhere that was visible, didn’t he?), and Los Angeles won the game 5-2 behind Clayton Kershaw. The Dodgers ended up winning the series in Game 7 to advance to the World Series against the Boston Red Sox.

I’m curious to find out what the public thinks of this. Was this a moment of strategic brilliance from Counsell, or was it a case of Counsell being bush league? Have your say here:


Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Sports

Everett’s Alana Washington poses for a photo at Everett High School on March 24, 2024 in Everett, Washington. (Annie Barker / The Herald)
The Herald’s 2023-24 Girls Basketball Player of the Year: Alana Washington

The Everett senior upped her game in the postseason to help the Seagulls overcome injuries and claim their first state trophy in 41 years.

Left to right, Arlington’s Samara Morrow, Kamiak’s Bella Hasan, Everett’s Alana Washington, Lake Steven’s Nisa Ellis, Lynnwood’s Aniya Hooker, and Meadowdale’s Gia Powell, pose for a photo at Everett High School on March 24, 2024 in Everett, Washington. (Annie Barker / The Herald)
The Herald’s 2023-24 All-Area girls basketball teams

A look at the top prep girls basketball players in the area from the 2023-24 season.

Silvertips players celebrate during a game between the Everett Silvertips and Tri-City Americans at the Angel of the Winds Arena on Sunday, Jan. 21, 2024. The Silvertips won, 5-3. (Annie Barker / The Herald)
Silvertips land No. 1 pick, chance to draft generational talent

Landon DuPont is the consensus top pick in next WHL prospects draft. Everett chief operating officer Zoran Rajcic said the team intends to select him.

Dennis Williams, head coach and GM of the Everett Silvertips, shakes hands with an assistant coach at the end of a season opening victory over the Vancouver Giants on Saturday, Sep. 24, 2022, at Angel of the Winds Arena in Everett, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Coach, GM Williams leaving Silvertips for Bowling Green State

After seven successful season leading Everett, Dennis Williams is heading back to his alma mater. He’ll stay with the Tips through the WHL playoffs.

Mountlake Terrace’s Jaxon Dubiel talks with head coach Nalin Sood during the 3A boys state basketball game against Todd Beamer on Wednesday, Feb. 28, 2024 in Tacoma, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
‘It was just time’: Mountlake Terrace basketball coach Sood steps down

Nalin Sood guided his alma mater to 381 wins and 15 state berths in 24 seasons as head coach. He spent over four decades with the program.

Stanwood High School student athletes during their signing day ceremony. (Courtesy of Stanwood High School)
Local class of 2024 athletes who have signed to play in college

A running list of 2024 high school athletes who are set to compete at the next level.

X
Prep roundup for Tuesday, March 26

Prep roundup for Tuesday, March 26: (Note for coaches/scorekeepers: To report results… Continue reading

Silvertips’ Kaden Hammell (47) enters the rink during a game between the Everett Silvertips and the Tri-City Americans at the Angel of the Winds Arena on Sunday, March 24, 2024 in Everett, Washington. (Annie Barker / The Herald)
Patterson: Overachieving Silvertips had season worth celebrating

In a season when some thought the team’s playoff streak could end, Everett put together one of its greatest campaigns.

Washington State athletic director Pat Chun, center, watches players on the first day of NCAA college football practice, Friday, Aug. 6, 2021, in Pullman, Wash. (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren)
Washington hires AD Chun away from rival Washington State

UW quickly targeted its in-state rival’s athletic director after Troy Dannen’s sudden departure.

Seattle Mariners' Mitch Haniger hits a single against the San Diego Padres during the fourth inning of a spring training baseball game Monday, March 11, 2024, in Peoria, Ariz. (AP Photo/Lindsey Wasson)
Why the Mariners could win the AL West, and what could hold them back

Starting pitching, a renovated offense and regression in the AL West are in Seattle’s favor, but injury issues, bullpen concerns and the Houston Astros could be a problem.

X
Vote for The Herald’s Prep Athlete of the Week for March 18-24

The Athlete of the Week nominees for March 18-24. Voting closes at… Continue reading

X
Prep roundup for Wednesday, March 27

Prep roundup for Wednesday, March 27: (Note for coaches/scorekeepers: To report results… Continue reading

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.