Boeing employees stand near a Boeing 787-10 Dreamliner at the company’s facility in South Carolina on March 31, 2017. (AP Photo/Mic Smith, File)

Boeing employees stand near a Boeing 787-10 Dreamliner at the company’s facility in South Carolina on March 31, 2017. (AP Photo/Mic Smith, File)

Geopolitics leads Boeing to downgrade dozens of jet orders

Sanctions on Russia force Boeing order revision, while ongoing 787 halt reduces jet deliveries.

By Dominic Gates / The Seattle Times

SEATTLE — In the monthly update of its jet orders and delivery data released Tuesday, Boeing removed orders for 141 jets from the official backlog — most of which were planes formerly destined to be flown in Russia, where ultimate delivery is now in doubt because of international sanctions.

The data otherwise showed a steady flow of new airplane orders in March, including 35 net new orders for the 737 Max.

Deliveries of that Renton-built plane also saw an uptick in March with customers taking 34 of them.

However, widebody jet deliveries remain very slow with just three freighter planes and one Air Force tanker airframe delivered. Deliveries of the 787 Dreamliner, largely halted since fall 2020 while Boeing sorts out a fix to fuselage defects, remained at zero for the year.

Data released last week by Airbus shows that so far this year, the European manufacturer has delivered almost 50% more aircraft than Boeing, with 142 jets delivered compared with 95 by Boeing.

Unlike deliveries, a precise order comparison between the two rivals is not possible because Airbus does not remove doubtful orders from its books as Boeing does.

If those jets Boeing removed as dubious weren’t taken into account, allowing for a fairer comparison, its net orders for the first quarter of the year would be 145 airplanes compared with 83 for Airbus.

Russia sanctions bite

March’s big cut in Boeing’s order backlog was driven by U.S. accounting rules, which require the removal from the firm order book of any sale that becomes doubtful due to contract terms or the financial circumstances of the buyer.

For its March data, while Boeing did not specify which orders were removed, a spokesperson said the reassessment of credit quality for most of them was due to geopolitical events or international sanctions such as those imposed on Russia for its invasion of Ukraine.

The planes taken out of the backlog included a net total of 130 single-aisle 737 Maxs, eight 777F widebody freighters and three 787 Dreamliner twin-aisle jets.

Those certainly would have included 28 Maxs ordered by Russian flag carrier Aeroflot and six 777Fs ordered by cargo carrier Volga Dnepr.

Beyond those, most of the planes destined for Russia are ordered by international aircraft lessors, and it’s not possible to see that data broken out by country.

Airbus still has on its books 13 large twin-aisle A350s ordered by Aeroflot and 14 small single-aisle A220s ordered by Ilyushin Finance Co., a Russian lessor.

Additional jets on the European jetmaker’s books that are destined for Russian carriers were purchased by international lessors but also cannot be delivered until sanctions are lifted.

Orders come and go

Leaving aside the orders taken off the books largely for Russia, Boeing had 42 new gross orders in March, consisting of 36 for the Max and six for the 777F freighter from DHL.

That’s not counting 11 for an unidentified customer because that order is matched by 11 cancellations of the Max by an unidentified customer.

This looks essentially like an order swap, with a new customer taking over an existing order. It may even be just an airline switching from a direct buy to leasing the planes. The new owner would be the lessor, though the plane would be operated by the original airline buyer.

Boeing also had four separate order cancellations, including one Max and three 787-9 Dreamliners. So its net order tally for March, excluding the Russian removals, is 38 aircraft.

Airbus in comparison had 104 gross orders, all of them for the A320neo family of jets. However, it also canceled 76 orders, leaving its net order tally for March at 28 aircraft.

All but three of the Airbus cancellations were for AirAsia X, the financially troubled Malaysian long-haul airline, which finally canceled 63 widebody A330neos and 10 single-aisle A320neos.

This is exactly the sort of order that Boeing would likely have had to remove from its books when the airline was forced into a financial restructuring in 2020. Yet Airbus kept the orders on its books until the official cancellation last month.

Taking into account the orders taken out as dubious, Boeing booked 76 net orders in the first quarter.

Airbus, with its dubious orders still counted, booked 83 net orders in the first quarter.

Zero 787s delivered

In jet production and deliveries, Airbus remains far ahead of Boeing largely because the U.S. planemaker has been able to deliver only 14 of its 787 Dreamliners since October 2020 and none at all since May.

Airbus delivered 63 airplanes in March.

Those consisted of 54 single-aisle A320neos and A220s, as well as nine widebody passenger jets, three A330neos and six A350s.

Boeing delivered 41 airplanes in March.

That consisted of 37 single-aisle 737s built in Renton, of which 34 were Maxs, plus the four widebody jets built in Everett.

The widebodies were two 767 freighters for FedEx, one 777 freighter for China Airlines of Taiwan, and one 767 military airframe delivered to Boeing’s defense unit for modification to make it a KC-46 Air Force tanker.

The 787 blockage is because Boeing discovered fuselage defects consisting mainly of tiny gaps and unevenness at structural joins that are not considered a threat to flight safety but nevertheless must be fixed before delivery.

Multiple airplanes are being reworked in Everett and in North Charleston, South Carolina, and the Federal Aviation Administration has yet to approve Boeing’s fix.

Last week in Everett, a 787 that had been built in 2020 for American Airlines was rolled out of the factory again following the rework, with its carbon fiber composite fuselage covered in a sheath of black plastic to protect it from weather damage until it could be repainted.

The good news for Boeing is that March saw an uptick in the pace of 737 Max deliveries. It delivered 27 Maxs in January, 20 in February and 34 in March.

Airbus delivered 49 of the rival A320neo family of jets in March.

Boeing has now delivered a total of 353 Maxs since the plane returned to service from its prolonged grounding in late December 2020.

The uneven pace of deliveries masks the production rate inside the factory. Some of those delivered in March were previously built airplanes that were parked since the Max was grounded in 2019 and 2020 and have only now been reworked and returned to service.

Boeing has said its production target for early this year is to build and roll out 31 new Maxs per month. With additional planes coming from the parked inventory each month, the delivery rate should eventually be higher.

Talk to us

More in Herald Business Journal owner Tom Harrison at his brick and mortar storefront on Tuesday, Sept. 6, 2022 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Near-death experience planted seeds for downtown Everett toy store

Former attorney Tom Harrison survived 9/11. It caused him to ask what’s important in life. Today, he runs MyMyToyStore.

Sean Jones, membership executive of Everett's Freedom Boat Club, helps club member Carolyn Duncan load equipment onto her boat before she and a friend head out crabbing onThursday, Aug. 11, 2022, at the Port of Everett in Everett, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
New Everett franchise offers boats at Everett Marina

Freedom Boat Club’s newest Washington location is in Everett, with six boats available to its members.

Devin Ryan, left to right, talks with Donald Whitley and Drew Yager before a test ride at Bicycle Centres Wednesday in Everett, Washington on August 24, 2022.  (Kevin Clark / The Herald)
New hands take the handlebars for Bicycle Centres

Longtime employees Devin Ryan, Aron Chaudiere and Ryan Brown bought the business that’s been around since 1976.

A truck drives past a sign displaying fuel prices on Friday, Sept. 2, 2022 in Arlington, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Diesel prices stay high for truckers, farmers

Gas prices have fallen steadily this summer, but diesel costs have started to climb again.

FILE - Test engineer Jacob Wilcox pulls his arm out of a glove box used for processing sodium at TerraPower, a company developing and building small nuclear reactors, Jan. 13, 2022, in Everett, Wash. A major economic bill headed to the president has “game-changing” incentives for the nuclear energy industry, experts say, and those tax credits are even more substantial if a facility is sited in a community where a coal plant is closing. Bill Gates' company, TerraPower, plans to build an advanced, nontraditional nuclear reactor and employ workers from a local coal-fired power plant scheduled to close soon. (AP Photo/Elaine Thompson, File)
Everett nuclear research facility gets $750 million infusion

Bellevue’s TerraPower, which operates an Everett facility, got a hefty investment to fund research.

Logo for news use featuring Snohomish County, Washington. 220118
Business briefs: Leadership Snohomish County names new executive director

Plus a new short-term, career programs at Edmonds College, state grants for small businesses and more.

Tim Leonard, owner of the Machine Shop, is closing the arcade this fall. (Photo by David Welton)
Arcade owner to pull plug on beloved Whidbey Island business

Tim Leonard, owner of the Machine Shop in Langley, recently decided he’ll call it quits this fall.

Jennifer Sadinsky is the owner of Grayhorse Mercantile, one of Langley’s newest stores. (David Welton)
Shopkeeper brings taste of Europe to Whidbey Island

A first-time business owner’s dream of opening a cheese shop became a reality this year.

Toggle’s Bottle Shop is closed permanently on Monday, Oct. 3, 2022, in downtown Everett, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Citing landlord dispute, Toggle’s closes in downtown Everett

The popular taproom shuttered Sunday. “Everett needs a cooperative landlord-tenant relationship in the commercial district,” a co-owner said.

The Think Tank Cowork building located in Everett's historic downtown district has been beautifully preserved and updated.
Bridge the work and work-from-home divide with Coworking

Shared workspace in Downtown Everett offers the amenities you want + flexible packages

Rick Winter (left) and Gary Yang, the founders of the former UniEnergy Technologies, stand with one their latest batteries, the Reflex, August 10, 2022. (Dan DeLong/InvestigateWest)
‘Chaotic mess’: Clean energy promises imploded at Mukilteo battery maker

UniEnergy Technologies absorbed millions in public funds, then suddenly went dark. The company is accused of providing tech to China.

Eviation's all-electric plane in flight Tuesday morning in Moses Lake, Washington, on Sept. 27, 2022. (Eviation)
Arlington’s all-electric plane, Alice, takes first test flight

Eviation Aircraft’s battery-powered plane logs successful first flight from Grant County International Airport in Moses Lake.