Label genetically modified salmon

Salmon hold sacred status in the Pacific Northwest, literally for the people of the region’s Indian nations. But the rest of us, specifically those who fish for salmon and those who serve them at family meals, also regard the fish as part of our heritage.

So it’s not hard to understand the skepticism and outright opposition to salmon that has been genetically modified. The moniker some have given it, “Frankenfish,” gives a good idea of its lack of acceptance.

Earlier this month, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration approved the sale of genetically engineered salmon, the first time an animal, rather than a plant, has been approved as safe for human consumption.

ADVERTISEMENT
0 seconds of 0 secondsVolume 0%
Press shift question mark to access a list of keyboard shortcuts
00:00
00:00
00:00
 

A Massachusetts-based company, AquaBounty has developed an Atlantic salmon that, through the introduction of genes from an eel-like fish and growth hormone from a chinook salmon, grows large enough for sale in a year and a half rather than the typical three years.

The FDA, the Washington Post reported, said its decision was “based on sound science and a comprehensive review” that the genetically engineered salmon was as a safe as Atlantic salmon to eat and was not discernibly different in terms of its nutritional value.

But at the same time the FDA said it would not require the salmon to carry a label that identified it as being genetically modified, claiming that it can’t require additional labeling unless there’s a substantial nutritional difference between the genetically modified product and its nonmodified counterpart.

That decision to approve AquaBounty’s salmon without a labeling requirement met appropriate criticism, including from U.S. Sen. Maria Cantwell, D-Washington and Rep. Don Young, R-Alaska.

“Wild seafood from Washington and Alaska are more sustainable than frankenfish, and our consumers have a right to know where their fish come from,” Sen. Cantwell said.

The House had an opportunity earlier this summer to reject legislation that could now pre-empt any mandatory state or local labeling requirements for GMO foods, in favor of a voluntary state-administered system. The bill passed the House, with Washington state’s delegation voting on a party line; Republicans for, Democrats, including Reps. Rick Larsen and Suzan DelBene, against. Alaska’s Young, despite his long opposition to GMO salmon, voted for the less-stringent voluntary system.

New legislation that would allow the FDA to require GMO labeling would give consumers the ability to make their own choice in the matter. Meanwhile, some retail outlets are making that choice. Costco, Whole Foods, Kroger (Fred Meyer) and others are refusing to sell the GMO salmon when it comes on the market.

The genetic alteration of our food has a history almost as old as agriculture itself as farmers and ranchers have bred and crossbred plants and animals for desirable traits, such as increased yields and better flavor. The difference now, reports a Q&A from National Geographic, is that science allows that crossbreeding to cross species, resulting in salmon with eel-fish genes that grow more quickly or lettuce that gets its vitamin C from of an introduced rat gene.

This is a relatively new science that holds promise but also potential harm to health and the environment.

AquaBounty is being required to raise its salmon in landlocked tanks to prevent any possible interbreeding with wild salmon. Aqua-Bounty has taken the further precaution of raising only sterile females.

The science of genetic engineering should be allowed to progress, as should the careful and considered review of its products. Labeling those products after they are approved has to be a part of the process.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

toon
Editorial cartoons for Sunday, May 25

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

A Lakewood Middle School eighth-grader (right) consults with Herald Opinion Editor Jon Bauer about the opinion essay he was writing for a class assignment. (Kristina Courtnage Bowman / Lakewood School District)
Youth Forum: Just what are those kids thinking?

A sample of opinion essays written by Lakewood Middle School eighth-graders as a class assignment.

House Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.) speaks to reporters after returning from a meeting at the White House on Capitol Hill in Washington, on Wednesday, May 21, 2025. (Haiyun Jiang/The New York Times)
Comment: Congress, over years, has become second-class branch

How Congress lost its constitutional clout and what it means for Americans and democracy.

Why do I protest? This is why

In the long four months of governing, the Trump administration has shown… Continue reading

For informed voters, cive the gift of news, information

A recent nationwide poll found that Donald Trump’s approval ratings were higher… Continue reading

Comment: U.S. diabetes epidemic is far more than medical issue

Much of it has to do with ‘red-lining,’ creating boundaries based on race and economic status.

Comment: Many veterans came home, fighting a war with addiction

Abuse of alcohol and drugs is common among vets, but services are available to individuals and families.

Comment: State worker pay raises behind $10B in tax increases

Gov. Ferguson missed his chance to pare tax increases that will hurt residents and businesses.

A visitor takes in the view of Twin Lakes from a second floor unit at Housing Hope’s Twin Lakes Landing II Wednesday, Feb. 22, 2023, in Marysville, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Editorial: Housing Hope’s ‘Stone Soup’ recipe for community

With homelessness growing among seniors, an advocate calls for support of the nonprofit’s projects.

Wildfire smoke builds over Darrington on Friday, Sept. 11, 2020 in Darrington, Wa. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Editorial: Loss of research funds threat to climate resilience

The Trump administration’s end of a grant for climate research threatens solutions communities need.

Sarah Weiser / The Herald
Air Force One touches ground Friday morning at Boeing in Everett.
PHOTO SHOT 02172012
Editorial: There’s no free lunch and no free Air Force One

Qatar’s offer of a 747 to President Trump solves nothing and leaves the nation beholden.

Forum: The magic created behind branches of weeping mulberry tree

The mature trees offer a ‘Secret Garden’-like room favored by children, one I hope to return to someday.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.