Governments take first, tentative steps at regulating AI

Can we control artificial intelligence’s potential for disrupting markets? Time will tell.

One of the earliest accounts of technology control appears in ancient Greek mythology in the story of Prometheus, who stole fire from the gods and gave it to humans. This stolen gift enabled the development of human civilization.

We humans are now attempting to control a new technology, artificial intelligence, and it is fair to wonder if we will be more successful than the Greek gods were.

State legislatures in New York and New Jersey have proposed legislation that represents the first, tentative steps at regulation. While the two proposed laws are different, they both have elements of information gathering about the risks to such things as privacy, security and economic fairness.

Both states owe a debt to the New York City’s efforts to understand what AI is, exactly, so it could be defined in law. The initial group established by the City Council could not agree on a definition, which may explain why some of the proposed laws aim at algorithm-based decisions rather than the broader concept of AI. This may be a good start to regulating the use of algorithms in the stock market – the city’s primary interest — but clearly leaves a lot undone.

New York State’s legislative action still lacks the governor’s signature, but that is likely. There is no real controversy about this law since its only action would be to create the New York State Artificial Intelligence, Robotics and Automation Commission.

Among the subjects that the commission would report on is a key economics issue: “The impact of AI, robotics and automation on employment in New York state. That should stir up enough controversy to satisfy the politicians that there were important constituencies interested in AI.

The New Jersey proposal is a different animal entirely. It is basically a consumer protection move that would require certain businesses to assess and report the risk to consumers posed by their company’s data collection and use of algorithms or otherwise automated decision systems. Businesses subject to this would be those with more than $50 million in annual revenue, possess or control personal data on over 1 million New Jersey consumers, their computers or mobile phones. The legislation would also include all data brokers, irrespective of size.

It is not clear whether either approach, New York’s or New Jersey’s, is likely to serve as a pattern for other states or cities considering AI regulatory legislation.

All the legislative efforts so far reflect a general uncertainty about what AI is and what about it, if anything, should be regulated. It is all mixed up with the growing distrust of so-called “big tech” and, more generally, with the public’s sometimes puzzling attitude toward AI.

Mark Twain wrote about a puzzlement of human behavior nearly a century and a half ago in his book. “The Adventures of Tom Sawyer.” In one episode Tom had been tasked by his Aunt Polly with whitewashing the fence around the house. And, of course, other kids cane to watch him work. Instead of complaining about the chore, Tom seemed to be enjoying himself so much that they wanted to help and get in on the fun. Eventually, after the other kids began to offer trade goods in exchange for a turn with the brush Tom relented and accepted their work and their payment.

It’s a funny story, and a revealing one from a behavioral theory standpoint. What was happening was that boys who would do anything to avoid a job like whitewashing eagerly paid to do same work – a puzzle, surely.

It would be reassuring, but inaccurate, to say that our behavior today is much more rational. But consider robots as an example. We whine and complain when forced to talk to a robot that answers a customer service phone. But we eagerly pay money to talk to a robot installed in our home. Another puzzle.

The potential economic impact of AI is huge and may also be very disruptive. And it goes well beyond robots taking our jobs. Our financial markets, for example, require participants with offsetting views in order to find equilibrium points and any kind of order. Even on the stock market’s darkest days every sale is matched to a purchase. For every seller that thinks that a stock will go down there has to be a buyer who thinks it will go up. That is how a market system works.

If all market participants, large and small, are using similar AI systems to manage their portfolios, though, even the smallest market twitch could thrust the entire system into all-sellers or all-buyers. Is there a way to regulate this in order to prevent disruptive or disastrous volatility? We don’t know yet, but we’d better find out.

Talk to us

More in Herald Business Journal

Double Barrel owner Lionel Madriz places a wine sale sign outside of his business on Friday, Nov. 19, 2021 in Snohomish, Wa. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Job-seekers today are choosy, forcing employers to adapt

If they even show up, prospective employees are calling the shots. First question: What’s the pay?

Local aero firms get $4.5 million from feds to protect jobs

Federal Aviation Manufacturing Jobs Protection Program grants were awarded to six Snohomish County employers.

Homes in The Point subdivision border the construction of the Go East Corp. landfill on Wednesday, Nov. 10, 2021 in Everett, Wa. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Mudslide briefly stalls housing project at former Everett landfill

The slide buried two excavators in September. Work has resumed to make room for nearly 100 new houses.

FAA Administrator Steve Dickson speaks to lawmakers as Michael Stumo, holding a photo of his daughter Samya Rose Stumo, and his wife Nadia Milleron, sit behind him during a Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation hearing on the implementation of aviation safety reform at the US Capitol in Washington on Wednesday, Nov. 3, 2021. Samya Stumo was among those killed in a Boeing 737 Max 8 crash in 2019. (AP Photo/Amanda Andrade-Rhoades)
Democrats push FAA for action against certain Boeing 737 Max employees

Rep. Rick Larsen co-signed the letter stating concerns over the “absence of rigorous accountability.”

FILE - In this June 12, 2017, file photo, a Boeing 787 airplane being built for Norwegian Air Shuttle is shown at Boeing Co.'s assembly facility, in Everett, Wash. Boeing is dealing with a new production problem involving its 787 jet, in which inspections have found flaws in the way that sections of the rear of the plane were joined together. Boeing said Tuesday, Sept. 8, 2020, it's not an immediate safety risk but could cause the planes to age prematurely. (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren, File)
FAA memo reveals more Boeing 787 manufacturing defects

The company said the problems do not present an immediate safety-of-flight issue.

Ameé Quiriconi, Snohomish author, podcaster and entrepreneur.  (Kevin Clark / The Herald)
Snohomish author’s handbook charts a course for female entrepreneurs

She’s invented sustainable concrete, run award-winning wedding venues and worked in business… Continue reading

A final environmental cleanup is set to begin next year at the ExxonMobil and ADC properties, neighboring the Port of Everett. Photo courtesy of the Washington State Department of Ecology.
Port of Everett to get $350K for its costs in soil clean-up

The end is finally in sight for a project to scrub petroleum from two waterfront parcels, owned by ExxonMobil and ADC.

Shawn Loring, owner of Lazy Boy Brewing, received $10,000 through Everett's federal CARES Act funding.  (Kevin Clark / The Herald)
Everett, Snohomish breweries to open on Everett waterfront

Lazy Boy Brewing and Sound to Summit see a bright future at the port’s Waterfront Place.

A woman walks by models of Boeing Co. aircraft, including the manufacturer's new Boeing 777X, at the Dubai Air Show in Dubai, United Arab Emirates, Wednesday, Nov. 17, 2021. (AP Photo/Jon Gambrell)
India’s Akasa Air buys engines worth $4.5 billion for new 737 Maxs

Boeing clinched a deal at the Dubai Air Show to sell 72 of the jets for some $9 billion.

FAA Administrator Steve Dickson speaks to lawmakers as Michael Stumo, holding a photo of his daughter Samya Rose Stumo, and his wife Nadia Milleron, sit behind him during a Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation hearing on the implementation of aviation safety reform at the US Capitol in Washington on Wednesday, Nov. 3, 2021. Samya Stumo was among those killed in a Boeing 737 Max 8 crash in 2019. (AP Photo/Amanda Andrade-Rhoades)
FAA says Boeing is appointing people lacking expertise to oversee airplane certification

The company was replacing senior FAA-authorized engineers who took early retirement during the pandemic.

FILE - In this Wednesday, July 17, 2019, file photo, Rep. Angie Craig, D-Minn., center, talks with Paul Njoroge, right, who lost his wife and three young children, as Michael Stumo, left, who lost his daughter, looks on before the start of a House Transportation subcommittee hearing on aviation safety, on Capitol Hill in Washington. The year since the crash of an Ethiopian Airlines Boeing 737 Max has been a journey through grief, anger and determination for the families of those who died, as well as having far-reaching consequences for the aeronautics industry as it brought about the grounding of all Boeing 737 Max 8 and 9 jets, which remain out of service. (AP Photo/Susan Walsh, File)
Boeing settles with Ethiopia 737 Max crash victims

The agreement allows victims’ families to pursue claims in U.S. courts instead of their home country.

Dennie Willard, a Navy veteran, became homeless in 2014 and began job training through HopeWorks at Renew Home and Decor. (Kevin Clark / The Herald)
Looking for his ‘last job,’ veteran found new work, new life

U.S. Navy veteran Dennis Willard, once homeless, now works for the nonprofit that helped him.