High court overturns Stolen Valor Act

The U.S. Supreme Court on Thursday struck down the federal Stolen Valor Act, which made it a crime to falsely claim to have received certain military medals.

By a 6-3 decision, the high court said that lying about medals and military service, while “contemptible” and worthy of public outrage and ridicule, is protected by the First Amendment.

Justice Anthony Kennedy, writing for the majority, said that the First Amendment “protects the speech we detest as well as the speech we embrace.”

The decision came in the case of Xavier Alvarez, a former member of the Three Valleys Municipal Water District governing board in Los Angeles County.

At his first meeting, Alvarez had claimed he was a former Marine and recipient of the Medal of Honor; in fact, he had never served in the military. After being charged, he resigned from the board.

Kennedy said Alvarez’s lies “were but a pathetic attempt to gain respect that eluded him. The statements do not seem to have been made to secure employment or financial benefits or admission to privileges reserved for those who had earned the medal.”

Alvarez pleaded guilty to violating the Stolen Valor Act and was sentenced to three years’ probation, a $5,000 fine and community service. His attorneys appealed; the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the appeal, and the Department of Justice petitioned the Supreme Court to reinstate the conviction.

Rep. Duncan Hunter, R-Calif., who served as a Marine in Iraq and Afghanistan, expressed disappointment in Thursday’s high court ruling and suggested that Congress look for another way to deter people from lying about having received medals for bravery.

“There might well be some legislative options here and that’s something we’ll be taking a closer look at, because our military men and women contribute and sacrifice too much for others to try taking the credit,” Hunter said.

Rep. Joe Heck, R-Nev., vowed to sponsor legislation making it a crime to seek a benefit by lying about military service. “As a colonel in the Air Force Reserve, I feel strongly about protecting the honor of our servicemen and women,” he said.

Michael Neil, a retired Marine brigadier general and recipient of the Navy Cross for bravery in Vietnam, said that lying about receiving a medal should be considered in the same way as impersonating a police officer, which is a crime.

“Why should we allow someone to impersonate someone whose bravery and heroism is far beyond what you could expect from the average citizen?” said Neil, an attorney in San Diego.

Neil said he recently encountered someone claiming to be a Navy Cross recipient. Neil said he quickly realized the man was lying. “I gave him two seconds to get out of the room,” he said.

Citing a case involving Hustler magazine, federal attorneys argued that lies about military medals are “false statements (that) have no value and hence no First Amendment protection.”

The court majority disagreed, saying that there is no proof that lying about medals degrades the value of the medal or the honor bestowed on recipients.

The law was passed by Congress in the midst of the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq and signed in 2006 by President George W. Bush. It called for a possible one-year prison term.

Joining Kennedy in the majority were Chief Justice John Roberts and Justices Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Stephen Breyer, Sonia Sotomayor and Elena Kagan. Dissenting were Justices Antonin Scalia, Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito.

More in Local News

Everett district relents on eminent domain moving expenses

Homeowners near Bothell still must be out by April to make way for a planned new high school.

Their grown children died, but state law won’t let them sue

Families are seeking a change in the state’s limiting wrongful-death law.

Shock from WSU suicide ripples through Snohomish County

Roughly 1 in 10 seniors, sophomores and 8th-graders said they had attempted to take their own lives.

Marysville hit-and-run leaves man with broken bones

The state patrol has appealed for help solving an increasing number of hit-and-runs in the state.

$1,000 reward for info on who killed an eagle near Snohomish

After being shot, the raptor was treated at the Sarvey Wildlife Center but died overnight.

Woman confronts man leaving house with stolen item

“He swung at her with a crowbar, missing her.”

Police seek suspect in Wells Fargo bank robbery

He was described as white, in his 30s, heavyset, with blonde hair and a maroon sweatshirt.

Possible bobcat sighting keeps Snohomish students inside

The creature was spotted on the campus of Valley View Middle School around noon.

Stabbing in Everett follows dispute between brothers-in-law

The victim, 54, was hospitalized. The suspect, 29, had not been apprehended Thursday.

Most Read