Replacing state sales tax with income tax would bring fairness

The Herald’s March 31 editorial “Boost to revenue, tax fairness” addresses the horrible regressive tax system in Washington state. The solutions it proposes would somewhat mitigate this by increasing the taxes on higher-income people, particularly by introducing a capital gains tax to increase much-needed revenue. The capital gains tax is not a great solution, mainly because people can choose when to take capital gains.

The biggest problem with our tax system is that the sales tax imposes a very high burden on lower-income people, because most lower-income people must spend all of their income for basic living expenses, much of which is subject to the sales tax. The only way to relieve the tax burden for low-income people is to eliminate or at least significantly reduce the sales tax, and the best way to recover the revenue lost from this is to implement a graduated income tax.

I know that Washingtonians have rejected an income tax in the past, most recently by defeating I-1098. This was defeated mainly because a few billionaires spent millions on negative and misleading ads so they could avoid the tax on their huge incomes. However, a major deficiency of the initiative was that reduced property taxes, and did nothing to reduce the sales tax burden.

If we are to effectively reform the tax system, we need to replace the sales tax with an income tax. A well-designed income tax would reduce taxes for lower and middle-income people while providing adequate revenue for the state. We shouldn’t let rich people avoid paying their fair share by imposing taxes on the poor and middle class.

Jerry Fraser

Snohomish

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

2024 Presidential Election Day Symbolic Elements.
Editorial: A recap of Herald Editorial Board endorsements

By The Herald Editorial Board Voters, open up your ballots and voters… Continue reading

The Buzz: We leave for a few days and all hell breaks loose

OK, it was breaking loose long before our vacation, but, still, somebody actually gave Trump a crown?

Schwab: Trump lives the life of a flexible dog, because he can

With a pliant Congress and Court, the president finds every impulse easily bent to his whims.

Comment: A hunger for leadership, compassion as SNAP snaps shut

There’s plenty of blame to go around, most of all for President Trump’s bullying of his opponents.

‘No sit, no lie’ ordinance hasn’t solved anything in Everett

Everett’s “no sit, no lie” buffer zone ordinance was intended to address… Continue reading

Salmon, orca need healthy Columbia, Snake rivers

A recent commentary (“Scuttling Columbia Basin pact ignores peril to salmon,” The… Continue reading

Why are cities seeking more growth and traffic?

The candidates running for office keep telling us we need more growth.… Continue reading

toon
Editorial cartoons for Thursday, Oct. 31

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Comment: Trump, GOP holding emergency SNAP funds over politics

Even during the shutdown, emergency funds could sustain food aid. It’s just another attack on SNAP.

Comment: Both parties need to work together to end shutdown

With pay halted for many federal workers and services threatened, only cooperation can reopen government.

Comment: Brace for higher health care costs during open enrollment

Federal reductions in subsidies may be joined by drug costs and other inflation for workers’ insurance plans.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.