Niece cares for her baby sibling at the expense of her social life

Adapted from a recent online discussion.

Dear Carolyn:

My sister and her husband had a baby. They have two older kids ages 17 and 14. The 17-year-old, “Nicole,” is on the shy side and we’ve always had a good relationship. The baby is 6 months, and when I hear Nicole talk about the baby, it almost sounds like her baby, not her parents’. Nicole is responsible for the baby at least three nights a week from the time she gets off school to about midnight, when my sister’s shift ends. Nicole also watches the baby quite a bit on the weekends because the 14-year-old is heavily involved in athletics.

Nicole seems to like it, but has also confided in me that she’s turned down social stuff because she was baby-sitting. Nicole also said from time to time her homework suffered, but she’s not too worried about it.

This is Nicole’s senior year of high school and instead of hanging out with friends she is babysitting. I think this is unfair, and I think Nicole gets overwhelmed, but I don’t think she knows how to tell my sister and brother-in-law that. Can I do anything to help?

— Confided In

You can encourage Nicole to stand up for herself. She’s certainly going to need it. And if she’s caving completely to her parents’ demands, then she’s getting a late start at developing self-determination skills.

But you also don’t want to be just another person cutting in on Nicole’s autonomy. So, draw her out. When she says “she’s turned down social stuff” to baby-sit, you say, “Does that bother you?” or, “Would you rather be out with friends?”

If the answer is yes, then: “Have you said that to your parents?”

If the answer is no, then assure her it’s OK to articulate what she wants and needs. Period — it’s not just about parents and siblings and babysitting.

If the answer is yes, then ask how her parents responded to that.

If she says they responded by not budging, then ask her: “How do you feel about that — do you think it’s appropriate?”

If she expresses unhappiness with their response, then ask: “What do you think you’ll do about that?”

If she expresses qualms about doing anything, then be encouraging on your way to butting out. “That’s your prerogative. You’ll be on your own soon, though, so give some thought to how you’ll handle something like this when it’s not your parents asking.”

This isn’t a script, it’s the demonstration of a point — that you can discuss this with her without actually telling her what to think or do (except the assurances here and there of what’s possible).

The way I’ve laid out the questions, at any given time Nicole can express that she prefers babysitting, or that she shares her parents’ values and sees it as her place/duty/honor to pitch in with the family responsibilities. Which is fine — the important thing here isn’t that Nicole parties with friends, but that Nicole at 17 and graduating soon is at least on the cusp of being able to speak for herself.

© 2017, Washington Post Writers Group

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Life

People parading marching down First Street with a giant balloon “PRIDE” during Snohomish’s inaugural Pride celebration on Saturday, June 3, 2023, in downtown Snohomish, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
What does Pride mean to you? The Herald wants to know.

Local LGBTQ+ folks and allies can share what Pride means to them before May 27.

Emma Corbilla Doody and her husband, Don Doody, inside  their octagonal library at the center of their octagon home on Thursday, May 2, 2024 in Sultan, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Is this Sultan octagon the ugliest house in America?

Emma Corbilla Doody and Don Doody bought the home for $920,000 last year. Not long after, HGTV came calling.

Road Scholar downgrades traveler from business to economy

While booking Maureen Kelleher on a different airline, British Airways also downgraded her. Is she entitled to a refund?

With history, markets and beer, life is good in Germany’s biggest village

Walking through Munich, you’ll understand why it is consistently voted one of Germany’s most livable cities.

What should parents do about a noisy child disturbing others in public?

Although there’s no single right answer, here are some guidelines parents might consider when out with their youngsters.

Music, theater and more: What’s happening in Snohomish County

A Beatles tribute band will rock Everett on Friday, and the annual Whidbey Art Market will held in Coupeville on Mother’s Day.

Mickey Mouse and Buddha are among this bracelet’s 21 charms. But why?

This piece’s eclectic mix of charms must say something about its former owner. Regardless, it sold for $1,206 at auction.

Great Plant Pick: Pond cypress

What: This selection of pond cypress (Taxodium distichum var. imbricatum ‘Nutans’) is… Continue reading

From lilacs to peonies, pretty flowers make the perfect Mother’s Day gift

Carnations may be the official Mother’s Day flower, but many others will also make Mom smile. Here are a few bright ideas.

Maximum towing capacity of the 2024 Toyota Tundra Hybrid is 11,450 pounds, depending on 4x2 or 4x4, trim level, and bed length. The Platinum trim is shown here. (Toyota)
Toyota Tundra Hybrid powertrain overpowers the old V8 and new V6

Updates for the 2024 full-sized pickup include expansion of TRD Off-Road and Nightshade option packages.

2024 Ford Ranger SuperCrew 4X4 XLT (Photo provided by Ford)
2024 Ford Ranger SuperCrew 4X4 XLT

Trucks comes in all shapes and sizes these days. A flavor for… Continue reading

Budget charges me a $125 cleaning fee for the wrong vehicle!

After Budget finds animal hairs in Bernard Sia’s rental car, it charges him a $125 cleaning fee. But Sia doesn’t have a pet.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.