Washington asks state high court to uphold tax on big banks

The 1.2% business and occupation surtax applies to banks that make more than $1 billion in annual profits.

By Gene Johnson / Associated Press

SEATTLE — The Washington Attorney General’s Office on Tuesday asked the state Supreme Court to uphold a new tax on big banks, a year after a lower court judge sided with the industry in finding it unconstitutional.

The 1.2% business and occupation surtax — a tax added on top of other taxes — was passed by the Legislature in 2019. It applies to banks that make more than $1 billion in annual profits, but it is assessed only on their economic activity in Washington state.

Lawmakers said they designed the measure, along with a similar surtax on big tech companies, to begin to fix Washington’s regressive tax system by raising revenue from businesses most able to pay.

But the Washington Banking Association and the American Banking Association sued. The industry’s attorneys, including former Washington Attorney General Rob McKenna, said the tax discriminates against interstate commerce — in violation of the U.S. Constitution, which gives Congress the right to regulate trade among the states and generally bars the states from hindering interstate commerce.

McKenna is also representing groups suing over Washington’s just-inked capital gains tax, another effort by Democrats in Olympia to make the state’s taxation more progressive.

McKenna told the justices that of the 153 financial institutions that had to pay the tax during the first quarter of 2020, 150 were based out of state. Out-of-state entities paid more than 99.7% of the $34 million collected during that period, he said.

“The surtax targets out-of-state banks that participate in interstate commerce,” McKenna said. Referring to comments made by then-Seattle Democratic Rep. Gael Tarleton, he added: “Legislators were assured by the bill’s sponsor on the floor … that only out-of-state banks would pay it.”

King County Superior Court Judge Marshall Ferguson sided with the banks last May, ruling that while the bill had a discriminatory effect on interstate commerce, even though as written it would apply equally to big banks based in Washington state or outside it.

Washington Solicitor General Noah Purcell told the justices such reasoning would lead to absurd conclusions. He gave this example: If states couldn’t approve taxes that are written neutrally but which wind up affecting more out-of-state businesses than in-state ones, Washington wouldn’t be able to tax tobacco.

“In-state entities and out-of-state entities are treated exactly the same, depending on their profit,” Purcell said. “Any bank with less than a billion dollars in profit can operate here without owing the surtax, no matter where they’re based.”

The case drew a friend-of-the-court brief from labor and community activists, including the Washington Black Lives Matter Alliance, who argued that the tax was a legitimate way for lawmakers to target Washington’s tax system, which disproportionately burdens low-income people. The state’s middle class and poor residents pay two to six times as much of their income in taxes as the wealthy do, lawmakers found.

The justices did not say when they would rule.

Talk to us

More in Northwest

COVID-19 contact tracers make phone calls and log potential exposures at the Umatilla County Public Health center in Pendleton, Ore., on Tuesday, July 14, 2020. In tiny Umatilla County in northeastern Oregon, contact tracers work out of a converted jail to try to stem the spread of COVID-19 as new cases surge in the rural West and elsewhere. (AP Photo/Ben Lonergan)
COVID-19 surge straining Eastern Oregon hospitals

Umatilla County has one of the lowest vaccination rates in Oregon, according to the CDC.

A brief history of rats in the Puget Sound region

The adaptable scavengers can sustain themselves by exploiting the sloppy habits of people.

A magnitude 8.2 earthquake hit near the Alaska Peninsula, west of Kodiak. (U.S. Geological Survey)
Tsunami watch issued for Hawaii after 8.2M quake hits Alaska

The U.S. Geological Survey said the temblor hit 56 miles east southeast of Perryville, Alaska.

Madroneagle (Wally Gudgell/Windermere)
Oprah Winfrey sells her Orcas Island estate for $14 million

The estate known as Madroneagle overlooks the East Sound and includes a four-bedroom, five-bath home.

King County Executive Dow Constantine signs an order July 28 to restart inquests into deaths that involved police officers. COURTESY PHOTO, King County
King County to restart inquests into killings by police

The cases include shootings by Kent, Auburn, Federal Way and Kirkland officers.

In this Sept. 2017, photo made with a drone, a young resident killer whale chases a chinook salmon in the Salish Sea near San Juan Island, Wash. The photo, made under a National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS) permit, which gives researchers permission to approach the animals, was made in collaboration with NOAA Fisheries/Southwest Fisheries Science Center, SR3 Sealife Response, Rehabilitation, and Research and the Vancouver Aquarium's Coastal Ocean Research Institute. Endangered Puget Sound orcas that feed on chinook salmon face more competition from seals, sea lions and other killer whales than from commercial and recreational fishermen, a new study finds. (John Durban/NOAA Fisheries/Southwest Fisheries Science Center via AP)
Where are the orcas? Looking for food, researchers say

The endangered Southern Resident whales have been seen only one day in the Salish Sea this season.

Starting Jan. 1, 2025, people who need assistance with at least three “activities of daily living” can tap into the WA Cares Fund to pay for things like in-home care, home modifications and rides to the doctor. (Washington State Department of Social & Health Services)
Deadline coming on long-term care: private or state plan?

Washington workers will pay a premium of 0.58% of total pay per paycheck.

Deception Pass Bridge (Emily Gilbert / Whidbey News file)
Suicides from Deception Pass Bridge renew calls for barriers

Meanwhile, an emergency phone that calls 911 was installed on the west side of the bridge in 2018.

Detectives are investigating after a man was shot and killed Sunday night outside an apartment building in Seattle's Lake City neighborhood. (Seattle Police Department)
Spate of shootings across Seattle kill 4 in 24-hour period

More than 200 people in King County have been killed or wounded by gunfire so far this year.

Most Read