That catastrophe north of us

Nature is as indifferent to national borders as Americans are consumed by them. The near blackout of U.S. news on the Mount Polley mine disaster near the Cariboo region of British Columbia illustrates the self-involved culture of regional and national media. Why should Northwesterners be concerned about a breached tailings dam up north?

With the notable exception of the Seattlepi.com’s Joel Connelly, a longtime B.C. and enviro watchdog who flagged the coverage issue, the mining catastrophe that began a week ago today is off the radar, supplanted by the primary election, the horrors of the Yazidis in Iraq and the distractions of a bucolic summer.

But the reality of the web of life and threatened sockeye salmon runs, of globalism, and of resonant lessons for lawmakers in the Pacific Northwest should push this man-made disaster to page one.

A once-pristine natural area will never again be the same. According to CBC, the breached tailings pond from the open pit copper and gold mine released 4.5 million cubic meters of metals-laden fine sand and 10 billion liters of water. A 2013 report from the Imperial Metals Corporation/Mount Polley Mine documents more than 406,000 kilograms of arsenic and more than 177,000 kg. of lead (mercury registers at around 3,000 kg.) on site of a pond that, according to the B.C. Ministry of Environment, was essentially drained. B.C and the Environment Ministry are doing what governments are wont to do: Covering their tail on tailings: “Seven geotechnical inspections took place before the mine went into care and maintenance in 2001 and nine geotechnical inspections have taken place since it reopened in March 2005.”

But what about a 2011 environmental consultant’s report, commissioned by Williams Lake First Nation, that there wasn’t a sustainable way to discharge excess water and that the company didn’t have a contingency strategy in the event of a tailings pond failure? Mount Polley demands not only a comprehensive investigation, but genuine safeguards (and consequences for not embracing those safeguards) to minimize future breaches.

The toxic stew in tailings ponds are a tangible reality for anyone who grew up in Montana or Wyoming.

Mount Polley also serves as a wake-up call to Northwest lawmakers not to postpone or ignore environmental warnings (consider the leaking 1940s-era T-111 tanks at the Hanford Nuclear Reservation.)

Victoria’s discharge of untreated sewage into the Salish Sea registers with Washingtonians for obvious reasons. This needs to as well.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

2024 Presidential Election Day Symbolic Elements.
Editorial: Garrard best for Edmonds School Board post

The retired teacher was appointed last year to fill a vacancy and has contributed from the start.

young handsome man in grey sweater sitting on chair isolated on white
Editorial cartoons for Tuesday, Sept. 16

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Friedman: Peace that Trump should seek is in his own land

It’s in his power to call for his political allies and opponents to stand together and speak against violence.

French: Our partisan blindness divides us into warring factions

If you believe the other side is ‘the problem,’ the temptation toward punitive authoritarianism is overwhelming.

Comment: Trump’s crackdown on drug ads good start; more needed

Rolling back rules to earlier standards is good, but the FDA may not have the staffing to enforce it.

Harrop: Murder can’t be erased; why lighten its sentences?

Yes, mental illness by those convicted of violence should be treated. But should release follow?

Stephens: Recognizing Palestine does nothing for Palestinians

It and other virtue signaling that condemns Israel fosters antisemitism and offers no hope for resolution.

FILE — COVID19 vaccines are prepared by a nurse in a mobile vaccine clinic at a senior living facility in McMinnville, Ore., Oct. 6, 2021. A dozen public health experts, along with seven former high-ranking officials, are describing the CDC under the leadership of Robert F. Kennedy Jr. as badly wounded and fast losing its legitimacy, portending harsh consequences for public health. (Alisha Jucevic/The New York Times)
Editorial: Western states take only course on vaccine access

The move assures access to covid vaccines but can’t replace a national policy vital to public health.

An image taken from a website attack advertisement targeting Everett school board member Anna Marie Jackson Laurence. (laurenceletusdown.com)
Editorial: Attack ads an undeserved slander of school official

Ads against an Everett school board candidate are a false and unfair attack on a public servant.

Pedestrians using umbrellas, some Washingtonians use them, as they cross Colby Avenue under pouring rain on Tuesday, Nov. 28, 2017 in Everett, Wa. The forecast through Saturday is cloudy with rain through Saturday. (Andy Bronson / The Herald)
Editorial: Speed limit reductions a good start on safety

Everett is reducing speed limits for two streets; more should follow to save pedestrian lives.

toon
Editorial cartoons for Monday, Sept. 15

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Comment: Trump misses opportunity to soothe instead of inflame

Rather than acting as ‘mourner in chief,’ Trump used Charlie Kirk’s murder to stoke America’s divide.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.