Court weighs lawmakers’ change to deadly force measure

The agreement was intended to end years of wrangling over an existing state law.

  • By Wire Service
  • Saturday, June 30, 2018 1:30am
  • Northwest

By Rachel La Corte / Associated Press

OLYMPIA — The Washington Supreme Court heard arguments Thursday on whether state lawmakers acted constitutionally when they passed a measure designed to improve police training in de-escalation tactics and make it easier to prosecute officers for negligent shootings.

Lawmakers approved Initiative 940 in March, but in an unprecedented move, first passed a separate bill amending the initiative that was a compromise between activists and police groups.

A Thurston County Superior Court judge said that procedure was unconstitutional and ordered that the original I-940 be placed on the November ballot. The state Attorney General’s Office appealed and argued in court Thursday that the Legislature validly enacted the amended law.

“The Washington Constitution reserves to the voters the power to propose an initiative to the Legislature, but the Legislature also has the power to legislate,” said Deputy Solicitor General Jeff Even. “This case arises at the intersection of those two sources of legislative power.”

Justice Sheryl Gordon McCloud noted the Constitution says such initiatives shall be “enacted or rejected without change or amendment by the legislature before the end of such regular session.”

Even said the constitutional language is written against a backdrop in which the Legislature has “authority to legislate.”

“If the Constitution is limiting the authority of the Legislature to amend an initiative, then I would expect to see that language occur rather explicitly,” he said.

Chief Justice Mary Fairhurst jumped in, reemphasizing the “without amendment” language.

“How much more explicit could it be than what the Constitution actually says?” she asked.

When lawmakers passed the agreement, it was intended to end years of wrangling over an existing state law that made it nearly impossible to hold police officers criminally liable.

Amid outrage over questionable police shootings, the organization De-escalate Washington gathered nearly 360,000 signatures for an initiative to the Legislature to change the law by eliminating a requirement that prosecutors prove an officer acted with malice.

Under the state Constitution, lawmakers can approve such measures as written; reject or ignore them, in which case they appear on the November ballot; or propose an alternative to appear alongside the original on the ballot.

In this case, the Legislature crafted a fourth option: It passed the original Initiative 940 as well as a law to amend it with changes called for by police groups and supported by activists.

Mindful of the Constitution’s requirements for a public vote, however, lawmakers also said the law to amend the initiative would only take effect if no referendum was filed by June to challenge it.

Initiative promoter Tim Eyman sued, arguing that if it’s allowed to stand, the Legislature’s move would effectively abolish the people’s right to petition the Legislature by initiative. Voters could collect signatures for a measure, only to see lawmakers drastically change it. Voters would then have to collect more signatures if they want to challenge the Legislature’s version by referendum.

Eyman’s attorney, Joel Ard, told justices that both I-940 and the separate bill amending it need to be presented to the voters this November. Otherwise, he said, lawmakers have evaded their obligation.

“And with that you’ve gutted the power of the initiative to the Legislature,” he said.

He also noted a 1971 attorney general’s office opinion that says anytime the Legislature makes changes to an initiative proposed to it by the people, those changes must appear alongside the original on the ballot. The opinion also said the Legislature couldn’t simply pass a separate law altering the initiative, even to make simple corrections.

“If you’re going to adopt an initiative and then amend it, you need to have a sufficient window of 90 days between adopting and amendment to allow for the referendum to be exercised against either one of them,” he said.

The constitutional concerns were aired during the rush to pass the deadly force compromise before the legislative session ended March 8. It passed with support from both parties in the House and from majority Democrats in the Senate.

The high court will decide whether the lawmakers acted constitutionally, or whether I-940 or I-940 and the compromise proposal should go to the ballot. A timeframe for their decision is unknown.

Talk to us

More in Northwest

King County map logo
Judge orders Washington AG’s office, DSHS to pay more for evidence withholding

A judge imposed the new costs in a ruling Friday. The amount is on top of an earlier $200,000 sanction.

Gov. Jay Inslee signs Senate Bill 5536 concerning controlled substances on Tuesday, May 16, 2023, in Olympia, Wash. Behind him are from left to right: Rep. Roger Goodman, D- Kirkland, Rep. Jamila Taylor, D-Federal Way, House Speaker Laurie Jinkins, D-Tacoma, June Robinson, D-Everett, an identified woman and Andy Billig, D-Spokane. The policy, approved by Washinton lawmakers and signed by Inslee, keeps controlled substances illegal while boosting resources to help those struggling with addiction.  (Karen Ducey/The Seattle Times via AP)
New Washington law keeps drugs illegal, boosts resources for housing and treatment

Gov. Jay Inslee quickly signed a major new drug policy Tuesday that keeps controlled substances illegal.

FILE - Patients line up to pick up medication for opioid addiction at a clinic in Olympia, Wash., on March 27, 2020. (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren, File)
Washington lawmakers reach deal on drug policy, avoid automatic decriminalization

Lawmakers will consider the compromise Tuesday when they return to Olympia for a special session.

Commissioner of Public Lands Hilary Franz watches as a team works to remove old toxic pilings from the water as part of larger salmon restoration plan near Ebey Waterfront Park in Marysville, Washington on Friday, Feb. 10, 2023.  (Annie Barker / The Herald)
Washington Public Lands Commissioner Hilary Franz announces run for governor

Gov. Jay Inslee announced on May 1 that he would not seek a fourth term.

Washington Gov. Jay Inslee signs bills at the Washington State Capitol, Tuesday, May 9, 2023, in Olympia, Wash. One of those bills was Senate Bill 5599, which was designed to protect young people seeking reproductive health services or gender-affirming care. (AP Photo/Ed Komenda)
Trans minors protected from parents under Washington law

Minors seeking gender-affirming care in Washington will be protected from the intervention of estranged parents under a new law.

The remains of Hurricane Ridge Day Lodge were to be examined by fire investigators. (National Park Service)
Fire investigators arrive to examine remains of Hurricane Ridge lodge

No fire suppression equipment was in structure; contents had been removed

FILE - A Boeing 737 Max jet prepares to land at Boeing Field following a test flight in Seattle, Sept. 30, 2020. Boeing said Tuesday, Jan. 10, 2023, that it took more than 200 net orders for passenger airplanes in December and finished 2022 with its best year since 2018, which was before two deadly crashes involving its 737 Max jet and a pandemic that choked off demand for new planes. (AP Photo/Elaine Thompson, File)
Boeing inks deal for up to 300 737 Max planes with Ryanair

At Boeing’s list prices, the deal would be worth more than $40 billion if Ryanair exercises all the options.

Logo for news use, for stories regarding Washington state government — Olympia, the Legislature and state agencies. No caption necessary. 20220331
Gov. Inslee signs law allowing duplexes, fourplexes

Gov. Jay Inslee on Monday signed a law legalizing duplexes and fourplexes in most neighborhoods in nearly every city in Washington.

The only dinosaur discovered in Washington state was discovered by paleontologists who found a portion of a left femur of a therapod dinosaur at Sucia Island state park in the San Juan Islands. While scientists are unsure exactly what type of therapod the fossil belongs to, evidence suggests it is a Daspletosaurus. The dinosaur has been nicknamed
Suciasaurus rex. This image shows a Daspletosaurus torosus restoration. (Wikipedia)
Suciasaurus rex named Washington state’s official dinosaur

Gov. Jay Inslee has signed a bill designating the Suciasaurus rex as the official dinosaur of the state.

FILE - Proud Boys chairman Enrique Tarrio rallies in Portland, Ore., on Aug. 17, 2019. Tarrio and three other members of the far-right extremist group have been convicted of a plot to attack the U.S. Capitol in a desperate bid to keep Donald Trump in power after Trump lost the 2020 presidential election.  (AP Photo/Noah Berger, File)
Proud Boys’ Tarrio guilty of Jan. 6 seditious conspiracy

Enrique Tarrio and three other members of the far-right extremist group were convicted Thursday of a plot to attack the U.S. Capitol.

Logo for news use, for stories regarding Washington state government — Olympia, the Legislature and state agencies. No caption necessary. 20220331
Washington AG’s office, DSHS fined for evidence withholding

The $200,000 fine is for what a judge called “egregious” and “cavalier” withholding of evidence in an ongoing lawsuit.

A troller fishes in Sitka Sound, Alaska on February 2, 2021. A ruling from a U.S. judge in Seattle could effectively shut down commercial king salmon trolling in Southeast Alaska — a valuable industry that supports some 1,500 fishermen — after a conservation group challenged the harvest as a threat to protected fish and the endangered killer whales that eat them. (James Poulson/Daily Sitka Sentinel via AP)
Ruling might cancel Alaska commercial king salmon season

A ruling from a U.S. judge in Seattle could effectively shut down commercial king salmon trolling in Southeast Alaska.