Cantwell amendment is key

If the fiscal train wreck Medicare is chugging toward isn’t prevented, none of the health-care reform ideas currently under debate will matter. Without dramatic action now to curb costs, the Medicare trust fund could be exhausted in a decade. Today’s health-care challenges will seem trivial in comparison.

Washington Sen. Maria Cantwell, along with health-care providers here and in several other states, has long argued that an essential part of the solution is changing the way Medicare pays providers. Cantwell, a member of the Senate Finance Committee, has gotten such an amendment into the health-care bill that panel is currently writing. The legislation could move to the Senate floor next week.

The importance of Cantwell’s amendment to the success of any health-care overhaul — and to the long-term survival of our health-care system — would be hard to overstate.

It would fundamentally change the flawed reimbursement rate formula that has long penalized doctors and hospitals here and in other states that deliver efficient, cost-effective care. Rather than rewarding the quality of care, it rewards the quantity of billable procedures. Providers are financially better off treating patients after they’re sick, because they get paid for each visit, each test, each surgery. The financial incentive, perversely, doesn’t lie in keeping seniors healthy in the first place.

That not only results in huge waste — Cantwell says Medicare currently wastes $120 billion a year, partly because of the flawed payment structure — is creates geographic disparities in what providers are paid. In Washington, some providers won’t see new Medicare patients because they lose too much money on them.

Unlike other points in the health-care debate, this one isn’t drawn along partisan lines. Cantwell and 27 other senators — including six Republicans and independent Joe Lieberman — wrote to President Obama earlier this month urging the Medicare payment change. All six senators from the Pacific Northwest signed the letter.

Cantwell’s amendment also has the enthusiastic backing of leading-edge providers such as The Everett Clinic, Virginia Mason Medical Center and The Mayo Clinic. They recognize it will result in more efficient, better coordinated and higher quality care for seniors.

Getting more Americans insured, and eliminating pre-existing conditions as a barrier to coverage, requires getting health-care costs under control. It’s the crux of the entire debate.

If we’re going to have health-care reform that truly works, now and for future generations, Cantwell’s amendment must be part of the final package.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

Pedestrians using umbrellas, some Washingtonians use them, as they cross Colby Avenue under pouring rain on Tuesday, Nov. 28, 2017 in Everett, Wa. The forecast through Saturday is cloudy with rain through Saturday. (Andy Bronson / The Herald)
Editorial: Speed limit reductions a good start on safety

Everett is reducing speed limits for two streets; more should follow to save pedestrian lives.

September 3, 2025: Contagious Infections
Editorial cartoons for Thursday, Aug. 4

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Thanks for coverage of local governments use of AI

I really enjoyed reading the recent article about the use of artificial… Continue reading

Everett School Board, Pos. 3: Clarke best for special ed needs

Respect Public Schools-Washington strongly supports Tom Clarke in the run for the… Continue reading

Herald reporters deserve fair wage, no quota

The demands of The Herald’s newsroom staff to ratify an employment contract… Continue reading

Stephens: Mass migration has been undoing of liberal democracy

By not seeking the consent of the governed on immigration, the West has invited the threat of populism.

Comment: America’s enemies thrilled by Trump’s war on expertise

An administration that favors fealty over experience is surrendering the nation’s security advantage.

Gov. Bob Ferguson and Rep. Rick Larsen talk during a listening session with with community leaders and families addressing the recent spending bill U.S. Congress enacted that cut Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program funding by 20% on Thursday, Aug. 21, 2025 in Lynnwood, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Editorial: Work to replace what was taken from those in need

The state and local communities will have to ensure food security after federal SNAP and other cuts.

Robotic hand playing hopscotch on a keyboard. Artifical intelligence, text generators, ai and job issues concept. Vector illustration.
Editorial: Keep a mindful eye on government use of AI chatbots

A public media report on government use of chatbots, including by Everett, calls for sound guidelines.

Gov. Bob Ferguson responds to U.S. Attorney General Pam Bondi's demands that the state end so-called sanctuary policies. (Office of Governor of Washington)
Editorial: Governor’s reasoned defiance to Bondi’s ICE demands

In the face of threats, the 10th Amendment protects a state law on law enforcement cooperation.

toon
Editorial cartoons for Wednesday, Sept. 3

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Welch: Blame a math mismatch for county’s budget deficit

The county promised more in pay than revenues now allow. It’s a problem it can avoid in the future.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.