Hung Bui (left), fights back tears with daughter Anny Bui during the sentencing for Allen Ivanov who shot and killed Bui’s daughter Anna, along with two others, at a house party in Mukilteo on July 30, 2016. Ivanov was sentenced to life in prison in Snohomish County Superior Court in Everett on Thursday morning. (Ian Terry / The Herald)

Grief fills a courtroom as mass shooter is sentenced to life

EVERETT — Will Kramer bears the scars of violence.

The Mukilteo teen was shot in the back the night three of his friends were killed by their former Kamiak High School classmate. Kramer ran for safety as gunfire filled the Mukilteo house where friends were spending a warm July evening hanging out and catching up after what for many had been their first year in college.

“I’ve personally been affected in countless ways by this coward that sits before us,” Kramer wrote in a letter to Superior Court Judge Janice Ellis ahead of Thursday’s sentencing hearing.

“From the seventeen days spent in the hospital with tubes inside of me to endless nightmares and thoughts that poison my faith in humanity. However, this is nothing compared to the emptiness I feel as a result of my dear friends’ deaths. I miss them so much. They were the best of us, and I cannot put into words how shameful and pathetic it is that their lives ended because of one small man’s insecurities,” Kramer wrote.

That man, Allen Ivanov, was sentenced Thursday to life behind bars without the possibility of release. It was the only sentence available under the law.

The July 30 gunfire lasted only about 35 seconds. It touched so many lives that the courtroom was filled beyond capacity and some people watched the proceedings from a video feed in another room.

Ivanov, 20, read a prepared statement Thursday. He apologized repeatedly.

“There is no justification for what I did. … I am so, so sorry for causing all of you to be here today,” he said.

Ellis announced the sentence after absorbing nearly three hours of testimony from people who lost family or friends.

The judge listed all the varieties of sadness that people shared Thursday, “the incomprehensible emotions and the horrifying facts; the irreparable harm suffered and the indescribable pain; the ripping away of so much, and the world turned upside down.”

“Mr. Ivanov, this is what you have done,” she said. “Your actions are heinous. They are unpardonable.”

As she spoke, Ivanov sat with eyes downcast, his expression unreadable.

Ivanov pleaded guilty Dec. 19 to three counts of aggravated first-degree murder and two counts of attempted murder. The move came the day before Prosecuting Attorney Mark Roe was scheduled to announce whether he would seek the death penalty.

Roe agreed not to pursue capital punishment. In exchange, Ivanov waived his right to a trial as well as an appeal of his sentence.

The former University of Washington Bothell student admitted killing his former girlfriend, Anna Bui, and acquaintances Jacob Long and Jordan Ebner, all 19. He’s also acknowledged trying to murder Kramer and shooting at other young men as they ran for cover.

Kramer was in the first row of the courtroom Thursday. His father, Paul Kramer, told the judge how grateful he was that his son survived the assault by a person he described as a “completely defective human being” and a “deranged coward.”

“It is incomprehensible how a young man from our community could do something like this,” Paul Kramer said.

Alex Levin was seated outside the house with Will Kramer, Long and Ebner when the gunfire erupted. As he scrambled for safety, he felt the heat of a bullet as it narrowly missed him.

Accompanied by a service dog, Levin told the judge Thursday that he can’t explain why he lived and his friends did not. He spoke of how his memories of the good times they shared now often are crowded out by the memories of the violence that claimed them.

He listed all of the things that they will never share: weddings; the birth of children; the day-to-day joys of being alive.

“And I will not be able to tell them just one more time how much I love them,” he added.

Prior to the gunfire, Ivanov wrote a six-page letter, explaining his motivation. He was upset over Bui moving on with life after their breakup.

“I’m selfish. That’s why I did this,” he wrote.

On Thursday, Ivanov suggested that he opened fire at the party as some sort of spontaneous and confused act. He also pointed the finger at current gun laws, saying they need to be changed.

“It was the ease of accessing a gun that allowed me to act on my emotions,” he said.

Ivanov bought a Ruger brand AR-15-style rifle as well as two magazines carrying 30 rounds apiece in the days before the shootings. He told friends he was thinking about harming Bui. They urged him to seek help and to get rid of the gun.

He later told detectives that he’d never fired the weapon before using it to kill at the house party.

Longtime attorney Walter Peale, who served on Ivanov’s defense team, told the court that he’s convinced Ivanov feels remorse. He said the defense team was focused on trying to keep their client alive. He said he was grateful that prosecutors entertained the plea agreement, resolving the case without trial and dodging a potential death sentence.

While awaiting trial, Ivanov wrote rap lyrics about the “murder game,” and appeared to directly reference the Mukilteo shootings. The lyrics became public when he enlisted his mother’s help in mailing them to a convicted killer he met while they both were awaiting trial in the county jail. Inmate mail is screened.

“Words can’t express the sheer rage I felt when I heard about the ‘rap’ lyrics Allen Ivanov had written, boasting about the crime,” Ebner’s stepmom wrote in a letter to the judge.

“Watching him wink at his mother in court and not being able to say or do anything left me feeling helpless. We are the victims, yet he seems to have all the rights in court,” Nicole Ebner wrote.

In her letter she described the anguish of watching her husband grieve for his son. “Many nights, he falls asleep in Jordan’s bed, wrapped in his favorite blanket,” she wrote.

Brad Ebner on Thursday called Ivanov a coward with a gun.

“He took my first, my first boy,” he said.

Autumn Snider brought the urn containing her son’s ashes to the courtroom. Jacob Long was gifted with intelligence, athletic ability and a knack for making people smile.

“Jacob’s gone. He is dead. Allen killed him,” she said, resting her hand on the urn.

Anny Bui told the judge that Ivanov had betrayed the trust she placed in him to keep her sister safe. Her sister wanted to spend her life helping others as a nurse.

Their family’s sense of security was stolen from them, Bui’s brother David wrote. “Nothing can be done to mend our wounds.”

The Bui family came to the U.S. from Vietnam. Her father sobbed openly in the courtroom Thursday and later spoke through an interpreter about a daughter lost. He urged young people to seek out help when confronted by what may appear to be overwhelming problems.

Deputy prosecutor Adam Cornell said Ivanov’s crimes were an attack on the community, and those who spoke for justice Thursday had demonstrated the community’s conscience.

The prosecutor paraphrased novelist Ernest Hemingway when he offered a benediction of hope. Sometimes things break us, Cornell said, but afterward we may grow stronger in the broken places.

Scott North: 425-339-3431; north@heraldnet.com. Twitter: @snorthnews.

Talk to us

More in Local News

Brace for delays along U.S. 2 for bridge and road work

Projects between Snohomish and Index are set for the coming week, with single-lane traffic in spots.

2020 primary election results for Snohomish County

Returns for contested races and ballot measures, updated daily as mail-in ballots are counted.

Memorial honors fallen Bothell police officer Jonathan Shoop

After a motorcade through the city, the rookie cop’s two brothers spoke at a service Tuesday in Bothell.

Appointees leading in area legislative races; few close ones

It was a solid night for incumbents, with more than half the expected ballots counted.

Mead and Carrington lead in Snohomish County Council race

Incumbent PUD Commissioner Sid Logan will likely face Rob Toyer for a spot on the utility board.

Police: Boy, 12, fights off kidnapper south of Everett

A suspect, 44, was tracked down and arrested Tuesday by Snohomish County sheriff’s deputies.

Man identified as the deceased in Bothell police shooting

Court records show Juan Rene Hummel Jr., 25, had a history of mental health issues.

Jen Hirman and her daughter Elizabeth, who attends Jackson High, waves signs along Evergreen Way in support of the Everett schools levy on Monday, Aug. 3, 2020 in Everett, Wa. (Andy Bronson / The Herald)
School levies are in trouble in Lakewood and Darrington

Everett’s $317 million bond proposal is within striking distance, but levies could go down in the north county.

Everett school bond loses ground in latest tally of ballots

Some good news in Lakewood where the district’s two-year technology levy inched closer to passage

Most Read