Columnist’s comparisons of 9-11 and covid are mistaken

Megan McArdle’s recent column compared Americans’ reactions to the 9-11 attacks and the covid-19 pandemic as similar. She proposes the do-nothing reactions from many Americans in both cases was “normalcy bias” and should be blameless.

The twin tower attacks in 2001 were immediate. Everybody regardless of politics was shocked by 9-11 attacks. Not one American felt that we should just sit around and do nothing about it, including President Bush!

The pandemic in contrast wasn’t seen as an immediate threat. People just went about their normal lives with it in the background. It was also completely dismissed by Trump as “fake news.” As the threat became obvious, it was again dismissed by the president prompting his followers to do the same. This is the same president who dissolved the pandemic team.

Many did not dismiss this threat. We actually listened to the scientists desperately trying to sound the alarm bell. We didn’t want it to be real, but knew it was! Once mask effectiveness was established Trump and his supporters made this a political issue. Many like me have worn masks and have taken social distancing measures seriously as an attempt to protect other fellow Americans.

Here’s just another attempt from Megan McArdle to even out the blame between Democrats and Republicans. History will show that Trump and his followers will bear the brunt of responsibility for the SNAFU we are in now.

David Winquist

Marysville

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

People listen as Rick Steves announces he has purchased the Jean Kim Foundation Hygiene Center property so the center can stay open on Wednesday, Dec. 17, 2025 in Lynnwood, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Editorial: The message in philanthropic gifts large and small

Travel advocate Rick Steves is known for his philanthropy but sees a larger public responsibility.

Charlie Brown and his little pals from the “Peanuts” gallery will gather once again for the special “A Charlie Brown Christmas,” and Apple TV+ is gifting non-subscribers with a free viewing from Dec. 22 through 25.
Comment: Finding wisdom and hope in ‘A Charlie Brown Christmas’

A 60-year-old cartoon and its melancholic soundtrack got our mixed-up feelings right about the holidays.

Winter in a peasant village, painted by the Limbourg brothers and published in the medieval illuminated manuscript ‘Très Riches Heures du Duc de Berry.’ Pierce Archive LLC/Buyenlarge via Getty Images
Comment: Medieval peasants may have enjoyed holidays more than you

Life wasn’t as bleak as many imagine, and Christmas celebrations with food and drink lasted months.

Comment: What would surprise Jesus about Christmas in 2025

A conversation with New Testament scholar Bart Ehrman, author of ‘Love Thy Stranger.’

Comment: A case for childlike wonder in our grown-up world

The Elf on the Shelf isn’t enchanted, of course, but what do we lose in telling ourselves it can’t be?

Comment: Making space at our tables at holidays and all days

Efforts for DEI don’t have to water down celebrations. They are an opportunity to highlight all cultures.

Welch: State’s climate act failing to deliver on promises

The law was sold, in part, on building resilience against flooding. How has that worked out?

Douthat: Rubio, quietly, is influencing Trump’s foreign policy

And that influence speaks to his ability to serve Trump while playing his own long game.

Harrop: Fight or flight: The response of two GOP congresswomen

Both Liz Cheney and Marjorie Taylor Greene objected to Trump. One ran and lost. The other just ran.

Comment: It’s not too late to protect against risk of flu

Cases of flu are growing and a new strain may be more infectious than viruses in past years.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.