In this 2017 photo, the Special Commitment Center on McNeil Island is shown from a boat. (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren, file)

In this 2017 photo, the Special Commitment Center on McNeil Island is shown from a boat. (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren, file)

Medical needs rise for aging sex offenders on McNeil Island

As off-island medical trips increase, so has the cost to the state for housing residents.

  • By ALEXIS KRELL The News Tribune
  • Monday, July 23, 2018 9:18am
  • Northwest

By Alexis Krell / The News Tribune

TACOMA — The sexually violent predators of Washington state are getting older.

And serving the medical needs of that aging population, civilly committed to the Special Commitment Center on McNeil Island, means more doctor appointments and the costs.

“They’re growing old with us,” said Sjan Talbot, CEO of the facility, which recently had 218 residents, 130 of them 50 or older. “The average age of offenders right now is 51.6 years.”

The law allowing civil commitment of sex offenders, enacted in 1990, led to an influx of people committed to state custody. Under the law, offenders found to be “sexually violent predators” are sent to the commitment center after finishing their prison sentences.

The facility handles general medical care for offenders, but specialty care — such as cardiology and urology appointments or appointments for MRI and CT scans — happens elsewhere.

That means taking residents to appointments off the island, which lies about 10 miles from the landing near Point Defiance Park.

In July, Talbot said, there were 43 off-campus scheduled medical visits.

As the population ages, the number of off-island trips is increasing. Last year, there were 557 planned medical trips; so far this year there have been 271.

In addition, there are emergency trips, in which a speed boat takes patients from the island to meet an ambulance that gets the resident to an emergency room. In 2017, there were 49 emergency trips; there have been 32 so far this year.

“If we keep up at this pace, we’ll top last year,” Talbot said of the emergency trips.

As off-island medical trips increase, so has the average annual cost to the state for housing residents. It was $153,488 for the 2017 fiscal year, and projected to be $185,136 for the 2018 fiscal year.

Talbot says that increase is due, at least in part, to rising medical costs.

The budget for the 2018 fiscal year is nearly $48.8 million. For the 2019 fiscal year, it’s nearly $49.5 million.

A budget request in 2016 asked for more nursing staff, and more security to help with the off-island appointments.

At the time, security staff were being pulled from the facility to make the trips, which the request said was affecting rehabilitative and habilitative services on the island.

For example, participation in sex-offender treatment was starting to decline in 2016, “in part due to services not being available due to limited security staffing,” the request said.

And in April and May 2016, residents got 65.5 fewer hours in the yard and recreation center than scheduled, because of the limited security staff.

“This reduced access is becoming the norm for residents and is counter therapeutic to their motivation for treatment,” the request said.

A sort of footnote in the request noted that a shortage of security staff also led to increased pilfering of food from the cafeteria, and a subsequent increase in incidents of homemade alcohol from stolen fruit, sugar and bread.

The facility didn’t get the funding it asked for, but Talbot said it’s fixed the problems, by filling vacancies, hiring a pool of on-call staff members and by designating a team of security staff to make the off-island trips.

“We have a crew of (six) guys now that just take residents on and off island for these appointments,” she said.

That means residents aren’t seeing cuts, such as a locked recreation center or yard, Talbot said.

One of the residents taken to appointments off the island is Richard Scott, 71. He made several trips last year and is expecting to make another trip soon.

One trip was for a CT scan to determine why he was having trouble breathing, Scott said. Another was for a test to figure out why he was coughing and having difficulty eating.

Between waiting for the boat and driving to the appointment, the trips make for long days in chains, Scott said.

“They hate it,” he said. “They really do.”

Rachael Seevers, an attorney with Disability Rights Washington, says she’s investigated some of the island’s medical emergencies, and found it can take about an hour to get someone from the facility to a hospital.

“It’s always a challenge getting people medical care in a remote location,” she said. “The island location makes it hard. They’re isolated there.”

Asked about the medical needs of the island, Seevers said the aging residents might see an increased need for nursing assistants to help with daily care — something approaching the level of nursing-home care.

Talbot said one of the facility’s budget requests this year is for additional nursing staff for the unit that houses the most medically needy residents, “to help support our aging population and end-of-life care.”

Seevers seemed wary about the idea of the island being a place for end-of-life care.

“To the extent that they have people in hospice care, I think it’s useful to remember why this facility exists, and what people are supposed to be there,” she said. ” . That there are people on hospice care, to what extent is that what the facility is designed for or intended to be doing?”

Budget requests

Residents can be reviewed annually by the court to check their progress in sex- offender treatment, and the court can order them released to a less restrictive living arrangement.

Seevers said she’d like to see social-worker positions on the island, to help residents plan for release.

“Having someone whose job is to know those resources and be able to work with people on developing discharge plans that are helpful and realistic,” she said.

A social-worker position is also one of the facility’s budget requests this year, Talbot said, to help aging residents with guardianship and power of attorney matters — to clarify who makes medical decisions for them.

They’ve also asked for funding for a medical database.

The island’s medical records system, still done on paper, is also aging.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Northwest

Freightliner eCascadia electric trucks used in a Coca-Cola Bottling fleet are pictured in 2023. (Photo courtesy of Daimler Truck AG)
$126M incentive program for zero-emission trucks nears launch in WA

Transportation is the biggest share of emissions in the state. Advocates are frustrated by how long it’s taking for the program to start.

The Beacon Pacific Village housing complex where Washington Gov. Bob Ferguson announced new proposed housing investments on Thursday, Dec. 18, 2025, in Seattle, Washington. (Photo by Jake Goldstein-Street/Washington State Standard)
Ferguson proposes $244M boost for housing programs

Some of the money will be dedicated to flood recovery. The governor is also starting the process to create a state Department of Housing.

Road damage along U.S. 2 in Tumwater Canyon, in a photo shared by Washington State Department of Transportation on Dec. 16, 2025. (Photo courtesy of WSDOT)
Highway 2 closure across WA’s Cascade mountains expected to last months

Parts of U.S. 2, an important road cutting across Washington’s Cascade mountains,… Continue reading

Masked federal agents arrive to help immigration agents detain immigrants and control protesters June 4 in Chicago. California in September became the first state to ban law enforcement officers from wearing face coverings, in response to immigration raids where federal agents wore masks. (Jamie Kelter Davis/The New York Times)
Ban on police face coverings pitched ahead of WA’s 2026 legislative session

The Trump administration is challenging a similar law passed in California, amid worries over masked immigration agents.

Jsason Phipps of the City of Mount Vernon tightens straps on the flood wall along the Skagit River in downtown Mount Vernon on Thursday. The river is forecast to crest on Friday morning after several days of heavy rain pushed waterways in the region to record levels. (Grant Hindsley/The New York Times)
Record flooding forces rescues across Western Washington

Waterways crested at record levels in several flooded small towns across western… Continue reading

Florida Lt. Gov. Jay Collins, left, participates in the extradition from California of Harjinder Singh, accused of causing a crash that killed three people in Florida. (Photo via Collins’ X account)
WA erred in granting hundreds of commercial driver’s licenses to noncitizens

The issue has flared up after a fatal truck crash in Florida earlier this year.

Police are failing to solve most violent crimes in WA

Over 49,000 incidents remain unsolved since 2022, including murders, rapes and robberies.

A Flock Safety camera on Oct. 28, 2025 in Lynnwood, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Washington lawmakers want to regulate license plate readers

Washington state lawmakers next year hope to rein in law enforcement’s use… Continue reading

Democratic state Rep. Shaun Scott of Seattle (left) is proposing a new payroll tax on large employers in Washington. He took part in a discussion on the state’s tax system during the Budget Matters Summit on Nov. 12, 2025 in Seattle. (Photo courtesy of Washington State Budget and Policy Center)
WA Dems’ latest run at taxing the state’s largest companies

Rep. Shaun Scott’s proposal mirrors an approach Senate Democrats drew up then discarded last session.

Washington Gov. Bob Ferguson appointed Colleen Melody to the state Supreme Court on Nov. 24, 2025. Melody, who leads civil rights division of the state Attorney General’s Office, will assume her seat following the retirement of Justice Mary Yu at the end of the year. (Photo by Jerry Cornfield/Washington State Standard)
Gov. Bob Ferguson makes his pick for WA Supreme Court seat

Colleen Melody, who leads the civil rights division at the state attorney general’s office, will succeed Justice Mary Yu, who is retiring.

The state ferries Klahowya (center right) and Hyak (left center) are taking up valuable space at the Eagle Harbor maintenance yard of Washington State Ferries. Both retired ferries have been for sale for more than four years. (Photo by Tom Banse for Washington State Standard)
For sale: Two retired state ferries. Dreamers need not apply

The vessels are lingering on the market as Washington State Ferries scrutinizes potential buyers. Past purchases haven’t always ended well.

Washington began selling a specialty plate honoring Pickleball on Nov. 19, 2025. This is a sample of a personalized plate. (Seattle Metro Pickleball Association)
It’s an ace. Pickleball gets its own Washington license plate

The design celebrates the state’s official sport. Other new plate designs are on the way.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.