Washington bill targets credibility of informants’ testimony

SEATTLE — A Washington state man’s conviction in his mother’s 2000 murder was based largely on a false confession he gave to police after a long interrogation. But like a lot of other wrongful convictions, his case also featured another troubling aspect: incriminating statements from jailhouse informants who received light sentences or had criminal charges dropped after their testimony.

DNA evidence helped free Donovan Allen from prison last month, 15 years after he was arrested. Several state lawmakers hope his exoneration will bolster their case for changes that could reduce the odds of such testimony helping convict innocent people in the future.

Fifteen Democratic and Republican representatives in Washington state introduced a bill this month that would require judges to weigh the credibility of “incentivized” informants before their testimony can be presented to a jury — a requirement that would be a first in the nation, experts say, and part of a broader examination of how such witnesses are used.

ADVERTISEMENT
0 seconds of 0 secondsVolume 0%
Press shift question mark to access a list of keyboard shortcuts
00:00
00:00
00:00
 

Among the nine factors the judge would consider are the informant’s criminal history, whether they’ve previously been rewarded for testimony in criminal cases and whether independent evidence corroborates the informant’s story.

A bill in the state Senate, meanwhile, would authorize such assessments without making them mandatory. Hearings were being held on both measures this week.

“Without question, informant testimony is useful for law enforcement, and maybe sometimes it’s the only evidence in a serious case,” said Lara Zarowsky, the policy director of the Innocence Project Northwest, which drafted the House bill. “But if the defense tried to incentivize a witness, it would be witness tampering. Wrongful conviction cases are showing us that, yeah, maybe if you’re paid for your testimony you’re going to lie.”

Nationally, incriminating testimony from incentivized informants factored in 16 percent of 337 convictions overturned by DNA evidence — and in about half of death-row exonerations, according to the New York-based Innocence Project. It’s played a role in at least seven wrongful convictions in Washington.

States have started taking a harder look at the concerns posed when jailhouse snitches stand to gain by providing information about cellmates or other defendants, though Washington would be the first to require pretrial reliability assessments in any case where such testimony is used. Nevada’s Supreme Court has long required such assessments in capital cases, as did Illinois before it abolished the death penalty, said Alexandra Natapoff, a professor at Loyola Law School-Los Angeles.

“This is an era of revelation as the public and legislators learn the extent of the practice and the kinds of risk it carries,” Natapoff said. “The reality is that most places haven’t regulated the use of informants.”

About a dozen states do insist that informant testimony be corroborated by some evidence, she said, and federal courts and many state courts direct juries to weigh testimony from informants with extra scrutiny. The latter is an approached favored by the Washington Association of Prosecuting Attorneys, said Tom McBride, its executive secretary. Juries should absolutely be informed of any deals given to informants, he said, but it should be up to the jurors — not the judge — to weigh that evidence.

Washington requires that juries are told to give extra scrutiny to accomplice testimony, but not to statements from informants.

“I don’t think there’s any dispute you have to be careful with that kind of testimony,” McBride said. “But I don’t like the idea of judge determining reliability before the testimony goes before a jury.”

In Washington’s most recent DNA exoneration case, Allen was convicted after two trials of murdering his mother, Sharon Cox, 49, who was strangled and bludgeoned in 2000. Then 18, he confessed after 14 hours of interrogation. Though he later recanted, he was convicted of aggravated first-degree murder and sentenced to life without parole.

He was freed last month after police said new DNA tests had linked his cousin to the crime.

One witness, a repeat offender who testified at both trials, shared a cell with Allen and said Allen confessed to him. Between the trials, he received an exceptionally lenient sentence for burglary, even though he was facing numerous other charges, including eight counts of forgery. The day after he testified in Allen’s second trial, he was released from custody on the forgery charges, which were eventually dismissed, Allen’s Innocence Project Northwest lawyers noted in a court filing.

Another witness, who testified that he had heard Allen say he “wished his mom was dead before and now she is,” had two felony charges dropped two days after Allen was sentenced.

Washington’s House bill would grant new trials to previously convicted defendants if they can demonstrate that an informant lied on the stand and that statement possibly affected the outcome of the trial. The Senate version would not.

A main sponsor of the House bill, Democratic Rep. Tina Orwall of Des Moines, also sponsored Washington’s 2013 law to compensate exonerated convicts for the time they spent behind bars.

“How can we prevent more people from being wrongly convicted?” she said. “This legislation is one of those steps.”

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Local News

Vehicles travel along Mukilteo Speedway on Sunday, April 21, 2024, in Mukilteo, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Mukilteo cameras go live to curb speeding on Speedway

Starting Friday, an automated traffic camera system will cover four blocks of Mukilteo Speedway. A 30-day warning period is in place.

Carli Brockman lets her daughter Carli, 2, help push her ballot into the ballot drop box on the Snohomish County Campus on Tuesday, Nov. 5, 2024 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Here’s who filed for the primary election in Snohomish County

Positions with three or more candidates will go to voters Aug. 5 to determine final contenders for the Nov. 4 general election.

Students from Explorer Middle School gather Wednesday around a makeshift memorial for Emiliano “Emi” Munoz, who died Monday, May 5, after an electric bicycle accident in south Everett. (Aspen Anderson / The Herald)
Community and classmates mourn death of 13-year-old in bicycle accident

Emiliano “Emi” Munoz died from his injuries three days after colliding with a braided cable.

Danny Burgess, left, and Sandy Weakland, right, carefully pull out benthic organisms from sediment samples on Thursday, May 1, 2025 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
‘Got Mud?’ Researchers monitor the health of the Puget Sound

For the next few weeks, the state’s marine monitoring team will collect sediment and organism samples across Puget Sound

Everett postal workers gather for a portrait to advertise the Stamp Out Hunger Food Drive on Wednesday, May 7, 2025 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Snohomish County letter carriers prepare for food drive this Saturday

The largest single-day food drive in the country comes at an uncertain time for federal food bank funding.

Everett
Everett considers ordinance to require more apprentice labor

It would require apprentices to work 15% of the total labor hours for construction or renovation on most city projects over $1 million.

Clothing Optional performs at the Fisherman's Village Music Festival on Thursday, May 15 in Everett, Washington. (Will Geschke / The Herald)
Everett gets its fill of music at Fisherman’s Village

The annual downtown music festival began Thursday and will continue until the early hours of Sunday.

Women hold a banner with pictures of victims of one of the Boeing Max 8 crashes at a hearing where Captain Chesley B. “Sully” Sullenberger III testified at the Rayburn House Building on June 19, 2019, in Washington, D.C. (Katherine Frey/The Washington Post)
DOJ plans to drop Boeing prosecution in 737 crashes

Families of the crash victims were stunned by the news, lawyers say.

First responders extinguish a fire on a Community Transit bus on Friday, May 16, 2025 in Snohomish, Washington (Snohomish County Fire District 4)
Community Transit bus catches fire in Snohomish

Firefighters extinguished the flames that engulfed the front of the diesel bus. Nobody was injured.

Signs hang on the outside of the Early Learning Center on the Everett Community College campus on Wednesday, Dec. 1, 2021 in Everett, Wa. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Everett Community College to close Early Learning Center

The center provides early education to more than 70 children. The college had previously planned to close the school in 2021.

Northshore school board selects next superintendent

Justin Irish currently serves as superintendent of Anacortes School District. He’ll begin at Northshore on July 1.

Auston James / Village Theatre
“Jersey Boys” plays at Village Theatre in Everett through May 25.
A&E Calendar for May 15

Send calendar submissions for print and online to features@heraldnet.com. To ensure your… Continue reading

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.