Progress made on oil trains, but more should follow

Some in the railroad and oil industries may believe the recent legislative and regulatory attention paid them is unwarranted. But the news keeps getting in the way of their point:

Federal investigators reported late last week that 16 cars in a 100-car Burlington Northern Santa Fe train carrying Bakken crude from North Dakota to an Anacortes refinery in January were found to have faulty valves that leaked a combined 25 gallons of oil before the leaks were detected, Spokane’s Spokesman-Review newspaper reported late last week. The Federal Railroad Administration tested valves on the cars, newer CPC-1232 tank cars, and attributed the leak to a design flaw. It has ordered owners of the cars with the affected values, about 6,000 of them, to take the cars out of service until the valves can be replaced.

Two crude oil train derailments were reported in March. A 94-car Canadian Railway train derailed March 7 outside an Ontario town, causing a fire that destroyed a bridge. Three days later, 21 cars of a 105-car BNSF train carrying Bakken crude from North Dakota derailed three miles outside Galena, Illinois.

As the amount of crude oil transported by rail has increased 50-fold between 2010 and this year, so to has the frequency of derailments and leaks from the trains. Thankfully, so has the attention of state and federal regulators, state legislators and members of Congress.

Washington’s Legislature did pass legislation that will require rail companies to show they can pay to clean up oil spills and extended to oil-by-rail a fee now collected only on oil delivered by marine tankers. The legislation also requires railroads to provide weekly notice to first responders along the rail route of the type and volume of oil being shipped, information that is to be made public on a quarterly basis.

And the U.S. Department of Transportation announced new rules on Friday that make official a new standard that will require older tank cars, referred to as DOT-111s, to be replaced or retrofitted by 2020. To their credit, refineries in Anacortes and Cherry Point in Whatcom County last year voluntarily switched from the older cars to the CPC-1232s.

At least one railroad association objects to a requirement to outfit all railcars by 2021 with electronically controlled pneumatic brakes which would slow all cars simultaneously, rather than sequentially, saying the DOT hadn’t made its case for safety. But common sense would seem to back the DOT on the brakes, as they are more likely to reduce the chances of a pileup and the number of punctured cars in an accident and increase the likelihood that trains could be stopped more quickly for an obstacle.

Members of Washington’s congressional delegation, including Reps. Rick Larsen and Suzan DelBene and Sen. Maria Cantwell, have said more needs to be done and more quickly. We agree. The DOT’s new regulations don’t require the notification rules nationwide that our Legislature has ordered here, for example. Cantwell has called for rules that would require the volatile gases in Bakken crude to be removed before being transported across the country. Oregon Sen. Roy Wyden has proposed charging a fee for the use of older railcars to train emergency responders and relocate tracks. Newer cars would get a tax break in return.

These regulations won’t come without costs, costs that will eventually be paid by the consumer. But those costs are minuscule when compared to the potential losses in a derailment that causes an ecological disaster in the Columbia River or the Salish Sea or an explosion that results in injuries or deaths in one of our communities.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) speaks to reporters during a press conference about the Cannabis Administration and Opportunity Act, on Capitol Hill in Washington, on Wednesday, May 1, 2024. Senate Democrats reintroduced broad legislation on Wednesday to legalize cannabis on the federal level, a major shift in policy that has wide public support, but which is unlikely to be enacted this year ahead of November’s elections and in a divided government. (Valerie Plesch/The New York Times)
Editorial: Federal moves on cannabis encouraging, if incomplete

The Biden administration and the Senate offer sensible proposals to better address marijuana use.

toon
Editorial cartoons for Tuesday, May 7

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

A radiation warning sign along the road near the Hanford Site in Washington state, on Aug. 10, 2022. Hanford, the largest and most contaminated of all American nuclear weapons production sites, is too polluted to ever be returned to public use. Cleanup efforts are now at an inflection point.  (Mason Trinca/The New York Times)
Editorial: Latest Hanford cleanup plan must be scrutinized

A new plan for treating radioactive wastes offers a quicker path, but some groups have questions.

Maureen Dowd: Consider the three faces of Donald Trump

Past, present and future are visibile in his countenance; an especially grim one on the cover of Time.

Paul Krugman: Still no stag and not much flation

The grumbling about inflation’s slow path to 2 percent isn’t worth steps that risk a recession.

David Brooks: Why past is prologue and protests help Trump

Today’s crowd-sourced protests muddle their message and goals and alienate the quiet disapprovers.

Jamelle Bouie: We pay price for upper-class state legislators

If we want more working-class representation, we need to make those positions more accessible.

A driver in a Tesla reportedly on "autopilot" allegedly crashed into a Snohomish County Sheriff's Office patrol SUV that was parked on the roadside Saturday in Lake Stevens. There were no injuries. (Snohomish County Sheriff's Office)
Editorial: Tesla’s Autopilot may be ‘unsafe at any speed’

An accident in Maltby involving a Tesla and a motorcycle raises fresh concerns amid hundreds of crashes.

A Black-capped Chickadee sits on a branch in the Narbeck Wetland Sanctuary on Wednesday, April 24, 2024 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Editorial: Bird act’s renewal can aid in saving species

It provides funding for environmental efforts, and shows the importance of policy in an election year.

Volunteers with Stop the Sweeps hold flyers as they talk with people during a rally outside The Pioneer Courthouse on Monday, April 22, 2024, in Portland, Ore. The rally was held on Monday as the Supreme Court wrestled with major questions about the growing issue of homelessness. The court considered whether cities can punish people for sleeping outside when shelter space is lacking. (AP Photo/Jenny Kane)
Editorial: Cities don’t need to wait for ruling on homelessness

Forcing people ‘down the road’ won’t end homelessness; providing housing and support services will.

RGB version
Editorial cartoons for Monday, May 6

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Michelle Goldberg: When elections on line, GOP avoids abortion

Even among the MAGA faithful, Republicans are having second thoughts on how to respond to restrictions.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.