HOT lanes may not be so hot

The Most Interesting Man in the World doesn’t always use the carpool lanes on I-405, but when he does later this fall, he’s going to want to have a Good to Go Flex Pass.

You might have read the account earlier in the week about a driver in an I-5 carpool lane in Tacoma who was stopped by a State Patrol trooper because his “passenger” was a cardboard cutout of the distinguished and adventurous Dos Equis spokesman known as The Most Interesting Man in the World. After the stop, TMIMW’s driver drove off, still in possession of his best friend and a $124 ticket for the carpool lane violation.

Actually, the flex pass, a transponder installed in your vehicle, wouldn’t have done the cardboard cutout or his driver much good; only living people count as carpool passengers. But the state Transportation Commission, in adopting new rules for the 17 miles of carpool lanes on I-405 between Lynnwood and Bellevue that begin this fall, may have created a market for the cardboard pals.

Rather than keep the High Occupancy Vehicle lanes as originally intended as an encouragement for motorists to carpool, the Transportation Commission has instead gone with rules that regard the lanes as a revenue source. As explained by Herald Street Smarts columnist Melissa Sager, the High Occupancy Toll lanes will be open to drivers with two or more passengers and to any driver with one or no passengers who is willing to pay a toll.

To use the lanes, drivers will need to carry a Good to Go Flex Pass transponder in their vehicles, which they will have to flip between two modes: one for a carpool with two or more passengers, the other to pay the toll.

Simple? It gets more complicated.

The amount of the toll will fluctuate between 75 cents and $10, increasing in cost as the traffic gets heavier, although transportation officials believe the average toll will be about $4. Tolls will be paid through a pre-paid Good to Go account.

The Flex Pass transponder costs $15, although some who regularly carpool on I-405 may qualify for a free transponder.

In December, we suggested that the Transportation Commission seek a more streamlined system than this, but we might as well have been talking to a cardboard cutout.

We’ll try again: If it is the intention of the Transportation Commission to extend this program to other carpool lanes on state highways and interstates, in particular, I-5 and I-90, then it ought to use the I-405 program as a case study. It should gather as much information as it can about the lanes’ use and acceptance by motorists, about lane infractions, revenue vs. costs and comments from those who depend on I-405 daily to get between work and home.

If the Flex Pass proves to be a hindrance to carpools, and its success as a revenue source is negligible, then the transponders ought to be left at the side of the road with the cardboard cutouts.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

A state Climate Commmitment Act map shows projects funded by the act's carbon auctions.
Editorial: Climate Commitment Act a two-fer for Washington

Its emissions auctions put price on carbon and use that revenue for climate investments.

toon
Editorial cartoons for Saturday, Dec. 20

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Comment: State funding cuts would devastate long-term care

The Legislature should at least maintain Medicaid funding for nursing facilities at current levels.

Comment: No trust due an administration that ended river pact

The White House killed a negotiated deal to save salmon. The rivers’ protectors must return to court.

Comment: $20-an-hour pay for fast food workers will kill jobs

To protect employment, other states should avoid adopting California’s 2024 wage law.

Charles Adkins
Forum: To make investments we need, wealthy can pay fair share

As state lawmakers consider budgets, they should reconsider proposals for more progressive taxes.

Water from the Snohomish River surrounds a residence along the west side of Lowell Snohomish River Road on Thursday, Dec. 11, 2025 in Snohomish, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Editorial: Keep eye on weather and on FEMA’s future

Recent flooding should give pause to those who believe federal disaster aid is unnecessary.

toon
Editorial cartoons for Friday, Dec. 19

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Schwab: What best fits a diagnosis of derangement?

Could it be vile attacks on the victims of tragedy? Vilification of immigrants? Economic denial?

Saunders: A plus for Trump 2.0: Far less firing among his staff

Turnover in the White House in his second term is far lower than his first. The stability is welcome.

Comment: A busy year for Trump, with far more lows than highs

A ceasefire holds in Gaza, and the southern border is quiet, but the economy is not ‘A-plus-plus-plus-plus.’

Comment: Oregon senator has plan to make Senate work better

Sen. Jeff Merkey doesn’t want to end the filibuster; he just wants to return it to its ‘Mr. Smith’ roots.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.