Pinup Girl, Man in the Mask and Dollface are back 10 years later to terrorize a family in “The Strangers: Prey at Night.” (Brian Douglas, Aviron Pictures)

Pinup Girl, Man in the Mask and Dollface are back 10 years later to terrorize a family in “The Strangers: Prey at Night.” (Brian Douglas, Aviron Pictures)

‘The Strangers: Prey at Night’: Cheesy horror simple, stupid

Director Bryan Bertino sticks to the simple filmmaking mantra that has guided so many before him.

  • Friday, March 9, 2018 1:30am
  • Life

By Michael O’Sullivan

The Washington Post

A follow-up to the 2008 cult horror hit “The Strangers,” “The Strangers: Prey at Night” isn’t really a sequel, at least not in the generally accepted sense of the word. Rather than advancing the story — about a couple who is terrorized by three masked assailants wielding knives and an ax — “Prey at Night” merely repeats that winning formula, swapping out the first film’s victims, played by Liv Tyler and Scott Speedman, for two new characters.

“Characters” is such a strong word.

Teenage Luke (Lewis Pullman) and his younger sister, Kinsey (Bailee Madison), aren’t so much people as pawns, fresh meat that just keeps getting pushed around an increasingly blood-soaked chessboard — here, an empty, dimly lit trailer park, just off the exit for Godforsaken Nowhere. During a stopover with their parents on the way to drop Kinsey off at boarding school, they’re stalked by the same trio of theatrical psychopaths we met 10 years ago: two young women in Halloween masks, known as Dollface and Pinup Girl (Emma Bellomy and Lea Enslin, respectively), and a man (Damian Maffei) with a burlap sack over his head, emblazoned with a crude, scarecrow face. (He’s identified in the credits, less poetically, as the Man in the Mask.) Mom and Dad, played by Christina Hendricks and Martin Henderson, get dispatched fairly quickly, along with some vague, never-specified backstory about Kinsey’s troubled past.

You’ve got to give credit to Bryan Bertino, who wrote and directed the first film on a shoestring budget of $9 million, and who co-wrote this one (with Ben Ketai) before handing the reins to director Johannes Roberts (“47 Meters Down”). At least he sticks to the filmmaking mantra that has guided so many horror auteurs before him: Keep it simple, stupid. You won’t get any bells and whistles here.

In this case, unfortunately, Roberts has opted to keep it simple and stupid, eschewing recognizable human behavior for set pieces that look good but make no rational sense. One lurid, extended sequence takes place in and around a neon-lit swimming pool, where the Man in the Mask goes after Luke, ultimately injuring him, amid an expanding plume of blood, in the aquamarine water. Of course, all that beautiful, if garish, cinematography would have been for naught if Luke had held on to the gun he found a few moments earlier, instead of tossing it away, inexplicably.

Speaking of inexplicable, that attack is set to the song “Total Eclipse of the Heart,” by Bonnie Tyler, which blares from the park’s PA system, in an attempt at — I don’t know, irony? An homage to the golden age of cheese-ball slasher movies? Other soundtrack offerings include such 1980s power ballads as “Kids in America” by Kim Wilde and Air Supply’s “Making Love Out of Nothing at All.” Talk about scary.

Despite such flashes of originality, the whole thing has the air of a cynical, low-quality knockoff of something that wasn’t very good to begin with. In the first film, when Tyler’s character confronts Dollface, asking her why she’s doing this, the answer comes back, jaded and unsettling: “Because you were home.”

In “Prey at Night,” when Kinsey asks the same question, Dollface’s response betrays not only her own apathy, but the film’s profound laziness: “Why not?”

“The Strangers: Prey at Night” (1 1/2 stars)

A family’s road trip takes a dangerous turn when they arrive at a secluded mobile home park to stay with some relatives and find it mysteriously deserted.

Rated R. Contains horror violence and terror throughout, and coarse language

Showing: Alderwood Mall, Everett Stadium, Galaxy Monroe, Marysville, Meridian, Pacific Place, Thornton Place, Woodinville, Cascade Mall

Talk to us

More in Life

Don Sarver, left, and Kyle James, right, snowshoe on the Skyline Lake Trail on Saturday, Jan. 26, 2019 in Leavenworth, Wa. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Avoiding avalanches: How to know and where to go

Follow these tips for researching on-the-ground conditions from comfort of your home or local library.

The parenting journey takes you on an adventurous path at each stage of your child’s development. (Jennifer Bardsley)
Growing up: The ages and stages of raising your children

One minute your child is the baby in your arms, and the next minute, they’ve just landed their first job.

Dr. Paul on struggles with parenthood during the pandemic

It’s esspecially challenging if you have kids with special needs, you’re single or you have lost your job.

Arcos, Spain, where locals “see the backs of the birds as they fly.”
Arcos de la Frontera: Nuns’ cupcakes and donkeys in the bell tower

Rick Steves on connecting with the culture of small-town Spain — and creating treasured memories.

This BritRail pass refund request has gone off the rails

Stephen Wilkes asks his travel agent for a BritRail pass refund. But six months later, there’s no sign of the money.

Book-related events in Snohomish County.
Author events and poetry readings around Snohomish County

The listings include Third Place Books, Everett Public Library and Neverending Bookshop events.

The Camano Wildlife Habitat Project is hosting a “Living With a Green Roof” webinar on March 17 via Zoom. (Getty Images)
Outdoors classes and activities around Snohomish County

The listings include Mount Baker-Snoqualmie National Forest updates and REI Lynnwood workshops.

Dave Dodge stands on a speaker while playing his guitar during Nite Wave's show at Tony V's Garage on Saturday, June 8, 2019 in Everett, Wash. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
1980s new wave streams when Bothell cover band performs

Hear Bothell’s own Nite Wave rock out at the “Best ’80s Party Ever!” on Feb. 27 via Facebook.

If you're a gardener who just can't wait for spring, winter-blooming pansies will tide you over. (Getty Images)
Do you suffer from the spring condition ‘hortitostrogenitis’?

It’s a made-up word for the feeling you get when it’s not yet March, but you’re itching to get back into the garden.

Most Read