Commentary: Freeze on rent might chill local economies

Unpaid rent means repairs can’t be made and employees and taxes can’t be paid, passing on the harm.

By Robert Pinnegar / The Washington Post

The number of Americans who have filed unemployment claims continues to increase as many U.S. businesses remain closed to prevent the spread of the novel coronavirus. This has made it difficult for many people to pay even their most essential bills and expenses, including rent.

As we wrestle with these challenges as a nation, consider the components of a rent payment and how it is used, how it affects residents’ experience and quality of housing, and how this translates to the broader economy. Some may point to not paying rent as the solution, but unpaid rent causes a long-term ripple effect in the economy with consequences for everyone. A better option is to explore practical solutions that sustain local economies and provide relief to renters and to owners and operators of rental housing.

There is a misconception that rent payments line the pockets of wealthy landlords. But rent is used to keep buildings operating on a day-to-day basis and provides economic support to communities.

On the basis of analysis of data from the National Apartment Association, the U.S. Census Bureau, Real Capital Analytics, the Institute of Real Estate Management, and financial reports from housing providers across the country, here’s the average allocation for $1 of rent:

Approximately 39 cents of every $1 of a rent payment goes to pay the property’s mortgage. While mortgage forbearance has been proposed to provide relief for owners and residents, the Cares Act only grants forbearance to government-backed mortgages, leaving many property owners without relief. More than half of housing providers are backed by private lenders. This puts property owners — and, by extension, their residents — in a tight and dangerous spot when the bill is due.

Fourteen cents is deducted for property taxes. That money funds schools and teachers, police, firefighters and other essential services on which all community members rely.

After that, approximately 27 cents covers payroll expenses, providing jobs to the people who keep the apartment community running, and ongoing maintenance, utilities and insurance.

Ten cents is allocated for capital improvements and major repairs. This includes efforts such as replacing the HVAC system, roof repair and other projects that help to ensure safety for apartment residents.

Only 9 cents is returned to the owner. The mom-and-pop landlords who own nearly half of the nation’s rental housing units rely on that for their livelihoods. Often, that revenue is further divided and distributed to investors, who also fund public pensions and 401(k)s for millions of Americans. According to Nareit, an association of companies that own or finance real estate investments, nearly $800 billion of pension, endowment and foundation funds are invested in commercial and residential real estate. In 2019, residential real estate made up 15 percent of real estate investment trusts’ funds. Other mutual funds and retirement plans also are invested in real estate investment trusts and publicly traded owners. Many Americans are invested in apartment buildings via their retirement funds, so it has an effect on them in ways they may not realize.

Every product, every service and every expense fuels our economy. While the effect of rent payments may seem less tangible, consider if we went into the grocery store to pick up food and left without paying. That loss would affect the store’s ability to pay its suppliers and its employees, disrupting the food supply chain and driving up prices for others. In turn, that would affect the cleanliness of the store and the quality of the food, among other issues. The same is true when rent goes unpaid. It affects businesses, jobs, state budgets, retirement accounts, essential community services and so much more.

In this time, when fear about coronavirus seems to permeate every sphere of our lives, communication and empathy are more important than ever.

Those who can pay rent should do so. Renters who are struggling financially should contact their property managers to explain their concerns; and vice versa. Renters are hurting, but so are owners, property managers, maintenance technicians and the millions of individuals and families with a stake in rental housing. There may not be a perfect solution, and we don’t know how long this crisis or the fallout will last, but the more people communicate their needs, the more communities can understand and support one another, and preserve and rebuild our economy for the future.

Robert Pinnegar is the president and chief executive of the National Apartment Association.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

toon
Editorial cartoons for Sunday, Oct. 12

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

2024 Presidential Election Day Symbolic Elements.
Editorial: Selecting county charter review panel fundamental

Voters’ picks of three members of the panel will help determine what amendments they see next fall.

The marble statue depicting “The Authority of Law” is visible outside the Supreme Court in Washington on Monday, Oct. 6, 2025. President Donald Trump’s policies will have an even more central role in the Supreme Court term that begins on Monday. (Tierney L. Cross/The New York Times)
Comment: Supreme Court poised to expand the president’s powers

The current term could see the overturn of precedents that provided a check against a unitary executive.

Humans caused climate crisis, and they can stop it

Our weather is changing before our eyes. Our planet is heating up… Continue reading

WM brings recycling basics to class

School is back in session, and so is the environmental education and… Continue reading

Everett council, Dist. 2: Rhyne delivers for district, city

My wife and I have lived in the Lowell neighborhood of Everett… Continue reading

Charlie Kirk was opposite of hater

We thank Nate Nehring for his recent commentary (“Thoughts on prayers and… Continue reading

Don’t put conditions on FEMA disaster preparation grants

As Washington braces for another season of floods and wildfires, the Federal… Continue reading

2024 Presidential Election Day Symbolic Elements.
Editorial: Frizzell best choice for diverse, growing Lynnwood

City council member Hurst has legitimate financial concerns, but Frizzell remains a skilled leader.

2024 Presidential Election Day Symbolic Elements.
Editorial: Mata, Leutwyler for Lynnwood council seats

With the city facing a budget crisis, voters will determine who serves on four council seats.

toon
Editorial cartoons for Saturday, Oct. 11

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Comment: AI can be health care boon; it needs national policy

The technology offers great promise but must have predictable and consistent policy guidance.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.