Comment: Using forests for carbon credits may defeat purpose

By blocking some state forests from timber production, the project limits an effective climate tool.

By Nick Smith / For The Herald

Everyone agrees Washington’s forests are key to helping the state reach its climate goals. Thanks to the continuous cycle of forestry, which includes the planting, growing, harvesting and manufacturing of wood products, our working forests already achieve net-zero carbon emissions. They also support thousands of green jobs and prevent the conversion of forests to non-forests.

Unfortunately, the Department of Natural Resources’ new carbon-offset project disregards international consensus around forestry and wood products. It may have the unintended consequence of enlarging the state’s carbon footprint, because it discourages harvest of Washington-grown wood. This effectively promotes wood imports and greater use of concrete and steel.

Ultimately, it will be rural communities that pay the price for a policy that will have a negligible impact on global greenhouse gas emissions, while providing a fraction of the revenue for public services.

The DNR manages 2.2 million acres of public working forests known as state trust lands to harvest timber and provide revenues for defined beneficiaries including schools, counties, fire districts, ports, hospitals and other community service providers. Every year, sustainable timber harvests on these working forests generate nearly $200 million annually for public services.

As working forests, these lands are managed under modern forest practice rules and a State Lands Habitat Conservation Plan (HCP) that is supposed to ensure a continuous timber supply, while also providing for clean water, habitat for wildlife and recreational opportunities. All of these policies were developed through a public process.

As a result, nearly half of DNR trust lands in Western Washington are no longer available for sustainable timber management because of conservation plans and past decisions to protect old and mature trees. These policies promised to provide certainty for the continuous management of the remaining forest lands.

DNR’s carbon project was not developed through a public process. There are many unanswered questions of how it will work, whether it will lead to actual carbon emission reductions, and how it will impact state trust land beneficiaries and the rural communities that are likely to be impacted through reduced jobs, economic activity and access to public services.

The Herald’s April 12 editorial likened the project to getting “an oil refinery, for example, to pay to leave a forest standing to do its work for the climate and fund schools and more at the same time.”

This political decision presumably benefits the oil refinery because it maintains the status quo and allows the refinery to continue doing its business. But it is troublesome for those Washington companies that need wood from these working forests to make the only building material that is renewable, requires fewer fossil fuels (oil) to produce, and one that actually stores carbon.

Whether we are producing cross-laminated timber or traditional lumber, Washington state needs a forest sector with viable logging and milling capacity to remain competitive, provide affordable wood products and create family-wage jobs in rural communities. With timber volume on state trust lands already in decline, further reducing timber harvest puts this industry and the jobs at risk.

Without a strong forest sector, Washington loses its leadership in green building and sustainable forestry. We lose our ability to make Washington-grown wood products, treat at-risk forests and we increase our carbon footprint by replacing these products with those produced from other countries that do not share our high environmental standards.

The DNR carbon project may seem like a political winner, but it fails to take the long view toward solutions that are already working to sequester and store carbon, while providing green jobs as well as economic activity and revenues for public schools and community services.

Nick Smith is Public Affairs Director for the American Forest Resource Council, representing Washington’s forest sector that depends on timber management on DNR state trust lands.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

toon
Editorial cartoons for Monday, July 7

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

A Volunteers of America Western Washington crisis counselor talks with somebody on the phone Thursday, July 28, 2022, in at the VOA Behavioral Health Crisis Call Center in Everett, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Editorial: Dire results will follow end of LGBTQ+ crisis line

The Trump administration will end funding for a 988 line that serves youths in the LGBTQ+ community.

Comment: Supreme Court’s majority is picking its battles

If a constitutional crisis with Trump must happen, the chief justice wants it on his terms.

Saunders: Combs’ mixed verdict shows perils of over-charging

Granted, the hip-hop mogul is a dirtbag, but prosecutors reached too far to send him to prison.

Comment: RFK Jr.’s vaccine panel turns misinformation into policy

The new CDC panel’s railroading of a decision to pull a flu vaccine foreshadows future unsound decisions.

FILE — The journalist Bill Moyers previews an upcoming broadcast with staffers in New York, in March 2001. Moyers, who served as chief spokesman for President Lyndon Johnson during the American military buildup in Vietnam and then went on to a long and celebrated career as a broadcast journalist, returning repeatedly to the subject of the corruption of American democracy by money and power, died in Manhattan on June 26, 2025. He was 91. (Don Hogan Charles/The New York Times)
Comment: Bill Moyers and the power of journalism

His reporting and interviews strengthened democracy by connecting Americans to ideas and each other.

Brooks: AI can’t help students learn to think; it thinks for them

A new study shows deeper learning for those who wrote essays unassisted by large language models.

Do we have to fix Congress to get them to act on Social Security?

Thanks to The Herald Editorial Board for weighing in (probably not for… Continue reading

toon
Editorial: Using discourse to get to common ground

A Building Bridges panel discussion heard from lawmakers and students on disagreeing agreeably.

Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) speaks during a news conference at the U.S. Capitol on Friday, June 27, 2025. The sweeping measure Senate Republican leaders hope to push through has many unpopular elements that they despise. But they face a political reckoning on taxes and the scorn of the president if they fail to pass it. (Kent Nishimura/The New York Times)
Editorial: GOP should heed all-caps message on tax policy bill

Trading cuts to Medicaid and more for tax cuts for the wealthy may have consequences for Republicans.

Alaina Livingston, a 4th grade teacher at Silver Furs Elementary, receives her Johnson & Johnson COVID-19 vaccine at a vaccination clinic for Everett School District teachers and staff at Evergreen Middle School on Saturday, March 6, 2021 in Everett, Wa. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Editorial: RFK Jr., CDC panel pose threat to vaccine access

Pharmacies following newly changed CDC guidelines may restrict access to vaccines for some patients.

Comment: Keep county’s public lands in the public’s hands

Now pulled from consideration, the potential sale threatened the county’s resources and environment.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.