Squeak toys still speaking to collectors

  • By Ralph and Terry Kovel / Antiques & Collectibles
  • Wednesday, March 21, 2007 9:00pm
  • Life

Soft, squeezable rubber toys were a new, amazing toy just after Charles Goodyear perfected the vulcanizing process and patented it in 1844.

In 1832, toys of soft, pliable materials similar to rubber were made. They had comical, stretchable faces. In 1850, there were many store ads selling India rubber toys such as balls, rattles and doll heads.

The first rubber squeak toys were made about 1860, but the squeak toys found by collectors today were popular in the 1930s and after. By then, the rubber quality was better and could be painted without flaking. The soft toys were made to squeak when squeezed. Most were shaped like cartoon characters or children and were not marked.

The ones bringing the best prices today are marked “Rempel.” Other makers were Sun Rubber and Edward Mobley Co. Prices range from $200 for Rempel rarities to a few dollars for unmarked toys at yard sales. Prices remain low and real bargains can be found at flea markets.

Yes. The Nelson McCoy Pottery Co. of Roseville, Ohio – better known simply as McCoy – made dozens of pottery lamp bases in the 1950s. Most are marked “McCoy USA.” Collectors pay $40 to $400 for them today, depending on style, condition, color and size. McCoy was in business from 1910 to 1990.

We recently purchased a silver-plated tea set at a local thrift store. The pieces – a teapot, sugar bowl, creamer and tray – are marked “Superior Silver Co.” We have been unable to find any information about this company. Can you help?

We can understand your confusion. Silver marked “Superior Silver Co.” was actually made by the Middletown Plate Co. of Middletown, Conn., or its successor, International Silver Co. of Meriden, Conn. Middletown Plate Co. was founded in 1864 and was one of the oldest firms to become part of International Silver, founded in 1899 when several New England silver manufacturers joined forces. Both companies used the “Superior Silver” mark on lower-priced merchandise.

Current prices are recorded from antiques shows, flea markets, sales and auctions throughout the United States. Prices vary in different locations because of local economic conditions.

“My One and Only Highland Fling” sheet music, by Ira Gershwin and Harry Warren, 1949, $25.

Depression-glass salad bowl, Cloverleaf pattern, green, 7 inches, $115.

McKee glass spice set, Roman Arches design, jade green, 4 inches, 14 pieces, $140.

Green Ghost board game, glows in the dark, Transogram, original box, 1965, $200.

Irish Belleek vase, Shamrock pattern, urn form, two handles, 1955, 8 inches, $310.

Teco pottery chamberstick, angular handles, green matte glaze, gray highlights, 21/4 x 5 inches, pair, $585.

Little Elf coffee tin, image of elf carrying tray, Bursley and Co., Fort Wayne, one pound, $670.

Irish sterling-silver creamer, helmet shape, molded grill, waved rim, Dublin, 1750, 5 inches, $1,440.

Barbie “Color Magic” doll, midnight and ruby red, long reddish hair, diamond-print swimsuit in psychedelic colors, matching headband, Mattel, 1966, 11 inches, $1,900.

George III window seat, mahogany, padded seat, out-scrolled arms, tapering square legs, spade feet, 30 x 49 x 14 inches, $3,120.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Life

‘Easy to Please’: The hot pink color of this beauty made it instantly popular locally, and those who grow it rave about how clean and floriferous it is for the garden. Moderate clove fragrance helps take this variety to the next level as well. (Sunnyside Nursery)
The Golfing Gardener: For the love of roses

One of the most frequent questions asked over my many moons of… Continue reading

Roger Sweet, left, creator of He-Man, signs Andy Torfin’s Funko He-Man box during a meet and greet at BobaKhan Toys & Collectibles on Saturday, April 13, 2019 in Everett, Wash. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Wife of He-Man co-creator starts GoFundMe for his care

Roger Sweet, an early Masters of the Universe designer, now lives in memory care that costs $10,200 a month.

Camellia (Sunnyside Nursery)
The Golfing Gardener: Valentine’s Day goodies for everyone

It is February and one of my favorite holidays is upon us…… Continue reading

Brandon Tepley does a signature Butch pose while holding a vintage Butch head outside of his job at Mukilteo Elementary where he is dean of students on Thursday, Jan. 22, 2026 in Mukilteo, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
The secret life of Butch T. Cougar, WSU mascot

Mukilteo school dean Brandon Tepley and other mascots talk about life inside — and after — the WSU suit.

2026 Forester Wilderness photo provided by Subaru Media
Subaru Forester adds new Wilderness trim For 2026, increasing versatility

Safety, flexibility, creature comforts all at the ready

Cherry Sweetheart. (Dave Wilson Nursery)
The Golfing Gardener: Cheerful Cherries

As we continue to work through the home orchard, sweet and delicious… Continue reading

The 2026 Subaru Crosstrek Hybrid compact SUV.
2026 Subaru Crosstrek Hybrid has a new powertrain

A series-parallel system replaces the former plug-in hybrid setup.

‘A story worth telling’: Snohomish County did it before Woodstock

Local author J.D. Howard reminds readers of The Sky River Rock Festival, a forgotten music milestone.

Children play and look up at a large whale figure hanging from the ceiling at the Imagine Children’s Museum (Olivia Vanni / The herald)
Curiosity lives here in Snohomish County’s best museums

Explore the spaces locals love for learning, inspiration, and discovery.

Photo Credit: Village Theatre Instagram Page
Your front-row guide to the best theatres around

From powerful productions to local talent, these stages deliver unforgettable moments.

Cars drive along Colby Avenue past the Everett Historic Theater on Tuesday, May 13, 2025 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Banff Film Festival returns to Everett on Feb. 27

The festival will showcase a variety of films centering on the outdoor community, including Banff’s 2025 Best Film winner, “Best Day Ever.”

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.