Top row: Norma Smith (left) and Scott McMullen. Bottom row: Dave Paul (left) and Dave Hayes.

Top row: Norma Smith (left) and Scott McMullen. Bottom row: Dave Paul (left) and Dave Hayes.

District 10 GOP representatives battle to keep their seats

Norma Smith and Dave Hayes face strong challengers in Democrats Scott McMullen and Dave Paul.

Two incumbents are fighting to keep their seats representing parts of Snohomish, Skagit and all of Island county in the Washington State House of Representatives.

Rep. Norma Smith, R-Clinton, and Rep. Dave Hayes, R-Camano Island, have some ground to make up from the primary election.

Scott McMullen, a Democrat from Mount Vernon, was about 553 votes ahead of Smith in the August tally. They are competing for Position 1 in the state’s 10th Legislative District.

Dave Paul, a Democrat from Oak Harbor, was 2,411 votes ahead of Hayes in the race for Position 2.

Camano and Whidbey islands, Stanwood, Mount Vernon, and the communities of Silvana and Bryant fall within the district.

McMullen credits his primary lead over Smith to the time he spent talking to people and going to events. He’s accessible to voters, he said.

Smith notes that many people have been focused on national politics.

Her strategy “is really about being able to tell my story locally, here, about the bipartisan work I’ve done,” she said, pointing to examples such as laws to protect personal data and net neutrality.

Hayes also has been talking to voters about his record in the Legislature, including rejecting new rules or programs that don’t come with the money or resources they need, he said.

His opponent, Paul, said the 10th district is more of a middle ground than people realize.

“I think this is a swing district, a moderate district, and (Hayes’) record has been far too conservative,” Paul said.

The contenders agree that public safety, education and cost of living are key issues. Their ideas diverge in some areas, though.

McMullen said he wants a new solution for funding education.

“I would like to remove the unfair property tax increase that has burdened a lot of lower-income and elderly right now, and propose a capital gains tax on corporations and high income (earners),” he said.

Paul, too, thinks the state needs to consider other ways to increase revenue for schools. He suggests eliminating business tax exemptions unless there’s a clear public benefit.

Smith, though, said the work done on funding education through state rather than local property taxes is “a huge stride forward.” Any changes should be decided after listening to educators and families, she said.

Hayes would support allowing school districts to collect more in local levies, provided that none of it goes toward basic expenses such as teacher salaries.

Voters are set to consider a gun control measure, Initiative 1639, on the upcoming ballot. Hayes said he does not support such broad restrictions. He wants better enforcement of existing laws.

“I think that every gun owner in the state or beyond has the responsibility to safely store their weapons. Absolutely,” he said. “But we already have a law … It’s called reckless endangerment.”

Smith said gun control should be focused on criminals, not law-abiding owners. She would consider reasonable restrictions, such as improvements to background checks, she said.

McMullen and Paul said they would support measures similar to those in 1639. That includes a higher age limit to purchase certain firearms, tighter background check requirements, and stiffer penalties if guns aren’t safely stored. However, McMullen noted that he is not opposed to gun ownership. He has hunting rifles.

The candidates also differ in their views on a carbon tax. Hayes and Smith do not support it, while McMullen and Paul are in favor of one, though not necessarily as laid out in Initiative 1631, also on the November ballot. They’d modify the proposal to help workers in affected industries transition to jobs in green energy, among other changes.

“I think climate change is one of the most defining issues of our time,” Paul said. “Not only do we have a moral obligation to address climate change, but our district depends on having a healthy environment for the economy.”

Smith and Hayes said Washington already is on track for reducing emissions. A state-level fee would have minimal positive impact on the global environment, Hayes said, if other states and countries continue polluting.

A carbon tax would “draw an artificial boundary around our state and put in its crosshairs family-wage jobs,” Smith said.

She aims to continue her work on solar incentives and solar panel recycling, as well as supporting development of new technologies.

When it comes to public safety, the candidates agree that mental and behavioral health is a focal point.

Smith and Hayes said the state needs to invest in resources such as local treatment centers. There should be a well-mapped mental health “safety net” that spans the entire state, so the Legislature can work to fill gaps, Smith said.

Hayes would support programs similar to the embedded social workers who partner with law enforcement in Snohomish County.

If elected, McMullen wants to direct more state resources toward training and equipment for first responders.

Paul has heard many concerns around public safety, mental health and drug addiction, he said. He wants to focus on programs that treat addiction rather than criminalizing it.

Paul reported $160,511 raised for his campaign, according to the state’s Public Disclosure Commission. McMullen reported $72,420. Both totals include sizable contributions from the House Democratic Campaign Committee.

Hayes reported $157,116 in his campaign fund, and Smith reported $128,741. Among the contributions are donations from the Republican parties in Island, Skagit and Snohomish counties.

Voters must mail ballots or bring them to a drop box by Nov. 6. Boxes close at 8 p.m. Election Day.

Representative, Position 1, 10th district

Scott McMullen

Party: Democrat

Age: 55

Residence: Mount Vernon

Elected Experience: Mount Vernon City Council (8 years)


Norma Smith

Party: Republican

Age: 67

Residence: Clinton

Elected Experience: State representative (10 years)


Representative, Position 2, 10th district

Dave Hayes

Party: Republican

Age: 52

Residence: Camano Island

Elected Experience: State representative (6 years)


Dave Paul

Party: Democrat

Age: 50

Residence: Oak Harbor

Elected Experience: None. Works as a vice president at Skagit Valley College.


Talk to us

More in Local News

Snohomish County Sheriff Adam Fortney during an interview at the sheriff’s department June 17, 2020. (Sue Misao / The Herald)
Auditor denies Fortney recall group the extra time it seeks

He said he could extend the deadline for signature gathering if ordered by a court or the Governor.

NO CAPTION NECESSARY: Logo for the Cornfield Report by Jerry Cornfield. 20200112
Private prisons, police reform and a Black pioneer’s plaque

Here’s what’s happening on Day 45 of the 2021 session of the Washington Legislature.

Everett man identified after being found dead in creek

The cause of death for Renee Baltazar Romero remained under investigation Thursday.

Joe Hempel swims off of the shore of Seawall Park on Friday, Jan. 29, 2021 in Langley, Wa. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Scantily clad is the dress code for these cold rush swimmers

Immersed for 30 minutes in frigid water would kill most of us. It energizes these swimmers.

Everett man found dead in creek near Lake Stevens

The man, 28, was reported missing Thursday. A neighbor found his body in Little Pilchuck Creek.

When not at home, Brett Bass keeps his rifle locked in a 600-lb. safe at his home on Tuesday, Oct. 23, 2018 in Edmonds, Wa. Bass, an NRA certified firearms instructor and safety officer, is one of three Edmonds residents who sued to block the city's safe storage gun law from being enforced. (Andy Bronson / The Herald)
Appeals court says Edmonds can’t enforce safe storage gun law

State law “unambiguously” pre-empts the city from enacting its own firearm rules, the panel concludes.

A Washington State Patrol detective photographs the vehicle involved in hit and run double fatality in Bothell Friday on February 19, 2021.  (Kevin Clark / The Herald)
Fatal hit-and-run victims identified after Friday crash

They were Carson M. Cox, 32, and Sarah L. Foxheath, 39, according to the state patrol.

Autopsy shows Lake Stevens woman, 20, drowned Saturday

Anna M. Lopez was swimming when witnesses noticed she was not responsive, according to officials.

Washington Gov. Jay Inslee speaks at a news conference, Tuesday, Jan. 5, 2021, at the Capitol in Olympia, Wash. Inslee said some COVID-19 restrictions in Washington will be eased beginning next week and the state will change its reopening plan to move from a county-based oversight system to one focused on regions. (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren)
Inslee: All of Washington to stay in Phase 2 for a few weeks

The governor issued a weekslong pause on regions moving backward, but has yet to outline a Phase 3.

Most Read