Nursing assistant gets jail for role in client’s death

A Mill Creek woman who used to work in an adult-care home was sentenced to nine months in jail Tuesday for not taking proper care of an ill 73-year-old woman who died at the facility in 2002.

Beth Suzanne Knowles, 31, pleaded guilty in April to a first-degree criminal mistreatment charge. She admitted not properly dispensing food, water and medications to Adela De Los Santos at the Alice House adult-care facility in Snohomish.

Two others remain charged in connection with the death. Both Eddie Lee Smith, 44, of Snohomish and Norma Tanya Infante, 45, of Everett are charged with manslaughter and criminal mistreatment.

They are scheduled for trial in September, deputy prosecutor Bonnie Tweten said.

All three worked at the now-defunct Alice House adult-care facility, one of 10 similar businesses operated in Snohomish County by Michael Goodwill and Goodwill Care Inc. The nurse assistant licenses of Knowles and Smith have lapsed, and Infante’s has been revoked, according to the state Department of Health Professions Quality Assurance.

The state closed down Alice house not long after De Los Santos died. State Department of Social and Health Services spokeswoman Deborah Schow said that Goodwill has sold the other nine businesses.

On Tuesday, defense lawyer Guss Markwell asked Snohomish County Superior Court Judge Thomas Wynne to give Knowles a break because she had no previous criminal convictions.

The sentencing range for Knowles was between six months and a year behind bars, but Markwell asked the judge to waive jail time and require her to perform community service.

Tweten said the nine months, the middle of the sentencing range, is appropriate in this case.

In her guilty plea, Knowles admitted that she “recklessly” withheld the basic necessities of life.

De Los Santos, who was plagued with mental and physical health problems, was admitted to Providence Everett Medical Center’s Colby Campus in November 2002. She was in a coma, had a 105-degree temperature and her breathing was labored, according to court documents.

The emergency room doctor said lack of medication, liquids and food had put her into a coma and caused her kidneys to fail.

Goodwill was not charged with a crime. De Los Santos’ family filed a civil lawsuit and settled with Goodwill in 2005 for $400,000, documents said.

De Los Santos previously had been in a nursing home and developed “disruptive and aggressive behavior problems,” documents said. De Los Santos went to Alice House after Goodwill assured family members that his facility could handle a dependent adult like her, documents said.

Reporter Jim Haley: 425-339-3447 or

More in Local News

Mill Creek councilman no longer lives in city, panel finds

The Canvassing Board determined Sean Kelly is not eligible to vote there.

A Democrat and ex-Republican team up to end two-party politics

Brian Baird and Chris Vance unveil a new organization called Washington Independents.

The beavers weren’t happy, either, about Mill Creek flooding

A tree fell on their dam, sending a rush of water into a neighborhood near Jackson High School.

Granite Falls names Success in Education winners

The Granite Falls School District announced its first quarter Success in Education… Continue reading

Alderwood-Terrace Rotary hands out Educator of the Month honors

The Rotary Club of Alderwood-Terrace awarded its October Educators of the Month.… Continue reading

Schools honor service members for Veterans Day

Schools across Snohomish County honored veterans leading up to the Nov. 11… Continue reading

Yes to turn signal — eventually

Adding a right-turn signal at 112th St. and 7th Ave. is turning out to be a bit more complicated.

Hard work is paying off for Mariner High senior

Mey Ly has excelled in school since moving here from Cambodia; she also serves as an intrepreter.

Front Porch

EVENTS Music for kids from 3 to 103 The nonprofit Everett Philharmonic… Continue reading

Most Read