USA: Debate is in our DNA

It’s the Fourth of July, and so, as we stand at our grills and look at rainbow-colored explosions in the sky, let’s also reflect on what makes us the same: our differences.

Don’t worry. This isn’t some after-school special. We’re not going to encourage you to celebrate one another’s partisan beliefs. No, we’re encouraging you to disagree, plain and simple. It’s the American thing to do.

As Joseph J. Ellis wrote in his Pulitzer Prize winning book “Founding Brothers,” America was founded on an argument. From the start, our country was the site of messy struggles between competing ideologies, all aiming to define the concept of freedom.

Those arguments continue today. At times, we’re told that they have never been worse — that our divisions are so severe we can’t accomplish anything anymore. We disagree.

For one, our divisions have always run deep. We have had some terrific and terrible arguments with each other over this country.

Take the classic example of Alexander Hamilton and Aaron Burr, two of Ellis’ “Founding Brothers.” Hamilton wound up in a duel with Burr because he had libeled his political rival. Hamilton died over their disagreement. It’s hard to imagine a similar eruption between U.S. Sens. Harry Reid and Mitch McConnell.

Then there’s Abraham Lincoln, who was called a warmonger, a president not interested in peace — and that was by his fellow citizens in the North. As the Library of Congress notes, Lincoln was so sure he would lose re-election, he drafted a sealed memo to his cabinet months before voting began, pledging to support the rival who defeated him.

Of course, he won. He was inaugurated into a second term, ended the Civil War and was shot dead by a political dissident, John Wilkes Booth, all in the space of six weeks.

When you consider how severe our differences have been, it’s easier to put our current divisions into context. Our disagreements run deep but rarely boil over. There have been no riots in the streets over the health care decision, just back-slapping on one side, soft curses on the other.

And that’s good, because we think there is room for disagreement in our complex society. Our debates — over immigration, marriage rights, stem cells — as maddening as they can be, give our country shape and, more often than not, move us forward.

Today, our country is 236 years old, and we’re still arguing about it. So what do we think freedom means?

We think it means we have the ability to disagree. We think the argument is the answer.

Now discuss.

Editor’s note: This editorial has been corrected from the original version to reflect the country’s age at 236.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

toon
Editorial cartoons for Monday, July 14

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Authorities search for victims among the rubble near Blue Oak RV park after catastrophic flooding on the Guadalupe River in Kerrville, Texas, on Sunday, July 6, 2025. The half-mile stretch occupied by two campgrounds appears to have been one of the deadliest spots along the Guadalupe River in Central Texas during last week’s flash floods. (Jordan Vonderhaar/The New York Times)
Editorial: Tragic Texas floods can prompt reforms for FEMA

The federal agency has an important support role to play, but Congress must reassess and improve it.

Comment: Midterm messaging fight for working class has begun

And Democrats have a head start thanks to the GOP’s all-in support for cuts to the social safety net.

Saunders: Considering attacks from left, ICE agents must mask

It’s not ideal, but with physical attacks against agents up 700%, the precaution is understandable.

Comment: Superman has been ‘woke’ as far back as Krypton

Conservative critics upset by the movie director’s comments on immigration need to read up on the hero’s origins.

Comment: GOP delayed worst of BBB’s cuts until after midterms

Republicans are counting on low-information voters’ party loyalty over their own financial interests.

Tufekci: Link between flood warnings and people wasn’t there

What might have saved many in Texas was a NWS coordinator position eliminated in the DOGE cuts.

toon
Editorial cartoons for Sunday, July 13

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

FILE — The sun sets over power lines in rural Ward County, Texas on Tuesday, May 20, 2025. Republicans plan to terminate billions of dollars in clean energy tax credits. Experts say that will mean more greenhouse gas emissions and more dangerous heat. (Paul Ratje/The New York Times)
Commentary: Bill will deliver dirtier energy at a higher price

Cuts to clean energy policy in the ‘Big Beautiful Bill’ will stifle our energy transition and cost us more.

Tufekci: ‘Garbage in, garbage out’ behind AI’s Nazi meltdown

That Elon Musk’s Grok chatbot defaulted to internet hate speech is concerning. Our acceptance is scarier.

Everett mayoral candidate had a role in budget problems

A mayoral candidate in Everett is being dishonest, blaming his opponent for… Continue reading

Social Security email was a false and partisan use of agency

I was appalled to get a spam email from the Social Security… Continue reading

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.