Time for the hard questions

Thirty-four years ago, President Jimmy Carter asked Gov. Dixy Lee Ray what the federal government could do to help after the eruption of Mount St. Helens. Ray literally spelled it out.

“M-o-n-e-y,” she said.

Sunday’s visit by Homeland Security Secretary Jeh Johnson and Federal Emergency Management Agency Administrator Craig Fugate was an opportunity to survey the magnitude of the horror and underline the need for federal resources (see m-o-n-e-y, above.) Johnson said residents affected need to register with FEMA to qualify for federal assistance. Registering with the feds seems an unnatural reflex for the self-reliant souls of Darrington, Oso and Arlington. They should do it anyway.

Today, crews begin building a gravel berm to sluice water from Highway 530. So much work, so much ruin.

From the air, the slide mimics the lahars of Mount St. Helens, a mega natural disaster. What is Oso? Likely a confluence of geology, rains, perhaps logging. We don’t know. Asking why is natural; it also tiptoes around the theme of Russell Banks’ tragic novel, “The Sweet Hereafter” ­­— the irresistible need to blame.

Washington must review likely causes, even if the answers are reduced to basic physics. The state also needs to examine the emergency response and brainstorm prevention, including an inventory of current threats.

In the short term, the emphasis must be on recovery and helping those hit hardest. But soon, perhaps by the end of April, Gov. Jay Inslee will need to appoint a commission to dig into the policy implications: the how, the whys, and the why-not’s.

Turf-conscious politicians adulterate commission outcomes. That must not happen with Oso. A commission limited to non-political actors such as first responders, public policy professionals, scientists and land-use experts, is in the public interest. Only two elected officials who viscerally understand Oso’s impact, Arlington Mayor Barb Tolbert and Darrington Mayor Dan Rankin, should participate. Former White House Cabinet member William Ruckelshaus, a leader with a command of policy and watershed science, would be an ideal commission chair.

One common-sense reform doesn’t require a commission’s review to move forward. As The Herald’s Rikki King reports, Gold Bar fire Chief Eric Andrews, charged with asking for a statewide mobilization of firefighters, was denied help. The reason? A state statute that limits callouts to fires exclusively. It’s a legal anachronism that needs to be amended.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

A Microsoft data center campus in East Wenatchee on Nov. 3. The rural region is changing fast as electricians from around the country plug the tech industry’s new, giant data centers into its ample power supply. (Jovelle Tamayo / The New York Times)
Editorial: Meeting needs for data centers, fair power rates

Shared energy demand for AI and ratepayers requires an increased pace for clean energy projects.

toon
Editorial cartoons for Thursday, Jan. 15

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

State must deliver on promises for state ferry system

Washington State Ferries’ crew shortages continue to cancel crucial sailings on Mukilteo-Clinton… Continue reading

State can’ tax income if robots take jobs

A recent Herald Forum commentary was essentially about how, “Everyone knows that… Continue reading

Comment: What Vance doesn’t get about ‘heritage’ or Americans

Ask the Founders or many who fought for the nation, immigrants are in every sense American.

Comment: Why Trump isn’t likely to back democracy in Venezuela

Based on Trump’s stated desire for control of the country’s oil, his best bet is its current autocracy.

Comment: Are we trending toward another devastating Dust Bowl?

It’s not a certainty, but heat and drought are more frequent in the U.S., upping the odds of the disaster’s return.

toon
Editorial cartoons for Wednesday, Jan. 14

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Tina Ruybal prepares ballots to be moved to the extraction point in the Snohomish County Election Center on Nov. 3, 2025 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Editorial: A win for vote-by-mail, amid gathering concern

A judge preserved the state’s deadline for mailed ballots, but more challenges to voting are ahead.

Burke: Work as a young caddy allowed a swing at life skills

Along with learning blackjack, Yiddish and golf’s finer points, it taught the art of observation.

Comment: From start, nation has relied on little ‘Common Sense’

Paine’s pamphlet laid out the case for independence, principles that the nation needed over its 250 years.

Comment: Wind energy scores win in court, but long fight ahead

A judge ruled against a Trump order to shut down a project, but projects still face his opposition.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.