PUD consultant fees criticized

By Jennifer Langston

Herald Writer

EVERETT — Kal Leichtman said the Snohomish County PUD’s decision to hire an expensive California management consultant reminded him of the monarchy before the French Revolution.

They lived in gold-plated palaces while their subjects went hungry.

He was among a half-dozen customers Tuesday who questioned the PUD board on why the utility spent more than $620,000 on outside consulting fees when customers were struggling to pay their bills.

The expenses charged over two years by consultant Laurence Akiyoshi to help fix management problems included more than $40,000 for air fare, $34,000 for hotel bills and $20,000 for rental cars.

ADVERTISEMENT
0 seconds of 0 secondsVolume 0%
Press shift question mark to access a list of keyboard shortcuts
00:00
00:00
00:00
 

"I would call that opulent decadence," Leichtman said. "There’s so many worthwhile consultants in this area who could have done the job less expensively."

A review of records by The Herald last week found that Akiyoshi billed the PUD $750,000 over a two-year period. That’s more than any of the utility’s top managers were paid.

The Woodside, Calif., consultant was retained to help hire three top managers, improve customer service, focus the utility’s computer department and analyze results of an employee survey.

The PUD commissioners requested a written report from general manager Paul Elias, who hired longtime business acquaintance Akiyoshi at $400 to $425 an hour.

Commissioner Don Berkey said at the very least there seemed to be a disconnect between customer expectations and the way the utility had been operating. Many of those customers have been cutting corners to pay record high electricity bills, following a 50 percent rate increase last year. The board reduced rates by 5 percent this week, offering some relief.

"I think we have a serious problem here," Berkey said. "Clearly, our customers did not expect to spend a half-million dollars on a consultant … and I think that deserves a full explanation."

Elias defended his decision to hire Akiyoshi at Tuesday’s meeting. He said the consultant was initially brought in to help identify problems and solutions in the utility’s troubled customer service department.

The utility needed a top-notch advisor, he said. Most organization behavior consultants charge between $450 and $625 an hour, and Akiyoshi agreed to reduce his usual fee, Elias said.

The PUD’s customer service department, with nearly 100 employees, is the utility’s third-largest division behind corporate services and employees who service poles and wires.

While customer service employees had good ideas for improving efficiency and saving money, they felt like they weren’t being listened to, Elias said. With Akiyoshi’s help, the utility acted on some of those suggestions. That included doing away with burdensome requirements like asking new customers for references, which should save $300,000 to $500,000 a year.

It also farmed out some work trying to collect on canceled accounts. That freed up more people to answer phones, saving another $240,000 a year, he said.

But Elias took responsibility for expenses charged to the PUD, including stays in a four-star Seattle hotel, expensive car rentals, valet airport parking and copying charges that the utility now says are unreasonable.

The PUD is questioning $45,000 worth of Akiyoshi’s billings after noticing last month they seemed high. It is also conducting an audit to see if it was overcharged in previous invoices that added up to more than $600,000.

Akiyoshi, a consultant with 23 years experience who has worked for companies including Hewlett-Packard, Kodak and Levi Strauss, said in an interview last week that he’s upfront with all his clients about his rates and the expenses he expects to be reimbursed for.

But Elias said he was surprised when employees told him about some charges showing up on the invoices that he wouldn’t consider reasonable.

"They were not expenses I ever agreed to, and I told them to push back," Elias said Tuesday. "But I’m accountable for what had been approved in prior contracts."

The utility also paid Akiyoshi $65,000 twice after failing to notice it had been double-billed for the same work. That money has now been refunded, Elias said. That means the utility has paid $557,000 so far.

"By any stretch of the imagination, that’s still a lot of money for a consultant," he said. "But we needed this kind of help … and Mr. Akiyoshi had the credentials."

Nels Konnerup, a retiree who lives on Camano Island, said the amount of money paid for a single consultant seemed exorbitant. He said he hired plenty of consultants during his career working for the U.S. State Department, and he was perplexed by the charges.

He questioned why, at a minimum, the utility couldn’t have hired someone closer to home who wouldn’t have incurred such high travel expenses.

The PUD spent more than $210,000 just to bring Akiyoshi from his home in California to meet with employees in Everett, according to The Herald’s review of invoices.

"I’ve never seen anything that approached this," Konnerup said. "I just don’t see why anyone … should have to go outside of this state to find a consultant, particularly not at the price this man has charged the PUD."

Ed Taft, who owns a heavy construction company in Arlington, also questioned why the PUD didn’t catch the fact that it had been overbilled $65,000. In his own business, he scrutinizes every bill that comes in and routinely questions expenses that seem high.

"I’m kind of disgruntled with paying someone $400 an hour. I don’t know too many people who are worth that," he told commissioners.

Leichtman, an Everett resident, said he just paid the highest electricity bill in his 76-year life.

"I think Mr. Akiyoshi’s opulence was uncalled for, particularly in light of what we’re paying for our energy bills," he said. "When you compare that with hiring a local consultant, they went totally overboard."

You can call Herald Writer Jennifer Langston at 425-339-3452 or send e-mail to langston@heraldnet.com.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Local News

(City of Everett)
Everett’s possible new stadium has a possible price tag

City staff said a stadium could be built for $82 million, lower than previous estimates. Bonds and private investment would pay for most of it.

Jennifer Humelo, right, hugs Art Cass outside of Full Life Care Snohomish County on Wednesday, May 28, 2025 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
‘I’ll lose everything’: Snohomish County’s only adult day health center to close

Full Life Care in Everett, which supports adults with disabilities, will shut its doors July 19 due to state funding challenges.

The age of bridge 503 that spans Swamp Creek can be seen in its timber supports and metal pipes on Wednesday, May 15, 2024, in Lynnwood, Washington. The bridge is set to be replaced by the county in 2025. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Snohomish County report: 10 bridges set for repairs, replacement

An annual report the county released May 22 details the condition of local bridges and future maintenance they may require.

The Edmonds City Council gathers to discuss annexing into South County Fire on Tuesday, Dec. 3, 2024 in Edmonds, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Community group presents vision for Edmonds’ fiscal future

Members from Keep Edmonds Vibrant suggested the council focus on revenue generation and a levy lid lift to address its budget crisis.

Cars drive along Cathcart Way next to the site of the proposed Eastview Village development that borders Little Cedars Elementary on Wednesday, May 7, 2025 in unincorporated Snohomish, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Former engineer: Snohomish County rushed plans for Eastview development

David Irwin cited red flags from the developers. After he resigned, the county approved the development that’s now stalled with an appeal

People listen as the Marysville School Board votes to close an elementary and a middle school in the 2025-26 school year while reconfiguring the district’s elementary schools to a K-6 model on Wednesday, Jan. 22, 2025 in Marysville, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Marysville schools audit shows some improvement

Even though the district still faces serious financial problems, the findings are a positive change over last year, auditors said.

Outside of the Madrona School on Monday, Aug. 26, 2024 in Edmonds, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Sewer district notifies Edmonds schools of intent to sue

The letter of intent alleges the school district has failed to address long-standing “water pollution issues” at Madrona K-8 School.

Providence Regional Medical Center Everett. (Olivia Vanni/The Herald)
Providence Everett plans to reduce certified nursing assistants

Nursing assistants at Providence Regional Medical Center Everett have until Thursday to accept a voluntary severance package.

A firefighting helicopter carries a bucket of water from a nearby river to the Bolt Creek Fire on Saturday, Sep. 10, 2022, on U.S. 2 near Index, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
How Snohomish County property owners can prepare for wildfire season

Clean your roofs, gutters and flammable material while completing a 5-foot-buffer around your house.

Nedra Vranish, left, and Karen Thordarson, right browse colorful glass flowers at Fuse4U during Sorticulture on Friday, June 7, 2024, in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Everett’s Sorticulture festival starts Friday

Festivities will include art classes, garden vendors and live music.

Logo for news use featuring Snohomish County, Washington. 220118
11-year-old, teen injured in Snohomish County shooting

The 11-year-old is in critical condition, the sheriff’s office said. Investigators believe the shooting was gang related.

Madison Family Shelter Family Support Specialist Dan Blizard talks about one of the pallet homes on Monday, May 19, 2025 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Madison Family Shelter reopens after hiatus

The Pallet shelter village, formerly Faith Family Village, provides housing for up to eight families for 90 days.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.