Comment: Leave working forests to their vital climate work

State forests managed for timber are more effective in reducing carbon emissions than locking them away.

By Nick Smith / For The Herald

Actively managing Washington’s state trust lands and using locally sourced wood is a far better climate solution than leaving forests unmanaged. It is also better than “leasing” these public lands to private interests so faraway polluters can keep polluting through artificial carbon credit schemes.

The ongoing campaign to shut down these public working forests ignores the fact that timber harvesting is already prohibited on roughly half of all state trust lands in Western Washington. Millions of acres of federally owned lands in the state are also left unmanaged. These “protected” lands have abundant old growth and mature stands, but also tend to be unnaturally overstocked and vulnerable to carbon-emitting wildfires, insects and disease that increase tree mortality and decay.

On the half of state trust lands that are available for timber harvest, we can make Washington-made wood products that lock in carbon for generations, while supporting thousands of family-wage jobs across the state. When we’re managing forests, we’re reducing wildfire risks while ensuring clean air, water and recreational opportunities.

ADVERTISEMENT
0 seconds of 0 secondsVolume 0%
Press shift question mark to access a list of keyboard shortcuts
00:00
00:00
00:00
 

Further, state trust lands are managed under the strictest environmental standards in the nation. And for every one tree that’s harvested, three are replanted, and those young trees will sequester carbon at high rates for decades. Under the state constitution, timber from these lands generate nearly $200 million in revenue for public schools, public safety, health care services, and much more. These are all benefits that carbon credits and preservationist policies simply can’t provide.

When state trust lands are set aside from timber harvest, proponents seem to assume consumers and businesses stop using wood or constructing buildings. That is not the case. If consumers and business are not using wood that’s grown, harvested and made here in Washington, we experience “leakage” effects, such as the importing of wood products from other countries, and “substitution” effects where more carbon-intensive projects, including concrete and steel are used instead of wood. These factors can’t be disregarded in the pursuit of a narrow political agenda.

At our request, researchers at the Consortium for Research on Renewable Industrial Materials (CORRIM) and the University of Washington’s Center for International Trade in Forest Products used data from a timber sale in Jefferson County and publicly available U.S. Forest Service Forest Inventory and Analysis (FIA) data to conduct a full carbon accounting of the timber sale using established life-cycle assessment data on forestry, forest operations, and manufacturing of products that were produced from that sale.

After accounting for substitution and leakage, the study found that for every acre of state trust lands that are harvested to produce carbon-storing wood products, an additional 11.71 metric tons of carbon dioxide are stored or offset in the same year, compared to a no-harvest scenario.

This means that renewable timber harvests and the use of wood products from state trust lands avoids more than 128,000 metric tons of carbon emissions each year, which is the equivalent of removing 28,000 gasoline vehicles from the road. Using this Washington-made wood doesn’t simply offset emissions, as carbon credit schemes claim to do, but result in real net reductions.

Timber from state trust lands offer a strong incentive to use Washington wood over more energy-intensive materials. The CORRIM study data suggests that using softwood lumber for framing instead of steel avoids 17 kilograms of carbon emissions per square meter.

Washington has millions of acres of unmanaged publicly owned forests, at the same time the state is failing to achieve its own ambitious carbon-reduction goals, despite the higher fuel costs and millions of dollars generated under the Climate Commitment Act. The state will fail to achieve meaningful climate benefits by shutting down more working forests, stopping the production of Washington-made wood products, nor selling carbon credits on public lands to faraway polluters.

Nick Smith is public affairs director for the American Forest Resource Council, representing Washington’s forest sector that depends on timber management on state Department of Natural Resources trust lands.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

South County Fire and Rescue crews responded after a dump truck crashed into an Edmonds home and knocked out power lines last September. (Courtesy of South County Fire)
Editorial: Edmonds voters, study up on fire district vote

Voters need to weigh issues of taxes, service and representation before casting their ballots.

toon
Editorial cartoons for Tuesday, April 8

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Comment: The struggle to guide masculinity of boys, young men

Boys will always be boys, but now they’re dealing with indifference on one side and toxic messages on the other.

Appreciate honesty, compassion in Sid Schwab’s column

I have admired the unique honesty of Sid Schwab’s Herald column for… Continue reading

Act to end the takeover of our democracy

I believe that the assault on our government and the people of… Continue reading

Clear that Trump doesn’t care about people

I get tired of President Trump continuing to put forth that he… Continue reading

Save funding for health care for low-income families

The fact that the Washington state legislature and Congress are considering cuts… Continue reading

The Washington state Capitol building in February. (Bill Lucia / Washington State Standard)
Editorial: Lawmakers puzzle over taxes, cuts and consequences

With the governor balking at one tax proposal, lawmakers look for balance among cuts and revenue.

King County Executive Dow Constantine and Senator Maria Cantwell walk through the Lynnwood Center Station to board the 12:30 pm train during the Lynnwood 1 Line extension opening celebrations on Friday, Aug. 30, 2024 in Lynnwood, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Editorial: Transit board, new CEO have much to deliver

Sound Transit’s board hired one of its own as chief. The stakes for success are high for all involved.

toon
Editorial cartoons for Monday, April 7

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Everett mayor Cassie Franklin delivers her State of the City address on Friday, March 28 in Everett, Washington. (Will Geschke / The Herald)
Editorial: The state of Everett amid the state of play

In her state of the city speech, Mayor Cassie Franklin makes the case for optimism amid dark clouds.

Brooks: Trump isn’t offering liberation, but stagnation

His tariffs and more are are walling us off from the crossroads of cultures and ideas that made us great.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.