Cutting band would be harmful to all

I’m a ninth-grade band student at Arlington High School, and am proud to be part of such a great program. We are becoming one of the best bands in the region, with strong concert, jazz, marching and pep programs.

However, there are proposals to make huge cuts to the elementary and middle school band programs. We cannot afford to lose that time if the AHS program is going to continue on the level it is. These cuts are being made to accommodate the new middle school and WASL preperation. I would like to focus on the latter.

Cutting band by any amount is going to hurt kids who are behind, along with those who are ahead. For the first group, band may be an outlet, a chance to get away from the frustration that comes with other classes. Not to mention the countless studies that show band improves school work. To give you a small example: The top three countries for science ability among 14-year-olds are Hungary, the Netherlands and Japan. Music education is mandatory K-12 in all three. St. Augustine Bronx Elementary almost failed as a school in 1984. They then implemented a music program and now 90 percent are reading at or above grade level.

What about the kids who are ahead and don’t need the relentless assault of learning the same thing over and over again for a test they’re already getting fours on? If they don’t have something to challenge themselves, they’ll just ignore their other classes and scores will drop.

When you throw in the ironic fact that the No Child Left Behind act labels arts a “core academic subject,” it’s ridiculous that band is being considered for cuts.

Amy Smith

Arlington

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

toon
Editorial cartoons for Tuesday, Nov. 25

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Story Corps
Editorial: Political debate isn’t on Thanksgiving menu for most

A better option for table talk are family stories. Share them with the Great Thanksgiving Listen.

Comment: Two ideas that could encourage housing construction

Give all residents of cities that build housing a rebate and ramp up construction of modular homes.

Douthat: Trump’s numbers down again; a rebound isn’t certain

None of Trump’s policies can deliver a quick fix that will impress Americans concerned for their future.

Honks of approval on I-5 for No Kings protest

No Kings protests Honks of approval on I-5 Thanks to everyone who… Continue reading

Comment: Not even Trump’s negotiators can agree on Ukraine plan

A foreign policy of schisms, confusion, arbitrariness threatens peace in Ukraine and elsewhere.

toon
Editorial cartoons for Monday, Nov. 24

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Comment: Can Trump stand down over Venezuela or is die cast?

Sending warships to the Caribbean seemed to signal a commitment to action, yet Trump has options.

Brooks: We’ve given politics over to chasing conspiracies

Meanwhile, both parties look to capitalize, while ignoring the core problems and coming challenges.

Comment: GOP can blame itself for Texas redistricting loss

A letter from the DOJ with factual, legal and typographical errors doomed the case before an appeals court.

Comment: Cheaper coffee, tomatoes small potatoes against inflation

The tariff rollbacks for some items make sense, but broader action is needed by Trump and Congress.

Comment: Why posecution of the 2020 ‘fake electors’ scams matters

If it seems like old news, consider that excusing election fraud only encourages it in the future.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.